Since I came to this country three years ago, I can honestly say that I’ve hardly learned anything new-at least not in school.
American schools just aren’t strict enough, and as a result, the students are way behind students in many other countries. Teachers don’t assign a lot of homework, or seem to care if you do it on time. Here, if a teacher told the class to memorize a three-page poem for the next day the way they do in Russia (where I’m from), for example, the students would probably look at her like she was from another planet or laugh in her face.
I remember my first day at Horace Greeley JHS in Queens. I was 12 years old and so scared that my blood was turning into a popsicle. Images of the surprise algebra tests they used to give us in Moscow still haunted me. If I could barely pass them there, in my native language, how would I do here?
Kid’s Stuff
The first assignment they gave us that day was a grammar exercise, something like, “Fill in the blank: The dress __ ugly. Those people ___ old.” I could do that when I was 8 and just starting to learn English back in Russia. I still remember the frightened look on the teacher’s face when I handed in a finished paper just five minutes after she had passed it out.
The next day we had a math test where we had to solve problems like 2x-3=7, which was something I’d done two years before. I got 100 on that test. I wanted to laugh out loud the following day when my teacher told me how good I was at math.
I wished my Russian math teacher could have heard that. The year before, I got a ‘C’ in her class. But here, at the end of my eighth grade year, they were teaching me things that we had learned in third grade in Moscow.
Almost No Homework
In this country, I got less homework in a week than I had every day in Russia for each of my classes. For every page I had to write for English class as a 13-year-old here, I used to have to write four back when I was 10.
Because I was getting straight ‘A’s, people in my American class thought that all I did was study, but I rarely spent more than an hour a day on homework. I often did most of it at lunch, and when I came home, I didn’t have to do anything.
“Don’t you have any homework?” my mom kept asking me when I came home.
“I already finished it,” I would say, but I don’t think she believed me. It took her awhile to get used to the idea that I didn’t have to spend three to four hours a night on homework anymore.
Nevertheless, because of my grades, the teachers couldn’t stop bragging about me. That only made me feel worse, though. It was like being proud of a 10-year-old because she can walk.
In the U.S., if you didn’t bring your homework on time, you could bring it tomorrow…or the day after tomorrow, or the day after that. I got the impression that some teachers were just happy to get any homework from the students at all. It almost didn’t matter if it was late or messy.
Feeling Sorry for the Teachers
In Russia, they were so strict about those things that I always used to think about students and teachers as “us against them.” But here, I honestly felt sorry for the teachers when they had to remind people to bring homework over and over again. No one even seemed to be listening.
Something like that teaches you not to take responsibility seriously. After all, why bother remembering anything if someone will always remind you?
I believe there should be consequences for making a mistake- otherwise why avoid making it in the first place? And if a teacher asks you a question, you should have to answer it instead of just saying, “I don’t want to” -something that I’ve seen many students here do. When a teacher gives homework, you should be required to bring it on time. And if you don’t meet that requirement you shouldn’t be given the same grade as someone who did.
Rules Help
I always hated all the homework I had to do when I lived in Russia, but now I realize how much I learned because of it. Maybe they don’t need to lower a grade for one misspelled word the way they do in my country, but at least the homework ought to be done. No matter how much we all hate rules (yes, even me), they teach discipline and respect, as well as self-respect.
The rules don’t need to be extreme, but they need to exist. Without them, you never learn to finish what you start, to manage your time so that you get everything done, to be responsible and punctual-qualities that are hard to succeed without.
Want To Learn? Get To Work!: American Schools Are Child’s Play
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.