Cops and Kids

About a year ago, Eric Smith, 19, of the HS for the Liberal Arts, was on a class trip when he was stopped by two cops.
“They tried to make me take all my stuff out of my bag, just so that they could check it out,” he said.
Eric tried to find out why they were harassing him, but they just kept telling him to empty his bag. Then his teacher came up and explained that they were on a school trip and the class continued on. “They just go around telling us what to do,” said Eric, who to this day remembers the embarrassment he felt in that situation.
Eric isn’t the only teenager who feels disrespected or threatened by the police. “They come ’round here thinkin’ they’re the man, and try to tell me where to go and what to do,” said Roberto, 18, who I found hanging out in front of my building. To Roberto, they’re just “a bunch of fat n-gas, looking to kick some ass.”
Teenagers I spoke to around the city said they were wary of the police and complained that they or people close to them had had bad, sometimes brutal, experiences. Alex Stephen, 16, of Brooklyn Tech HS, said her cousin was beaten up by cops in 1989. Pedro Nieves, 19, said he and his friend were stopped by police and when his friend couldn’t show them identification they arrested him because they claimed he looked like a suspect in a robbery.
Scary Cops
Incidents like these make many young people mistrustful, even afraid, of cops. Though her worst experiences with the police have been when they’ve told her and her friends to move along, Jessica Jenkins, 20, of City College, says there are times when a person can’t help but look at a cop and get scared. “Like if you was in an alley, and going somewhere, when you see a cop car, you can feel something jump inside of you,” she explained.
“Historically, it’s been an adversarial relationship,” said Lt. Arthur Doyle, who recently retired as commanding officer of the Police Department’s Youth Services Division.
One of the reasons for this, he feels, is that the police are the ones people call to report disorderly conduct: “Get off the corner,” “Turn that music down,” “Where’s your bus pass?” and things like that. And, according to Doyle, teens “don’t always see what they’re doing as disorderly” so they end up feeling picked on.
Teens as Potential Criminals
When it comes to police suspicion towards teens, Doyle says it comes about “the same way all prejudices are formed.” Much of the crime that’s committed in this city, he explained, is committed by young people, and unfortunately, when officers “see the same people” repeatedly breaking the law, “you form an opinion that all teenagers are up to something.” But he stressed that “that’s not an opinion that’s shared by all officers.”
While all cops may not be prejudiced against us, “too many police officers view all teens as possible criminals,” said Richie Perez of the National Congress for Puerto Rican Rights, an organization that works to protect and defend the rights of the Puerto Rican people and other minority groups. “They don’t respect the rights of young people.”
Perez says the police regularly violate young people’s rights through illegal searches and arbitrary commands, like “I don’t want you waiting at this train station, take the next train and get out of here.”
One reason for this kind of misconduct is the young age of many officers. In spite of their training, Doyle says that “people that age often don’t have the life experience” to be able to handle the situations they face on the street.
Outsiders in the Hood
But regardless of how old they are or how many years they’ve been on the force, Perez says that, “some officers don’t live in the city and know nothing of the communities [they patrol].” He thinks they often have racist attitudes toward those communities and are taught in the police academy that “it’s us against the world.” All of this makes them view the communities and teenagers they are supposed to be serving as the enemy.
Doyle agrees that many of these problems exist, but feels it’s not something unique to the police. “If you were brought up to disrespect people,” he said, “you’re going to disrespect [them] no matter what profession you go into.”
As for the infamous “blue wall of silence,” where cops look the other way while other cops break the rules or unofficially punish the ones who speak up about it, Doyle says that’s something that “exists in almost any profession.”
But Perez says that policework isn’t just any profession. “They have one of the most difficult jobs in society,” he explained. Because we allow them to carry guns and make life and death decisions, Perez feels society has a responsibility to monitor their activities closely and punish them severely when they abuse their authority.
A Matter of Life and Death
When we fail in that responsibility, it can often have consequences far beyond people getting their feelings hurt. According to Perez, after the Puerto Rican Day parade in June, 1995, one Bushwick teenager was allegedly punched in the face by a cop, and another was maced while already in handcuffs.
And in 1995, New York City detectives shot robbery suspects Anthony Rosario, 18, and 21-year-old Hilton Vega, 22 times. Medical experts say they appear to have been shot while lying face down on the floor and the case is still under investigation.
Perez feels that as long as cops don’t get punished even for the most severe forms of misconduct, their attitudes are unlikely to change. He also believes there should be a law that requires police officers to live within the city limits and that they should receive better education about the cultures of the communities they serve.
Doyle agrees that police officers who break the law should be treated like any other law breaker. But he’s not enthusiastic about the value of special training designed to make police more sensitive to the feelings of people in the community. “Coursework and streetwork are different,” he said.
Cops from the Community Make a Difference
For him, the solution lies in recruitment of more minority officers. “People from some backgrounds have a certain understanding which can take the tension out of the situation,” he said. Doyle, who is Black and grew up in the South Bronx, gave the example of seeing young Black males “acting macho.” “I can identify with that,” he said, explaining that he feels he is often in a better position to judge when a Black teenager’s rowdy behavior and tough talk is just that and when it is something potentially dangerous or criminal.
As for the use of force, Doyle said that an officer who’s comfortable in the community is less likely to feel threatened or overreact to a teenager’s behavior.
A Tighter Leash
Like Perez, my neighbor Roberto feels the mayor ought to “put a tight leash on [police] and make sure [they behave].” But none of the people I spoke to were terribly optimistic about that happening or relations improving anytime soon.
“Not under a city administration that feels cops can do no wrong,” said Perez. “And not during times when poor communities are under attack,” he added, referring to severe budget cuts in education, health care, and social programs which he feels demonstrate the government’s outright hostility towards poor people.
“It ain’t never gonna change, so what’s the point in askin’?” said Jessica Jenkins. “[Not] as long as they got the power.” Her solution is “always try to avoid [police] as much as possible.”
But for Doyle the best hope is for young people to join the police force and make a difference from within. “How are you going to change things,” he asked, “if you don’t become a part of them?”

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.