Gaybashers: What Are They Trying to Prove?

n 1991, three young men lured Julio Rivera into a deserted schoolyard in Queens. Two of them beat him repeatedly with a hammer and a wrench, and the third stabbed him in the back. Then they left him there to die.
The youths who murdered Rivera had two things in common: they were all between the ages of 15 and 25 and they all hated him because he was gay.
A lot of young guys feel threatened by gays and lesbians. They call them names, make jokes about them and some of them are responsible for attacks like the one against Rivera.
Why would anyone hurt or kill someone just because that person is different? The most basic reason is fear, fear of the unknown. “People think we are a whole different species,” says Angel Star, 20, a gay student at Harvey Milk HS in Manhattan. “Because you don’t understand someone, you become afraid of him or her.”
In the case of young men, who are often insecure about their sexuality, the fear is even greater. When some young men can’t accept the possibility that they might be gay themselves, says Naomi Lichtenstein of New York City’s Gay and Lesbian Anti-Violence Project,”they go out looking for targets, saying subconsciously, ‘That one’s the f-got, not me’…they literally want to get rid of the other person as a way of getting rid of the feelings in themselves. Of course it won’t work; violence solves nothing.”
Real Men Don’t Have to Prove It
Another reason is the pressure to be a “real man.” A lot of young guys believe a man has to have sex with women and fight a lot. Most of these hate crimes start when a guy wants to prove to himself and his buddies that he’s a man. So he’ll say, “Let’s go beat up a junkie or a f-g.”
Lichtenstein says older men tend to be more secure. “They don’t need to prove anything,” she explained. “And they’ve learned other ways of solving their own problems without hurting someone else.”
But it’s not just teens who are anti-gay, it’s our whole society: parents, teachers, religion, the media, even the law. In movies and on TV young people see images of homosexuals as criminals and child molesters, according to Andy Humm of the Hetrick-Martin Institute for Gay and Lesbian Youth. It’s still a big deal to air programs that show two homosexual people together.
The Roman Catholic Church teaches that it’s wrong to be gay or lesbian and until recently the military threw people out if they were even suspected of it. In some states (not New York) there are still laws forbidding homosexuals to make love. Until 1973, the nation’s psychiatrists considered being gay a mental illness.
As Many as 1 in 10
There is such lack of understanding about homosexuals that even their parents often turn against them. Parents tell their kids:
” ‘I’d rather have a junkie than a gay son,’ ” says Angel, “[or] ‘I’d rather you be a slut than for you to like [other] girls’ They’d rather have their child destroy their life and be miserable, than be gay.”
It’s no wonder a lot of teens grow up prejudiced against gays. Whether they learned those values at home, in church, in school, or from TV, homosexuality threatens a lot of people’s “views on how the world should be,” says Lichtenstein. Their belief in the traditional family is so narrow that anything else is wrong. So they go out and beat somebody up.
Experts agree the best way to change that is through education. Most people are not aware that studies suggest that as many as 1 out of 10 people in the United States is gay. “Society takes for granted [that] everyone is straight or that everyone should be,” says Angel.
People need to understand that it’s normal to be gay, lesbian, or bisexual. “[It] doesn’t make someone less of a man or woman,” explains Lichtenstein. “A man or woman is not defined by who they love.”
Like Racism
There was a time when Blacks were separated to the point where they had to use their own water fountains. Yet they drank the same water White people did. The only thing different about them was the color of their skin. Blacks went through a lot to prove they are equal. Well, gays are fighting a similar fight.
We all know that disliking someone because of color is being prejudiced and it’s wrong. When teens think they’re better than someone because he or she is gay, when they avoid the person or make rude comments, then they’re being bigots just like the Ku Klux Klan. We are all human beings. Before you start to look for a reason to hate, look for a reason to love.
Melissa Lee Gruenler was a 16-year-old student at Graphic Communication Arts HS when she wrote this article. Reprinted from New Youth Connections, May 1992.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.