Busted!

Names have been changed.
The East Village on a Saturday night is a haven for almost every type of person imaginable, from wandering junkies on a quest for their next hit to tourists shopping for T-shirts and little Statues of Liberty. And it isn’t uncommon for my friends and me to hang out there, going to concerts or just sitting for hours in one of the local coffee shops gabbing about nothing in particular. So the fact that a bunch of us were sitting on a stoop next to Munchy’s Deli on St. Marks Place on the night of November 26, at around 9:20 p.m. was nothing unusual.
It wasn’t unusual that a patrol car pulled up, either, or that two chubby cops got out of the car and started walking towards us. You see, technically you’re not allowed to hang out on a stoop unless you live there, and if the cops see more than a couple of people doing it they’ll tell you to move along.
More Cops
Figuring this was just business as usual, a couple of us got up and stood out on the sidewalk trying to decide what to do next. My friend, Jane, had to go to the bathroom so we went off in search of a place that would let us use their potty.
When we got back onto the street there was still a large group of people at the corner (most of whom we knew because we had all just come from a concert about 15 blocks away). As Jane and I walked back towards them, we noticed that the patrol car had not left yet either-which was odd, because we’d been gone at least 10 minutes. Then we saw another car and a police van and hurried to see what was going on.
A couple of officers from the second patrol car had one guy backed up against the metal gate of a brownstone on the other side of the street and were talking to him about something. We figured they probably caught him with an open bottle of beer or something stupid, but I crossed over anyway, because I felt like being nosey.
I asked a couple people if they knew what was going on, but before I could get an answer I heard screaming and yelling from behind me. I turned around to see two more officers grab my friend Danny. They got a hold of him, grabbed his arm, twisted it behind his back, and threw him down face first. When they pulled him up, blood was streaming down his chin and onto his leather jacket and army pants.
‘Let Him Go!’
At the time, Danny and I were very close friends, and I flipped. I darted across the busy street (probably in front of a car, I didn’t even notice) and started screaming “Let him go! He didn’t do anything!” Of course I didn’t know if he’d done anything or not. I mean, for all I knew, they were picking him up on murder charges. But I didn’t care, Danny was like my brother, and the cops were hurting him.
The cops cuffed Danny and put him in the back of the police van. But even though they told us to leave, no one did. And I wasn’t the only one yelling. There must have been 50 of us. A tall, White officer with a brown mustache held his club over his head as if to say, “If you come any closer I’ll hit you,” to the crowd. Then a female officer with chin length dirty blond hair told me to back up. When I didn’t move, she shoved me. I took a few steps backwards and after I caught myself, I yelled, “Don’t touch me, B-ch!”
Clubbed over the Head
That’s when someone grabbed my arm, twisted it behind me the same way they had Danny’s and threw me up against the police van. While I was pinned against it, I felt something hard hit me on the back of my head. I didn’t see stars or anything-I didn’t even get a bump-it just hurt for a while when I touched it.
An officer, whose name I later learned was Cunningham, put handcuffs on me. Then he led me around to the other side of the van, where the door was. I climbed in, which wasn’t as easy as it sounds-the van was at least two feet off the ground, and I’m only 5 foot 4, plus my hands were cuffed behind my back. Cunningham slammed the door behind me and I walked to the back and sat down next to Danny.
After a few minutes, I heard my name being called from outside of the van. I couldn’t see too well out the dirty back windows, but finally I spotted my friend Chip waving his arms. When he saw that he’d gotten my attention, he told me he would call my mom and tell her what happened. “OK,” I said loudly, and nodded my head up and down just in case he couldn’t hear me.
Maced While In Handcuffs
Next into the van was my then boyfriend, Andrew, who took a seat in front of Danny and me and didn’t seem upset about the situation at all. Then they threw Dave, a kid from Bergen County, New Jersey, into the van. His head, adorned with a brown spiked Mohawk, landed at my feet. He was crying in pain and couldn’t see because he had been maced (after he had been handcuffed, he told me).
Dave lay there on his stomach with his hands cuffed behind his back on the way to the Ninth Precinct. When we got there, they opened the sliding door and because of the way Dave was wedged up against the door, he just kind of rolled out of the van and into the middle of Fifth Street.As he lay there the officers taunted him, saying things like, “You cry like a b-ch.”
An officer named Kohlar led me inside, through the lobby, and stopped at a doorway where there was a dirty old cardboard sign that said in orange letters “NO FIREARMS PAST THIS POINT.” He gave in his gun, walked me through a big room with a lot of cops sitting at desks, up some stairs and along a corridor lined with small holding cells to the very last one. An officer sitting outside it unlocked the large iron door to the cell and I stepped inside. No one who arrested me had bothered to read me my rights, never mind tell me what I was being charged with.
The Holding Cell
My friends Helen and Cathy were already in there. Helen had a large bump on her head from being wacked in the head twice-once with a walkie-talkie and once with a billy club. The second blow knocked her unconscious for a few moments, she said. When she came to, she was in handcuffs and her eyes were stinging with mace. The mace still had not worn off and Helen was crying. There was a sink in the cell where she could have washed her eyes out, but we were all still in handcuffs.
I sat down on a green bed-type thing next to her, and Cathy sat across from us on a metal bench. Fifteen or 20 minutes later, a female officer came and took us downstairs, one by one, to be searched. On the way, a young male cop with blond hair asked us to give some basic information, like our names, ages and addresses.
I was the last one to be removed from the cell to be searched. As a short Hispanic lady led me back down the steep metal staircase, I was worried that I would lose my balance, confused because I didn’t know what was happening, and just plain tense. She took me to a room with bare cinderblock walls and chalky dust on the floor. Then she uncuffed me and instructed me to take off my jacket and my boots.
The Last Time I Saw My Belongings
I unlaced my boots as quickly as possible and stood up. She told me to lean up against the back wall and spread ’em. She gave me the basic pat down/frisk type deal that you get on the way into some clubs and concerts. Then she took my jewelry and some other stuff from my jacket pocket and put it in a little bag. She counted my money and gave it back to me and then filled out some papers which Cunningham, the arresting officer, later had to sign. Unfortunately, they never gave me a property slip so I could retrieve my belongings after I was released. That was the last time I saw any of my stuff, including my house keys and my favorite necklace.
After that they put the cuffs back on me and led me back upstairs to the holding cell. About five minutes later, Helen, Cathy and I were all taken back downstairs to the main office and put on a bench next to the cell where Danny and Dave were. Danny’s face looked a little better, but now Dave’s face was bleeding because, according to him, the officer who lead him into the station had smashed his face into the corner of a soda machine.
Andrew and another guy named Joey were cuffed to the outside corner of the cell. They were both 15 and therefore considered juveniles so the cops couldn’t put them inside. (Anyone 16 or over is an adult in the eyes of the New York State criminal justice system.) My right hand was also cuffed to the cell, Cathy was cuffed to my left hand and Helen was cuffed to a Stairmaster! Soon the cops took Andrew and Joey into another room and cuffed them to a heating pipe. At around 1 a.m. their parents came and they were both released.
Cell Mates
The five of us who were 16 and over sat in the station for hours doing nothing. While we were there they brought different people in and out of the boys’ cell. First off there was a man named Miguel who was there for hopping a turnstile. Then there was a cute guy we dubbed “Drug Dealer Boy” who was arrested for selling crack and then trying to bribe his arresting officer.
“PsychoLoco” was an extremely gorgeous guy who had been arrested for fighting. He definitely earned the name we gave him. When he first got there, and the cops put him in the cell with the other guys, he sat alone in the corner holding something like a tissue on his bloody right hand and just sort of growled at the other males. Every time one of them opened their mouths to say anything at all, he would growl out, between clenched teeth, “Shut the #*!@ up!” And they did!
My One Phone Call
During our time at the precinct we were each allowed our one phone call. I called my mother, who had already heard what had happened from Chip, and had been calling the precinct to find out what was going on. I thought she’d be angry but she took it really well. She said the police had told her there was nothing she could do, that even if she came down, they wouldn’t let her see me. They said I was going to be charged with two felonies-riot in the first degree and assault-and they were going to put me and my friends through the system.
There was nothing Helen, Cathy and me could do to pass the time except talk about our situation, the cops, and the two cute boys inside the cell. Then we started taking about how pathetic we were that we’d just been arrested, and we were still checking out guys! Occasionally a song we knew would come on the radio and we would sing along.
One by one, they took us to have our fingerprints taken on this big electronic scanner that was supposed to speed up the process of checking our criminal records by transmitting the prints directly to Albany. But the Ninth Precinct ended up losing all of our prints and they had to be retaken the old fashioned way-with ink-about 24 hours later when we were downtown at Central Booking. (Even when this doesn’t happen, a person’s first arrest can often take the longest, because the computer in Albany has to look through all the records to see if it can find a set of matching prints.)
Crude, Sexist Comments
We were seated in a big room with a lot of desks. About eight or 10 cops, both in and out of uniform, were sitting around doing paperwork and talking about a test they had just taken.
After a while they decided to pick on us. The first insult came from a short, balding, White man with a light brown mustache and wire-rimmed glasses. He told Cathy, whose blond hair was shaven nearly bald, except for a tuft of fluffy bangs in the front, and who had thick black circles painted around her eyes, that he wouldn’t like to wake up next to her in the morning.
We knew it was pointless to talk back, that it would only make our time there even more unbearable. Instead I just rolled my eyes at the ugly cop’s comment about my friend, slumped back against the wall, and rested my right boot on the lower bar of the holding cell. A tall White police officer with short, dark brown hair and a thinnish mustache noticed the way I was sitting. “Look,” he remarked to his fellow officers with a smile, “She’s trained, she opens right up for me.”
Going Downtown
I wanted to get up and brutally murder that man, but I knew that’s exactly the reaction he wanted, so I just made a face that kind of said, “Whatever.” He went on to say that the three of us, meaning the female contingent, needed Lysol in between our legs, and refer to us as h-es. I was praying that my lovely visit to the Ninth Precinct would come to an end. And soon my prayers were answered.
Finally, at about 4 a.m., they cuffed our hands behind our backs again and told us we were being taken downtown to Central Booking. We were all escorted back into a police van and driven down to Centre Street in lower Manhattan.
The process of checking into Central is simple and fairly quick. In fact, it doesn’t really involve anyone but the officers who brought you there. You and the police wait on a line until you get to the guards sitting at a counter, where they hand over your paperwork and then take you upstairs to see the nurse. (At this point the sexes are separated again, but this time for good.)
Strip Searched
Cathy, Helen and I lined up in the hallway outside of the door to the nurse’s office and were called in one at a time. When it was my turn, the nurse asked me basic female health questions, like whether I was pregnant and/or needed to go to the hospital.
I asked the nurse if I could have a cup of water from the sink. I was dying of thirst, and when I had asked for water at the Ninth they basically laughed in my face. She said “yes,” however, and soon Helen joined me in drinking as much water as we could manage before they took us to the place where they hold women captive until they get arraigned.
At this point I had to get strip searched. But after the night that I’d just had, one more type of humiliation was the least of my problems. I took off all my clothes. The female guard searched through them and took away a cassette tape that they had overlooked back at the police station. Then she made me do the old “squat and cough” routine to make sure I wasn’t concealing anything inside one of my orifices. After that I was allowed to put my clothes back on and was led to the large holding cell where I would spend the next day or so.
The Twilight Zone
It was a 20 x 30 foot space, that had beige school tiles on three walls. The fourth wall was made of prison bars. Near the front right-hand corner of the cell was a shiny aluminum cubicle just big enough for a person and a toilet. There were skinny little benches lining the walls and spaced out in the middle of the floor, and on the left wall there were two pay phones.
Cathy, Helen and I found a small space on one of the narrow benches in the middle of the cell. It was really way too small for three people to be sitting on, but we crammed ourselves there anyway. Most of the other 40 or so women were sleeping, but a few were quietly talking and a few were just staring into space.
Florescent lamps were shining down on us, and there were no windows to see out of. That didn’t bother me at first, but as time went on, it began to have the Twilight Zone effect. I had no way of knowing if it was night or day, sunny or rainy…I lost all sense of time. We were only there for a day and a half, but after a while, if I looked at my watch and it said four o’clock, I couldn’t be sure if it was a.m. or p.m.
The cell was also extremely hot. Before long, Helen and I moved to an empty piece of floor (most of it was covered by shoeless sleeping women). An elderly lady we dubbed Grandma, who was sitting across from us, made some room on the bench where she was sitting and Cathy stationed herself there.
It turned out that Grandma was there because someone knocked her packages out of her arms on her way home from the store and she hit him with her purse. For that, the poor old lady was arrested. She was there with us almost the whole time, and was very sweet although she mainly kept to herself. When feeding time came around, Grandma would give Helen the bread from her sandwiches, because Helen’s a vegetarian, and couldn’t eat the meat.
There was also an extremely big-busted lady in the cell with us (we’re talking like Triple F here) who was laying on the floor near the bars. When we first arrived, she had popped up, her chest half falling out of her bustier-type top, and asked us why we were there.
I Couldn’t Sleep a Wink All Night
We still weren’t really sure, but they had told our parents that we were being charged with rioting, so that’s what we told her. (She was in for prostitution.) She said that our being there was complete bullsh-t. Especially after she found out our ages (Cathy’s 18, Helen and I are 16.) That’ s basically the same response that we got from everyone: they all said it was bullsh-t, and that we were babies.
After that we chatted for a little while, and made phone calls home just to check in. We wanted to call our friends and stuff but it was like 5:30 on a Sunday morning. We decided to try to get some sleep. I don’t know about Helen or Cathy, but I couldn’t sleep a wink that night.
I spent the next 12 hours or so in the same cell befriending crackheads and prostitutes, and then it started to smell really bad and they moved us all to another cell. It wasn’t until late Monday afternoon-almost 48 hours after we were arrested-that they took us out one by one and brought us through a long passageway. There I met my lawyer, a middle-aged Irish lady who was appointed by the court to represent me.
The Arraignment
She said the whole thing was ridiculous and that I would be released but would probably have to come back and appear in court later on. They put me on a bench and I could see my mom sitting on the other side of the courtroom. I had to wait for around 20 minutes while they arraigned other people, but I couldn’t understand a word of what they said.
Then they called my name and the prosecuting attorney asked for a “restraining order” to keep me out of the area covered by the Ninth Precinct. The judge seemed kind of ticked off, like they were wasting his time (Helen and a couple of the others had already come before him.) “Didn’t we already go through this?” he asked. He said no to the restraining order, and announced a court date in January. Finally, I was allowed to go home.
In January, the court date was postponed because the police had not signed something called a deposition. We were given another date for March. At that hearing the charges were finally dropped because the police had failed to complete some type of paperwork within 90 days of the arrest.
No Regrets
When I tell people my story one of the most commonly asked questions is, “Would you do the same thing if a similar situation came up?” I guess my answer should be “no” but it’s not.
I would still stick up for my friend, which is all that I really did to begin with. I would try to watch my back a little bit more, and I probably wouldn’t yell at a cop the way I did. But hey, what can I tell you? Everything that happenedthat night happened so fast that all I had to act on was gut instinct. I didn’t have time to think about what I was doing, or the consequences of my actions. It all comes down to good ol’ fight or flight, and I sure as hell wasn’t going to run away and desert my friends.
I never really trusted the cops, not even as a small child, because of hearing about corrupt police on the nightly news. When my grandmother’s store got ripped off and she needed their help, they never seemed to come through. The same thing goes for most of the people I know. Yet the police were always very good at harassing the homeless street peddlers that my grandmother would allow to set up shop outside her store.
Time to Revamp the Police Force
In my early teens, the cops were more foes than friends to me. When I ran away from home, I always had to be on my guard so that I wouldn’t get arrested. One time, I was sleeping in a storefront on St. Marks Place with a bunch of my friends and was awakened at 6:30 in the morning by someone kicking me in the head. When I opened my eyes, I saw that it was a cop, who then told me to get my friends up and leave, which we did-very quickly.
That was also the summer the cops raided a peaceful squat on East 13th Street in Manhattan. I knew people who lived in those buildings and who were beaten and arrested for defending their homes.
After my arrest, whatever ability I might have had left to someday respect the police is completely gone. I think there needs to be an almost complete revamping of our police force.
Screwed Up Priorities
One of the problems is the mayor’s crackdown on “quality of life” crimes. I don’t feel cops should be allowed to hassle people for making too much noise, or drinking a beer on the sidewalk, when there are 6-year-old children being beaten and raped. We as a society have to look at the priorities that we set for the police force. I don’t know about the rest of you, but not getting robbed, beaten, raped, or killed on my way home takes total priority over a harmless group of people drinking or blasting their radio.
The cops I’ve dealt with have been a very heavy-handed bunch of people. They forever pick on those who are rejected or cut off from mainstream society-like the poor and the young-because they know that society’s throwaways have no political leverage. Most people won’t care if one more teenager goes to jail for being a little rebellious, or another squatter gets forced out of her home.
How Can We Feel Safe?
Cops are also well aware of how to cover their tracks, what they can do to you and still be able to say that you brought it on yourself, or that it was an accident. Either way, they know they can’t be held accountable for their actions.
Cops are often rude and derogatory too. More than once they’ve called me stupid, and when those cops made crude comments to us in the station house there was nothing that we could say or do to make them eat their words. We were in handcuffs in the middle of a police station.
I would love to know how we are supposed to feel safe in a city that is protected by people approaching middle age who beat the hell out of teenagers and sexually harass 16-year-old girls.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.