I’ve always wondered why a woman would want to be a construction worker, lifting heavy materials, wearing a hard hat and laboring outdoors in the extreme heat or cold. And why would women want to face the dangers and hardships involved in police work, fire fighting, and other traditionally male jobs?
I just assumed that most women chose traditionally female jobs like secretarial and office work because they liked wearing nice outfits, make-up and lipstick-something you can’t do on a construction site.
Besides, since women deal with a lot of harassment even in offices, why would they want to expose themselves to even greater problems in workplaces like police stations, fire houses and construction sites? (It’s bad enough for women to walk by a construction site, much less work at one.)
But I’ve noticed that more women are going for jobs in male-dominated careers that involve physical challenge or risk. To find out why, I spoke to some women working in “non-traditional” jobs including an electrician, a police officer and a telephone installer. I also visited an organization called Nontraditional Employment for Women (NEW) in Manhattan, which trains women to work in traditionally male skilled trades.
Why Should Men Make All the Money?
Probably the biggest reason women choose to work in male-dominated fields that require some skills and training (but not necessarily college) is money. “Blue collar work pays well without a college education,” said Rebecca Lurie, former program director for NEW. According to Kristen Watkins of Wider Opportunities for Women (WOW), a Washington, D.C.-based organization that works to create more jobs for women in skilled trades, a secretary’s typical weekly salary is $340, whereas a telephone installer (a typically male job) makes $556 a week.
The women I spoke to also said they chose these jobs for other reasons, like greater opportunities for advancement, better benefits, or because they get more satisfaction from the finished product, like something they’ve helped build, than from office work. So, who can blame women for putting on hard hats and going to work?
But what is it like for them when they are actually in these jobs, surrounded by men who are probably bigger and stronger and tougher? Do they enjoy it? Is it worth the price for the better pay? Here is a look at a few women’s experiences.
At Home In Construction
When I met Marilyn Meertins last spring she was working on a job as an electrician at the World Trade Center. Marilyn was trained as an electrician by NEW, where she came for help after trying many other kinds of jobs. She had worked in office jobs that didn’t pay well or interest her much; she had also worked as a private detective, a corrections officer, and a police officer.
Meertins wanted to learn about the building trades because she thought she could make a better living in that area. “I needed more money,” she said. “Men and women both have kids to feed and bills to pay, but the man will be making more money. Why should men make all the money?”
Meertins says she feels at home working in construction partly because she grew up around it. When she was a little girl in Guyana, she helped her father build a house. She says she now realizes that working in construction “was always in my heart.”
Harassing a Harasser
Nevertheless, Meertins has faced obstacles because of her sex. She recalls being harassed at a job site by a male co-worker who made insulting remarks. First she dealt with the problem by speaking to him, letting him know she wanted him to stop.
When he continued, she used a more aggressive approach: she repeated everything he said out loud so everybody else would know what was going on. She said that her other male co-workers came to her defense and let him know that his behavior wasn’t acceptable.
Now, Meertins says she doesn’t have problems with men she works with, perhaps because she has developed greater confidence in her ability. She tells other women following in her path: “Never underestimate yourself because you’re a female. Never limit yourself.”
Bored in the Office
When Christine Ix was growing up, she just assumed she would be a secretary. “My whole family went to secretarial school,” said Ix, and after graduating from high school, she did the same. The problem was she didn’t enjoy the work. “It was boring,” she says.
She heard about a job opening at NYNEX from her sister, and ended up doing something she would never have imagined: going to work as a technician for the phone company. (They sent her to school at Metro Tech in Brooklyn to train her to install phone wires.)
Now Ix has been promoted to switching equipment technician and she works out in the field. She wears a beeper and can be found carrying tools from building to building in midtown Manhattan where she works in basements, removing dial tones from old equipment and installing them in new equipment.
Although she is glad she made the change, Ix admits that the transition from office worker to phone technician wasn’t easy. “The first day on the job I cried,” Ix recalls. “It was very different for me. I had long nails…It was all very different in every aspect.”
But now she says she has no regrets about her choice to cross the barrier into a male-dominated field. “I love it,” she says. Unlike Marilyn Meertins, she has encountered little sexism among her male colleagues. Noting that with four to five years of experience, her position pays $46,000 a year, she feels she is well rewarded for her work.
Male Cops Don’t Want Female Partners
Like construction sites, police departments are another difficult place for a woman to break down gender barriers. Arlene Beckles, a New York City police detective, says that in her seven years on the force, there have been times she could not do her job because of the prejudice she encountered.
She recalls one supervisor who would take her male colleagues on raids and leave her behind, claiming that she didn’t have enough experience-even though she had more experience than most of the guys who went.
“Most of the men don’t feel that it’s for women,” Beckles said. When they need a partner, they usually won’t choose a woman, she said. The explanation the men on the force offer is, “If sh-t hits the fan, this person (a woman) won’t be a back-up.” She added that the male officers also say that women want to be on the job, but don’t want to do the job.
When she was young, Beckles didn’t plan to go into police work. Although she describes herself as a tomboy growing up, she planned to follow her father’s footsteps and become a nurse practitioner. “I wanted to be in a helping profession,” says Beckles.
Then, during her first year at Hunter College, she learned that her job responsibilities as a nurse would include changing sheets and bed pans, and she decided that was not for her. She transferred to John Jay College to study forensic science, and worked for a year as an intern at the Medical Examiner’s office. While she was still in school, she took the police exam and after graduating, she went on to the Police Academy.
It Helps To Be Tough
Beckles feels that being an “ex-tomboy” helped her through her initial training at the Academy. “It helps to be tough,” she says. “The gym was the toughest challenge for me-the workouts were tough.” But it helped prepare her for a rigorous career, where her work has taken her into tough situations like arresting drug dealers.
Beckles carries a gun “24 hours a day, seven days a week,” but has only fired it one time in her seven years on the force, during a highly publicized robbery at a beauty parlor while she was off-duty. “You hope that you can go 20 years without using your gun,” she says. “No cop wants to get into a gun fight.”
She has overcome the gender bias she has faced by doing her job well, earning a gold shield and the rank of detective, as well as the position of instructor at the Police Academy. But in spite of her own achievements, she would still like to see women on the force treated with greater equality. “They (men) don’t feel that you’ll (women) be as good as a man,” she said. “But they automatically give a man the respect, whether he’s good or not.”
Women in Non-Traditional Jobs: Makin’ It in a Man’s World
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.