Pataki to CUNY Students: Pay Up or Drop Out

For students at the City University of New York, budget cuts and tuition increases are a fact of life.
For the third year in a row, Governor George Pataki wants to cut millions of dollars in state funding from CUNY’s budget and financial aid programs. That would mean a tuition hike, less financial aid and fewer services for anyone attending a CUNY college next year.
The governor’s proposed budget for fiscal year 1997-98 recommends a $57-million reduction in state aid to CUNY’s 11 senior colleges and a $400 tuition increase that would take effect in September, making full-time tuition $3,600 a year.
Pataki also wants to cut $175 million from the Tuition Assistance Program, which helps low and middle-income students cover their tuition expenses at both public and private colleges. That proposal would result in some students losing as much as $1,200 in aid per academic year.
‘Tuition Is Too High Now’
CUNY administrators estimate that as many as 12,000 full and part-time students could be forced to drop out of college if tuition is increased and the TAP cuts take effect.
“Tuition is too high as it is. We should be paying less so more of us could go to college,” said Antonio Seisdedos, a student at Queens College and member of the New York Public Interest Research Group (NYPIRG), which is opposing the cuts. “Instead of raising tuition, Governor Pataki should lower it.”
Many students say tuition at CUNY has been increasing so rapidly that they can no longer afford to attend college. In 1995-Pataki’s first year in office-the state slapped CUNY students with a $750 tuition hike and reduced their TAP awards by 10 percent. Last year, Pataki proposed another $250 tuition increase and massive financial aid cuts. But the state legislature did not approve those proposals, so tuition remained the same.
Heather Martinez, a student at Queensborough Community College and another NYPIRG member, said even though her parents and grandparents are paying her tuition, she still has a part-time job to help pay expenses. “A tuition increase would mean another part-time job for me, making it almost impossible to go to school.”
The Poorest Students Would Lose The Most
The financial aid cuts would affect almost 100,000 CUNY undergraduates. Many of these students currently use their TAP awards to cover tuition and rely on federal Pell Grants to pay for books, supplies, transportation and other living expenses.
Pataki has proposed reducing a student’s TAP award by half the amount of her federal Pell Grant. (For example, a student who this year received a $3,200 TAP award and a $2,000 Pell Grant would have her TAP grant reduced by $1,000 next year.) That would force thousands of students to use Pell funds to help pay for tuition, leaving less money for other expenses. And since the poorest students receive full Pell Grants, they stand to lose the most TAP funding.
‘Hurry Up and Graduate’
Pataki also wants to reduce the number of semesters that students working towards an associate’s degree will be eligible for TAP awards. The current limit is six; the governor wants to cut it down to four.
CUNY Chancellor W. Ann Reynolds told state legislators in January that this new requirement would make it very difficult for thousands of CUNY students who have children and jobs to get a degree. “It takes our students more than six semesters to complete an associate’s degree program,” she said. “It’s not because they are lazy.”
In addition to the loss of financial aid, the proposed cuts would translate into more crowded classrooms, faculty layoffs, fewer course offerings, less counseling and shorter library hours at most CUNY campuses.
The governor and his staff insist that the cutbacks and tuition hike won’t drive students to drop out of college. In fact, his budget director said in a written statement: “Governor Pataki’s executive budget preserves and opens access to higher education for families and individuals throughout New York State.”
There’s Still Time To Fight It
Pataki’s proposed budget must be approved by the state legislature in Albany. The legislature can restore cuts and request other changes in the final budget. The governor and legislature are supposed to agree on a state budget by April 1, but in recent years the negotiations have extended several months past the deadline. Members of the state Assembly’s Higher Education Committee and a group of Black and Hispanic legislators say they will fight to restore the TAP cuts and prevent a tuition hike.
Students, faculty and other concerned activists are already organizing against the cuts. The Professional Staff Congress, which represents 12,000 CUNY professors, is planning to hold a series of lobbying days at each campus later this spring. The events will feature speakers, write-your-legislator sessions and voter registration drives.
NYPIRG, which has chapters on seven CUNY campuses, plans to launch its own lobbying and letter-writing campaign aimed at influential members of the state legislature. Other student groups are planning to hold demonstrations in Albany and at City Hall.
For more information about upcoming protests call SLAM/Coalition for Public Education at 212-642-2549. For more information about lobbying state legislators, call NYPIRG at 212-349-6460.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.