My parents sweat their bucks, so when they bought me an 18-speed mountain bike I was on cloud nine. This wasn’t your ordinary bike. It is a lime-green Savoy, one of the top names, and has a lightweight frame made of titanium alloy. Whenever I ride it, I get this great feeling of freedom, as if I were a bird.
One evening last September, my friend Phil and I were riding on a quiet block in my Queens neighborhood. I had ridden there many times before and I never expected what happened next: out of nowhere, two teenage guys rode up from behind us and stopped their bikes right in front of me.
One of them pulled out a knife and said, “I need money, give me money.” It happened so fast. I gave him all I had-which was $4. Phil pedaled away to call the police. The other guy pushed me off my bike, leapt on and rode away, leaving his on the street. His partner rushed off too.
The Chase Begins
I ran after them. “Somebody call the police, help, this guy is stealing my bike,” I screamed as I followed them into an area with markets and stores. Some people didn’t even look, they just kept walking by. But two men jumped in a car and drove off after them.
I started chasing after the car, and kept on going for several minutes, even after I lost sight of it. When I couldn’t keep going, (I had a 25 pound book bag on my back) I turned and walked the long road back. I had this burning feeling in my gut. It wasn’t so much the money but this terrible feeling that I couldn’t do anything to get back what was mine. I felt helpless. I kept hoping my parents wouldn’t think the whole thing was somehow my fault.
When I got back to the block where my bike had been stolen, I saw Phil, four police cars… and my bike. The new light was broken off and some of the frame was scratched. “What the hell is going on here?” I yelled out. An officer replied, “You tell us.” I told them everything that I just told you…and so began my journey through the criminal justice system.
The Cops Take Over
I soon found out that the two men who helped me were off-duty cops from the 112th precinct. Another cop, a real clean-cut, streetwise detective, drove me and Phil to where the off-duty cops had caught the bad guys. His car smelled of stale coffee and cigarette butts.
When we arrived, we found one of the off-duty cops handcuffing the guy who had stolen my bike. The detective asked me if that was the right guy. “Yes,” I quickly said, since I couldn’t wait to see him behind bars.
Catching Them Was Just the Beginning
I was ready for the cops to take me home and give me my bike back so I could end this miserable day (not to mention that I had a science test to study for). But I was told that my bike was now officially police evidence, and I would have to wait until after the court date to get it back.
“But why?” I asked. “We know that it’s my bike, we know this guy took it, we got witnesses, what more do we need? Can’t you just say ‘take him away boys,’ like they do it in the movies and throw this guy’s butt into jail?” Sorry, they said, we have to follow procedures.
First stop was the police station where I had to fill out this long form on what happened. When I finished, I asked them if I could go home. But we had no luck reaching my parents, so I had to wait till the cops could give me a ride. I didn’t get home till after 10 p.m. (Oh, by the way, I got a 72 on my science test the next day.)
Two weeks later, I received a summons to show up in court on a school day (there went my perfect attendance record). I borrowed my brother’s black suit even though it’s much too big and looked ridiculous on me. My parents, meanwhile, were saying, “It’s not a big deal, don’t get so excited over such a small case. Don’t you get it? It’s all just routine for them.” But no, I couldn’t believe that.
It’s Not Like On Tv
I felt as if I was fighting on the side of everyone who was ever mugged or hurt by an assailant. I had to win it for them, for us. I remembered a quote that I once saw on a police car, “To protect and to serve.” I remembered the amendments and laws that are supposed to help us. I mean, this wasn’t New York Undercover or some other television series. This was real life.
I wasn’t disappointed, not at first. From the outside, the courthouse was so huge and glorious, and there were so many lawyers dressed in suits, like myself.
When I went inside though, it didn’t look that fancy at all. A security guard at the desk said, “Sign in here please, go through there please,” and there was a metal detector, which wasn’t working too well since I was able to go through with my keys in my pocket. My parents’ tax money at work, I muttered.
I was directed to a room where I ended up waiting for the next three hours along with a whole bunch of other people. Then this guy came up to me and asked, “Are you Ovid Sanders?” I said, “Yes, that’s me.” He said, “Room B-12.” I later found out that he was the assistant district attorney trying my case.
In his office the attorney asked me questions like: “Where did this happen to you?” and “What time was it?” When we were done, I went back to waiting. I asked the attorney why it was taking so long, and he said the court had many cases to settle.
I wanted the attorney to pay more attention to me. But then I thought how hard lawyers and cops have it, dealing with robberies and worse crimes every day. They never get to see the positive side of people.
I wasted the day in those rooms with cigarette smoke wafting in from hallways, from under the doors. I felt punished for having dared to activate the system! I did nothing but sit and read some National Geographic magazines from 1968 (talk about boring).
I Take the Stand
At 2 p.m., after a four-hour wait, it was finally my turn, but I wasn’t that enthusiastic anymore. I also had a bad feeling. The guys who robbed me weren’t even in the courtroom.
“Where are they?” I asked the attorney. “Aren’t they supposed to be here? Is this a no-show?”
“They’re not supposed to be here,” he said, without offering any explanation.
I just answered my attorney’s questions like we had practiced. Ten minutes later, a man sitting near the judge wanted to know if I had ever provoked the guy who robbed me. I almost got up out of my seat. How could he even ask such a question? “Of course not,” I said. “I never did or said anything to him but ‘Here’s the money!’ ” The judge slammed his gavel and it was over. My case was the last one of the day.
I left the courtroom while the attorney stayed inside. Five minutes passed and then he came out and told me, “You can go home now. Everything’s fine.” I took that to mean I had won. (I later learned that the two guys got five years probation). I felt like screaming out the news. The attorney didn’t really care. To him, it was the same as his work yesterday and the day before. I never knew that something could mean so much to one person and almost nothing to someone else.
I Lost My Illusions
My day in court was nothing like the movies. You know, where the courtroom (not to mention the lawyers) seems so full of purpose and the justice system is complex and dramatic. Even though my case was considered a felony because one of the guys had pulled out a knife, it didn’t go to trial because the two guys pleaded guilty. The process was simple and boring. The court workers looked like they wanted to go home. I will never again have the same respect for a court case (fact or fiction).
A few weeks later, I went to get my bike back. I had to miss another day of school and my dad had to take off from work to bring me to this huge police property warehouse in Long Island City. I walked to the back, past a few cars, even a toaster oven (everything was placed according to value), until I saw my bike. One of the tires was deflated and my bike looked like it had been through a lot in the month since I lost it.
You Call That Justice?
Looking back on all this, I think that if I ever get robbed again, I probably would just give the bike up since it’d be less costly. If I had to put the event in terms of financial cost, from the cops who maybe had to ignore another call for mine, to the off-duty cops who could have been doing something else, to the cost of keeping the two robbers in jail, it’s a lot of the taxpayers’ money. Plus, my dad had to take a day off.
I had to go through a lot too. There was the stress of the robbery itself, doing badly on the science test and the pain of being jerked around by the whole system. Most of all, I regret losing my illusions that everything is perfect in the courtroom.
Of course I’m happy that I wasn’t hurt. It could have been worse, I could have been stabbed. I could be dead. And I realize that getting robbed of my bike isn’t the same as getting shot. But it was my first experience with crime and the feelings of being helpless. It was traumatizing.
In the end, I fixed my bike and the next day went riding…on the same street where it had been stolen. (I believe that if something bad happens, it’s best not to avoid the issue.) I still ride there. I look over my shoulder every once in a while, but I’m not going to let anyone stop me from riding my bike.
To Catch a Thief: A Long Wait for My Day in Court
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.