I discovered what a horrible place the school cafeteria can be at the beginning of my freshman year at Curtis HS. I walked in expecting to see at least one familiar face but looked around only to find what seemed to be hundreds of strangers staring at me.
But it wasn’t just the strange faces, the smell, and the mile long lunch lines that turned me off. What bothered me most was the fact that it was the only place I was allowed to go. I felt that after sitting in classes all morning I should be free to leave the building and go outside. But not at my school.
For the first part of the year I forced myself to bear it. This was especially hard when my friends with the same lunch period were absent or cutting and I had to eat by myself. It’s one thing to eat lunch alone while you’re outside but it’s a completely different thing to eat by yourself in a high school lunchroom. All around you there are groups of kids talking and laughing and if you’re sitting by yourself, you can’t help but feel really out of place.
During the second semester I decided to try the library. I discovered that eating was not allowed there when the librarian, who spends most of her time kicking kids out, told me to throw out my food or leave. I decided the only solution was to leave the building. I had no trouble recruiting some of my friends to come along.
Getting Around the Rules
The problem was that leaving school before your classes are over isn’t allowed. If you got caught, your parents would be notified and you would probably be sent to the dean’s office. The school rule was that after three times you would be suspended, but I never actually heard of anyone getting suspended for going outside. I think that they said this mainly to scare us since they weren’t big on actually enforcing this rule.
Since Curtis has about seven exits and only half were always guarded, my friends and I were able to get around the rule. For about six months we went outside for lunch almost every day. The hard part was getting back in undetected since all the doors were locked from the outside. Usually it was just a matter of waiting a few minutes for some other kid to come out. When they did we would just sneak back in. My friends and I weren’t the only ones breaking this rule. No matter what time of day we went out, there would be at least 20 kids outside the school or by the deli next door.
In my opinion, you cannot give a person free time and then tell them what to do with it. If you do, then those people are obviously going to rebel. Regardless of the rules kids do not want to be in one place for six hours or however long the school day is.
My freshman year I got caught a couple of times on my way back in, but the only thing that happened was one of the teachers in the office would talk to me and threaten to call my parents. They usually didn’t. But that was before the student truancy program started.
A New Policy
I first heard about it last year when I was a sophomore. I heard there were going to be a whole bunch of police officers sent out to look for kids on the street who were supposed to be in school. Once they picked you up they would take you to the truancy headquarters, which on Staten Island was McKee HS. They would contact your school and call your parents and the whole event would be written up on your permanent school records.
During the first week after I heard this, I forced myself to stay in school. But once again I found it very hard to just sit in the lunchroom and sneak cigarettes in the girls bathroom. I decided that they weren’t going to stop me from enjoying the only period that I didn’t have to be sitting in a classroom. It just didn’t seem right that we weren’t allowed outside. It was as if we were prisoners.
My friends and I soon discovered that this truancy thing was no joke. We saw the blue and white truancy vans all over the area around our school. But we weren’t discouraged. The minute we would leave the school grounds we’d look around for one of the vans. If we spotted one we would run like a bunch of animals in the opposite direction.
Escapes and Hideouts
We found that if we walked on one-way streets and the truant officers came by we could just run in the opposite direction. By the time they came around the block to get us we would be long gone. We found every way to avoid getting caught. It soon became a big game for us, like Manhunt.
We discovered every “safe” place to hang out. One of our particular favorites was a covered garage behind an abandoned building about three blocks away from school. We even spent an hour once hiding behind parked cars in a parking lot because a truancy van was parked up the street. As a result of this we started to miss classes. The way I see it is that the whole truancy thing was actually keeping us out of school.
No Getting Away This Time
Towards the end of my sophomore year I was walking back to school with a bunch of other kids after another successful outing when one of those truancy vans started coming up the street. Suddenly I found myself standing there with one other kid as the rest of the group fled. The van pulled up to us and I knew that there would be no escaping this time.
There were three truant officers inside and they asked us to stop. At this point I started getting very nervous. They had on uniforms like school security guards. They didn’t seem to be in the mood for joking around. They asked why we weren’t in school. At first I made sure that I was very respectful and polite because I still thought there was a chance of getting myself out of the situation. When I started to explain that it was my lunch period the guy who was driving the van cut me off and told me to get in the van.
When I got in the van there were already three or four other kids inside. Instead of taking us back to our school they brought us to McKee HS. We were led into a room set up like the police station in NYPD Blue and told to fill out some forms with our name, age, school, etc. There were two real policemen in there but they didn’t say anything to me. I was beginning to feel like a criminal.
They Made Me Feel Like a Criminal
Then came the interview. I had to sit across from this man while he grilled me and took notes. I wasn’t sure if he was a truant officer or what because he didn’t have a uniform on but he was pretty rude and didn’t look up once. He asked me why I felt the need to cut out on my lunch break. I told him that I didn’t like the lunchroom and he told me that he didn’t like a lot of things. I could tell that he wasn’t going to be very understanding.
Next he called my high school and spoke to one of the deans and told him that I had been truanted. Then, while I was still sitting right across from him, he called my mother’s job. That was the worst part. Watching him dial those seven numbers was like torture. Fortunately my mom couldn’t come to the phone. I knew that she would understand if I was the one to tell her, but she wouldn’t be happy if she got a phone call at work.
When they were finally through with me they gave me a note to hand in to someone at my school and sent me on my way. (I was surprised they didn’t make sure that I actually went back.) When I got back I went straight to the dean’s office and gave the note to the teacher at the first desk I saw. He joked around with me for a while because he used to teach my older sister and then he told me not to do it again. That was the only thing that happened as far as getting any kind of punishment from my school.
When I explained to my mother what had happened she wasn’t very upset at all since it happened on my lunch period. I found the whole thing to be a waste of my time and theirs. I figured if that was all that happened when you cut out of school then I had nothing to worry about and it certainly wasn’t going to stop me from going outside.
Let’s Be Reasonable
I’m not suggesting that kids be allowed to run around unsupervised all day and just forget about school. I know that the schools are responsible for their students during the day and they can’t have them running all over the place. But since students are going to go outside anyway, wouldn’t it be safer if they were allowed to? Then most of them would stay near the school and go back in right after their lunch period. The way it is now, kids are scared of getting caught by the police so they aren’t going to be hanging around near the schools. That means that once they leave the building a lot of them won’t be returning that day.
This September I transferred to City-As-School, an alternative school, where I have a lot more freedom. It’s much easier to attend school knowing that I can run to the store if I want to and if I choose to go out for lunch I don’t have to sneak out a back door as if I’m breaking out of jail.
Putting more and more restrictions on kids isn’t going to stop that many from cutting. It’s just encouraging them to find more ways of getting around the rules.
SIDEBAR: Who’s a Truant?
After Mayor Giuliani took office, the Police Department started a major citywide push to cut down on truancy. In the past, the police had focused on a few places in the city like Times Square where they picked up kids they thought should be in school. Now there are specially trained police officers in all five boroughs assigned to stop teens or younger kids they suspect are out of school without permission. The number of kids they are picking up is huge. Since September 1994, 4,000 kids have been picked up. The total since last April is 8,000, according to the Board of Education. “It’s not a punitive thing,” said Bob Terte, a Board of Education spokesman. “The point is to get kids in school, where they belong. It’s safer in school.” When the police approach a truant they are supposed to ask for school identification and program cards. Their job is to find out if the student has a valid reason for being outside of school. (They will usually stop kids they find outside of school between the hours of 9 a.m. and 1 p.m.) Some of the reasons the police will accept include travel to jobs for co-op students, or to classes at another school. “The police officers are trained to know how to read a program card, and how to talk to teens,” said Francine Goldstein, executive director of Student Support Services for the Board of Education. Going out to lunch is not usually accepted as an excuse for being out of school. Out of concern for students’ safety, most city high schools now have what school officials call a “captive” lunch period, meaning that leaving the premises is not allowed, says Goldstein. If they find that a student is a truant, the police will take her to an assigned school in that borough or bring her back to her own school. Any student who is picked up will also be checked for weapons before being returned to school. At this point, the school authorities take over and the police’s involvement with the student is over (unless the student is carrying an illegal weapon). At the assigned school, the student is interviewed by an attendance teacher who will try to find out why she is cutting, and who will contact both her own school and her parents before sending her back to school. If they don’t reach a parent or guardian by phone, a written notice is supposed to be mailed to the student’s home. Students picked up for truancy are supposed to be placed in a drop-out prevention program and/or get counseling in their school.
