Spraypainted on a wall at the corner of 153rd Street and Morris Avenue in the South Bronx in big multicolored letters is the name “Dave” and the words “We Love You.”
It is a curbside shrine to my cousin, David Elias Torres, who two years ago was shot in cold blood while talking to his girlfriend on the pay phone across the street. Eight blocks uptown sits the Bronx Supreme Courthouse where Johnny Adames, the man police and eyewitnesses believe to be David’s murderer, was tried, found guilty, and released.
David was 20 when he was killed. His life ended before it ever really began. He grew up in a three-bedroom apartment on the third floor of an apartment complex across the street from his mural with his mother and brothers, Jose and Hector. The neighborhood around there was full of hoodlums hanging out in front of the building or chilling on the corner.
A Troubled Youth
When we were little, David was always curious. I remember him trying to get us all to come with him across an abandoned bridge near where he lived so we could see the trains pass by. As he got older, David let his curiosity get him into trouble. By the time he was 15, he was hanging out with people who dealt drugs and staying out late at night partying.
At 16, he dropped out of school and three years later he was arrested in an apartment containing drugs and guns and charged with possession of weapons and narcotics. He was sentenced to 20 years in jail but was released on parole after 11 months when he agreed to give the police some information they wanted.
I hadn’t seen David in over a year and I missed him. So two weeks after he got out, on a Saturday, I took the bus over to see him. When I got there, he was cleaning his room, throwing out some of his jeans, shirts, jackets, sneakers, some pictures and magazines.
A Brand New Start
He had pumped a lot of iron in prison and showed off his muscles to me. His mother, Titi Ana, was scolding David, “Mira muchacho, no ‘te’ botando todo, que no hay dinero para comprar m’.” (Don’t be throwing out everything; we don’t have money to replace it.)
“Ay, no te apures, Mami. Yo voy a conseguir un trabajo,” David said smiling. (Don’t worry, Mom. I’m going to get a job.)
He said he had an interview that Tuesday at the Big Apple Messenger Service in Manhattan. David seemed determined to change his life around. In jail, he had taken classes toward his GED and now he spoke proudly about going to night school to finish.
As we talked, he rearranged the furniture in his room trying to give it a new look. He said he wanted a new start. He wanted to put his mistakes behind him and was throwing away everything and anything that reminded him of his past. “I should have done this a long time ago,” he said.
His Last Words to Me
My 15th birthday was only two weeks away and he kept giving me weird suggestions on what to do to celebrate. Like he told me to walk around all of Manhattan with my friends in the freezing cold. I looked at him like he was crazy. We joked around some more and then I gave him a hug and a kiss and said goodbye.
“God Bless!” he said. Those were his last words to me.
Three days later, I was chilling at home with my older brother Jose Elias, who was home from college on vacation. We were watching TV and catching up on each other’s lives, when the phone rang.
It was Nirma, a friend of the family who lived downstairs from David. Nirma never called us, so immediately I knew something was up.
“I don’t know how to say this….David’s been shot,” she told me.
“What?” I yelled into the phone as a chill ran through my entire body.
“David’s been shot.”
Jose snatched the phone from my hand and talked to Nirma for what seemed like an eternity. Then he hung up and stared into my eyes.
“David’s been shot,” Jose told me, on the brink of tears.
Shot and Killed
“Is he OK?” I asked, already knowing the answer in my heart.
“He’s dead.” The words echoed throughout the house and I looked away in disbelief.
He said Nirma had heard shots fired and a lot of commotion so she ran outside to see what happened. There was David lying on the ground across the street, bleeding from his head. The ambulance had come, but there was no need for it. David was dead.
Somehow, Jose’s words didn’t sink in. I remained standing. I felt numb. I wasn’t quite sure what was happening. Maybe I had misunderstood or maybe Jose had.
Jose zoomed out of his PJ’s and got dressed fast. I didn’t know what to do. I didn’t know what to think. I just stood there for a long time waiting for someone to tell me, “This is only a bad dream. It’s not real.”
“I’m leaving to go see what happened,” Jose told me. “Call Ma and Pa at work to tell them what happened.”
After the door closed, I just sat there on the sofa alone, stunned, tears rolling down my cheeks. I was too scared to call my parents, scared of the truth. “It’s not true,” I kept telling myself. “It’s not true.”
Bloodstains on the Concrete
Finally, I got myself together and called my father. I didn’t know how to tell him so I just blurted out, “David got shot.”
My father sighed and said, “Oh my God, how is he?”
“He’s dead.”
“Are you sure he’s dead?” he kept asking me.
“Yes,” I remember saying. “David’s dead!” Only when I said it out loud did I believe it was really true.
My mother was already on her way home from work and as soon as both she and my father arrived, we went straight over to David’s house.
It was true. There were bloodstains on the concrete in front of the bodega. Yellow police tape surrounded the crime scene and most of my relatives were looking on in disbelief.
The next day, Wednesday, there was a picture in the Daily News of the store owners washing away the bloodstains on the sidewalk underneath the pay phone. In a brief two sentences under the picture, it said that an unidentified Hispanic male in his early 20’s was killed outside a store in the South Bronx. They might as well have just said, “Oh by the way, some nobody was killed in-where else? the South Bronx.”
Reality is Hard to Swallow
I felt horrible. I’d seen in the news how teenagers in New York City were dying left and right, but I never figured it would hit so close to home. David was family, my blood. Reality is hard to swallow sometimes, and this was one of those times for me.
The day after that, Thursday, was the wake. A part of me didn’t want to go. I wanted to remember David as I last saw him. But I went anyway.
The funeral home was packed and everyone was crying-some hysterically, others quietly. “ÁDios, mi hijo! Me cogieron mi hijo.” Titi Ana kept yelling. “God, my son! They took my son!”
David left a lot of people behind. His younger brother Hector, for example, who always looked up to him. Hector had heard the shots, ran to where David lay on the ground and sat in the pool of blood holding David’s head on his lap. At 15, it was a hard blow to withstand.
The Man They Said Pulled the Trigger
On the final day of the wake, before they closed the casket, everyone lined up to see David one final time. When it was my turn, I looked at David’s face. I could see the marks where the bullet had pierced his head. I kissed him on the forehead one final time. He was so cold that I started to cry. My cousin, who I had just seen with his vibrant smile and changed outlook on life, was dead and would not be coming back.
Once David had been lowered into his grave questions began to pop up about who killed him and why. Who witnessed it? Rumors began to spread. Everyone had a different story.
Some said Johnny Adames, a kid from the neighborhood who grew up with David and had a reputation as a troublemaker, got out of an “OJ car,” came towards David and shot him in the head, got back in the car and drove off. Others claimed there was someone else driving the car and Johnny didn’t act alone. But all the stories we heard from people in the neighborhood agreed that Johnny Adames was the one who pulled the trigger.
After David was buried, the whole family came together every day to pray for him and say a rosary. That’s where David’s girlfriend, Marisol, told us that the day he died, David passed by her job at Lincoln Hospital to get her keys. On his way home, which was only two blocks away from the hospital, David called her and told her that he had seen Johnny Adames and Johnny appeared to be stalking him in a car.
“I think he’s going to kill me,” he told her. They continued talking until Marisol heard shots through the phone and ran out of the hospital and down two blocks to where David lay dead on the ground.
An Arrest and a Confession
My cousin, Jose, told me that two days after the shooting, Johnny, knowing the police were looking for him, went to the 41st precinct and turned himself in. He was arrested and charged with second degree murder. Jose said that Johnny had confessed.
Jose also said that he heard that another kid from the block, George Rivera, 15, was coming out of the video store and saw Johnny drive up in an “OJ car,” get out, approach David, and shoot him in the head twice at close range. Then he got back in his car and drove off. That’s what Rivera told the police.
According to Jose, David’s neighbors Shiree and Irma, the ones who first called the police, also witnessed the shooting out their living room window and said it was Johnny. In short, everything pointed to Johnny, and after he was arrested, he went to jail to await trial.
It eased our suffering to know that the person who did this to David was locked up and had no chance to roam the streets and possibly kill again.
A Solid Case
The prosecutor appointed to the case was Jeffrey Rosenbaum. Rosenbaum informed the family that the chances of convicting Johnny were very good. We had the witnesses and the confession. We were confident that the justice system would make Johnny pay for what he had done by locking him up for a long time.
Two very slow years passed while we waited for the trial to begin. When it did, last May, things quickly started to go wrong. Some of the witnesses changed their stories about what they had seen. Rumor had it they were either scared or that someone paid them off to keep their mouths shut or change their testimony. I don’t know if the rumors were true but I wouldn’t be surprised if they were.
When the time came for Johnny himself to testify, I went to court. Johnny claimed that the police beat the confession out of him. He described how he was handcuffed to a pole by his left wrist and how, as they were questioning him, they kept moving him farther and farther from the pole until his arm was completely stretched out.
Police Brutality?
His defense lawyer, Robert Gould, who had his hair slicked back like Pat Riley, showed pictures of Johnny looking fine upon arrival at the police station but with many bruises on his face later.
I wanted to throw up. Johnny was acting like he was the victim. He kept whining and whining about how bad the police treated him and looking more innocent all the time. I could tell the jury felt bad for Johnny. (Well, the jurors who were awake anyway, because one old lady was knocked out.) They had that “Ay bendito!” look on their faces.
Then Gould asked Johnny to describe his friendship with David. Johnny told the court how much he loved David, how he missed him and how he could never have done what they said. As he kept talking, it was like a knife was being stuck into my heart, piercing it again and again until I almost died.
I couldn’t believe what I was witnessing. The prosecutor was horrible. When he had Johnny on the stand during cross examination, he made him look better instead of worse.
A ‘Lazy, Unorganized’ Prosecutor
Johnny’s wife had claimed he was with her at the time of the shooting. They went through this whole thing about the exact time and she said she was sure because they had been listening to the radio. But in his testimony, Johnny mentioned that it was a tape they were listening to. Instead of pinning Johnny into a corner and calling attention to the inconsistencies in their testimonies, Rosenbaum laid back and didn’t attack.
It seemed to me that Rosenbaum didn’t want to win the case as badly as Gould did. And then, to put the icing on the cake, after the jury had left the courtroom, the judge insulted Rosenbaum on his lazy and unorganized style and told him to get his act together and stop complaining about his rulings.
The Walls Were Closing In
When I heard that, I knew it wasn’t just my emotions getting the best of me. If a judge-who knows a lot more about law than I do-noticed how poorly Rosenbaum was doing, then something was very wrong in this trial after all. I felt the walls closing in on the whole case and in the pit of my stomach I began to fear that Johnny would be set free.
But I swallowed my fear, telling myself to believe in justice. The system would not allow a killer to roam the streets. The weekend passed and it took a couple more days for the closing arguments and other procedural matters. It was finals week at school and I tried to focus on my exams, but it was difficult.
Then one day, I got home from school and my mom, who’s usually chipper and eager to tell me about her day, was sitting on the sofa with a dim look on her face. “What’s wrong? What happened?” I asked.
‘Not Guilty’
“They let him go,” she responded.
“They let who go?” I asked, although I already knew the answer.
“Johnny.”
What I felt at that moment was beyond hurt and beyond anger. I felt rage. It brought me back to the day David died. I felt like he had been killed a second time. First by Johnny, then by the justice system. Now everything had been taken from us. We had no David. We had no justice.
The day of the verdict, the family gathered together in Titi Ana’s (David’s mother’s) house. We looked at old pictures of David and cried, remembering how things used to be.
Assistant District Attorney Rosenbaum told my cousin Jose that he was sorry. He had tried his best and there was nothing more that could be done. He didn’t mention that Johnny could still be sued in civil court on wrongful death charges. He didn’t mention the possibility of filing an appeal either. Rosenbaum left us feeling helpless.
A Visit to David’s Grave
Later on that day, we all went to the cemetery. Titi Ana collapsed on top of David’s grave crying hysterically. “Quiero mi hijo, she screamed. “Dios, por favor, dame mi hijo.” (I want my son. Please, God, give me my son.) David’s brother, Hector, now 17, had an expressionless look on his face that remained there for weeks following the verdict.
It all seemed so hopeless. It was the emptiest feeling I have ever experienced and it continues to this day. The jury’s verdict was final. To them, it is over and done with. But to us, it will never be over.
It’s not supposed to work this way. I was taught that if you kill, you go to jail. You pay for yanking a loved one out of a family’s life. You don’t get set free to roam the streets while your victim lies six feet under.
A Head Full of Questions
It’s the most empty feeling in the whole wide world to visit your cousin’s grave and not have an answer to why he died. I don’t understand how one day I’m joking around with David and then a few days later someone shoots him. I don’t understand how the police arrest Johnny Adames for killing David and then when the trial comes, the jury sets him free.
In my heart I know that Johnny murdered my cousin. No, I wasn’t there, but other people were. David was killed on a beautiful January afternoon. The street was filled with people. Maybe they felt it was in their best interest to keep out of it. Maybe the cops did beat Johnny up while he was in custody-I don’t know. But the fact remains that, to this day, all the existing evidence as well as all the talk around the neighborhood points to the same person.
In the trial the burden of proof was on Rosenbaum. It was his job to prove “beyond a reasonable doubt” that Johnny pulled the trigger. He didn’t do that, and based on what I saw in the courtroom, the clutter on his desk, the way jurors were literally falling asleep during his cross examination of Johnny, and the way the judge told him to get his act together, Rosenbaum was incompetent, a joke.
The Jury Couldn’t Care Less
But Rosenbaum wasn’t the only thing wrong with the trial. While witnesses were testifying, the jury seemed disinterested, in another world. You could tell by the bored looks on their faces that they weren’t focusing, that they just wanted to get this case over with. They spent hardly any time deliberating; after both sides rested, the jury announced its verdict the very next day.
Johnny got off because of a combination of factors: the suspicion of police brutality; a lazy, disorganized prosecutor; uncooperative witnesses and a jury that didn’t seem to care.
A month after he was released from jail, I was walking down Southern Boulevard to the bus, when I saw Johnny coming the other way. He doesn’t know who I am, but I recognized him from the trial. I stopped walking, stood near a store and watched him as he strolled right by me.
God’s Justice
He was wearing a nice, dark suit and had his head held high like he was on top of the world. So many things ran through my mind at that moment. I felt like confronting him and spitting in his face. I wished he could feel what I felt when David was buried. I wished he had seen Titi Ana when she collapsed on David’s grave wanting her son back. I wished he could feel what we were all going through and realize how much David meant to us.
My first thought was that Johnny should die. He seemed to have no remorse. I was convinced that what my family and I had gone through meant absolutely nothing to him and I wanted him to suffer like we suffered. I wanted him to pay. I felt like doing so many things, but I kept my cool and refused to let my emotions get the best of me. I didn’t want to lower myself to his level.
They say there is no justice in this world, but I don’t believe that. One way or another, the person who killed David will get what he deserves. If this world doesn’t provide its justice, then I leave it up to God to provide his. David’s murderer may have escaped the justice system, but sooner or later, what he did will catch up to him.
Will There Ever Be Justice for David? (Part I)
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.