A Student Metrocard: Are Two Fares Fair?

We’re used to using our bus and train passes as often as we need to, as long as it isn’t the weekend or after 7 p.m. Well, in the future when you forget your homework and have to go back home for it or when you have to go to the library after school, there is a good chance that you’ll have to pay for that extra ride.
In August, the city announced a plan to replace the current bus and train passes with student Metrocards, good for only two trips a day.
A Metrocard looks a lot like a credit card; it’s made of blue plastic and has a dark, magnetic strip on the back. Instead of showing it to the token booth clerk and waiting to be let through, you slide your card through an electronic “reader” on the turnstile and walk through just as if you’d dropped a token in the slot. After you’ve used up your allotted number of rides, the card stops working. It can also be programmed to only be valid at certain stations.
For many students, having a card that only allows them two rides a day could create big problems. Teenagers around the city use their passes to travel to sporting events that take place off school grounds, meetings of afterschool clubs, part-time jobs, youth programs, and other extracurricular activities.
Shelly Singh, 14, of William Cullen Bryant HS, told me she sometimes uses her bus pass to go to the library or visit friends. She knows one girl who has to make an extra stop on her way to and from school every day. “She has to drop off her sister,” said Shelly. “[That’s] four trips.”
“I don’t think anybody just goes to school and comes home [every day],” she added.
‘We’re Not Paying For it’
Under the proposal put forth in August, students would only be allowed two rides per day to get them to and from school and would have to pay to go to any extracurricular activities that weren’t within walking distance. “If you’re not going to school, we’re not paying for it,” said Termain Garden, a spokesman for the Transit Authority.
Many of the students I spoke to think that would be unfair. “I’m not going to be able to use [my new pass] if there’s an emergency and I have to go back to my house,” said Natalia Saenz, 15, of International HS, “[or] if I don’t have any money.”
Shelly agreed. She said there are places students really need to go and stops they have to make. “It’s not like they’re cheating,” she said. “They can’t afford it. They don’t have enough money.”
Kids Can’t Afford It
But Garden said that the TA loses millions of dollars each year because of unauthorized use of transit passes by students. “We’re getting too much abuse,” he said, and the new Metrocard passes will be one way to cut down on it.
“We recognize that many kids [need] more than two rides a day,” for legitimate, educational purposes, Garden added, but he feels that most don’t. Harry Spence, deputy chancellor for Operations of the Board of Education, believes that while there may be a lot of students who cheat, the number who have school-related activities is a lot larger. “It’s worth suffering a small amount of abuse,” he said, to ensure that no kids drop out of after-school activities because they can’t afford to pay for transportation.
The Board has suggested that students be given a card good for several trips a day, and they’re still working with the Transit Authority to work out an agreement on this issue.
Despite the many problems that could arise if the TA’s plan actually goes into effect, the Metrocard does have advantages over the passes students use now. Several of the people I’ve spoken to who have used them say it makes their trip a lot faster and easier. Instead of having to stand in line, argue with the token booth clerk and miss the train as a result, you just slide it through. (Right now only half the city’s subway stations have Metrocard readers. At the others you would have to flash the card the way you do an ordinary pass until the readers are installed.)
Because it’s made of plastic, the Metrocard is more durable than the paper passes; it’s even waterproof. And best of all, it’s good on both buses and subways anywhere in the city (unless the TA programs it not to be).
Another good thing about the cards, is that they can be replaced. Every card is encoded with its own serial number. According to Garden, if you report your card missing, its serial number is simply erased from the computer and you get a new card within a few days. Anyone trying to use the lost or stolen card will find that it no longer works.
But, for all the advantages the Metrocard seems to offer, parents and advocates are concerned about a number of other issues, like privacy. Every time you use the card, the computer records what station you got on at and when.
Big Brother?
“The question is, do you want the government to know where you are?” said Gene Russianoff, a senior attorney with the Straphangers Campaign, an advocacy organization that fights for the rights of subway riders. He suggested that one way of dealing with the privacy issue is by having safeguards on the Metrocards, so that the computer is not able to record that information.
Because of this and other concerns, the United Parents Association (UPA) opposes the whole idea of student Metrocards and is circulating a petition to stop the plan. “We just don’t like this technological tracking of our children,” said Ayo Harrington, the president of the UPA. She compared it with recent proposals to institute a curfew for people under 18 and feels this is yet another example of the government trying to be a parent and keep track of where kids go. According to Harrington, that’s not the government’s job.
More Stealing?
Another concern is safety. Natalia Saenz, 15, of International HS, said she knows people who steal the current transit passes and sell them for $15 or $20 apiece. With a Metrocard, she feels, “people will start stealing more.” And, while in theory you can report the theft and have the card electronically canceled, Gene Russianoff said security concerns still need to be thought through a lot more carefully before the plan is implemented.
Termain Garden says that all students will have Metrocards by January of ’97. He says this proposal is “definitely” going to be approved by then. Theoretically the Metropolitan Transit Authority, which oversees the TA, has the power to make that decision all by itself. But Gene Russianoff doesn’t think that will happen. “It’s unclear what the process is going to be like,” he said. “There’s a lot of opposition.”
Russianoff said the outcome of the process depends on how the parents react. Some have already started reacting. Ayo Harrington of the UPA told me her organization has sent their petition opposing the plan to the PTA of every high school in the city. Other advocates are organizing to make sure that concerns about the number of trips, privacy and safety are adequately adressed in the plan.
Make Your Voice Heard
Right now nothing has been decided for sure. If students and parents speak out, and tell how they feel, they can influence the decision. One way to do that, Gene Russianoff suggests, is to write to Mayor Giuliani, to the MTA and to the public officials in your district. Tell them how you feel about the proposed change, what you think is the best solution and why.
The MTA also holds public hearings every month, where anyone can step up to the mic and talk for two minutes about how she feels about issues concerning the New York City transit system. Russianoff thinks that if enough students and parents demand four rides a day on their Metrocards, and give a reason why, they just might get what they want.
It Worked the Last Time
It’s happened before. Just over a year ago, the Mayor announced that, after 50 years of free public transportation to and from school, he wanted to eliminate passes altogether and make students pay their own way. That would have cost each family $540 a year minimum-double if they lived in a two-fare zone.
Students and parents became very angry. The Straphangers Campaign put up posters all over the subway system with a picture of a token and Mayor Guiliani’s face in the middle. In big, bold letters, it said, “Mayor to the students: Take a hike!” It listed phone numbers that people could call to say how they felt about the proposal.
According to Russianoff, thousands of students and parents made phone calls to the Mayor’s office over and over again. “The Mayor had a big crisis,” he said. Eventually, Giuliani found another way to balance the budget and reached a compromise in which the city, state, and the MTA each had to pay one third of the cost. “We beat the Mayor,” said Russianoff with a smile of victory.
But that was a year ago. This is a different proposal that has a lot of obvious advantages and Russianoff believes that, with a little work, “it can be made fair.” The TA wants all its riders to use Metrocards. And sooner or later, we will. Russianoff believes that in four to six years “practically everyone will have a Metrocard.
“I think the Metrocard is in the future,” he said, “We just don’t have to rush into it.”

SIDEBAR: Trial Run
Last year, the Transit Authority designed a pilot project at two high schools, one in Manhattan and the other on Staten Island, to test how Metrocards would work as student passes. At Murry Bergtraum HS, every student eligible for transit passes was given a special Metrocard with his or her picture on it for the entire school year. The card could be used twice a day on weekdays. But after 7 pm, the two rides were lost. If the station did not have Metrocard readers on its turnstiles, the student had to show the card to the token booth clerk like a regular train pass. I talked to five students from Bergtraum, and they all seemed to like the Metrocard because it saved a lot of time. They didn’t have to wait in line or argue with the token booth clerk anymore. “It gets pretty hectic around here when you get out of school,” said Jazmin Pernett, 19, who I interviewed at the school. “With a Metrocard, it was a lot faster.” Jazmin also said it was “a good piece of ID. I can use it to cash my check.” Unfortunately, Termain Garden, a spokesman for the Transit Authority, said that the photos were a mistake. Taking pictures of all 436,000 kids who currently receive transit passes every year would be way too expensive, he explained, so any future student Metrocard will have to be without pictures. Joannie Morota, 18, liked the card for many of the same reasons and added that, “it wouldn’t break so easily, and it was easy to carry.” According to Jazmin, kids from other high schools were impressed with how advanced and technological the Bergtraum students’ passes were. Amazingly, almost no one I spoke to complained about the limited number of trips. When asked, Joannie did say that she would rather have a regular train pass, “because yeah, you can use it more than twice.” But other than that, I didn’t hear any complaints. No one mentioned going to the library or after-school activities that required them to travel. No one said they forgot something at home and needed to go back. The Transit Authority claims that Metrocards are easy to replace if lost or stolen, but Joannie told me that when one of her friends lost her new card, she was issued one of the old train passes after two months of paying her own money. Jazmin also lost her Metrocard and also got a paper pass, but in her case it only took a day. The pilot project is now over, and though neither the Board of Education nor the MTA has actually talked to students who participated to find out how they think it went, the MTA considers the project a success because there were so few complaints.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.