When we first walked into the downtown Brooklyn office of Alfred B. Curtis, the new Commissioner of the Department of Youth Services, we were a little nervous. It was the first time either of us had ever interviewed a public official and we were both worried that maybe he would just look at two teenage reporters, lick his chops, and mercilessly have us for breakfast.
When we actually met Mr. Curtis and saw his pink shirt and busy tie, we thought we were dealing with a real down-to-earth guy. With his cheery disposition and easy-going manner, he was nothing like the bloodthirsty politician we had been expecting. He seemed like a guy who was more than happy to share his vision for the future with the city’s teenagers. But, even though he treated us nicely, his answers to our questions weren’t very satisfying.
Getting To Kids Before the Cops Do
The Department of Youth Services (DYS) is the city office responsible for making sure that young people get the services they need. It funds non-profit organizations that provide tutoring, recreation, counseling, etc.
Before becoming commissioner, Mr. Curtis was a vice president at Chemical Bank and was active in community groups on Staten Island, including the NAACP. He told us he took the position at DYS because it would give him the chance to “be involved in something youth-oriented.”
Commissioner Curtis shared with us the three things he most wants to accomplish in his new position. His top priority is to make sure that some of the money that New York City receives from the recently passed federal crime bill is spent on programs that prevent crime and not just used for “enforcement”-hiring cops and building jails. “Enforcement is after you’ve gone wrong and the cuffs are put on you,” Curtis said. “So what I’m saying is, if we can work and come up with an equal balance of enforcement and prevention, we will have accomplished something here.”
The Money Trail
His second priority is to look at the process DYS uses to decide which youth organizations should get city money. This year, many well-respected groups including New Youth Connections, The Door, and Big Brothers/Big Sisters got their funding cut. Curtis said he found it hard to believe that NYC was cut. “It serves a purpose in the community…and prepares [kids] for the future,” he said.
While Curtis denied responsibility for the cuts, saying, “The funding decision preceded my tenure here,” he admits that mistakes were made. “If I had my druthers, I would have been more accommodating to those programs that have been functioning and that serve a purpose in the community,” he said.
He even went so far as to promise to re-examine the decision to cut the funding of New Youth Connections. “It’s difficult to believe that this type of program was defunded,” he said. “This should not have happened, and I’m going to investigate this.”
The Commissioner’s third priority is to increase the number of kids that DYS serves from the current 700,000 to 1 million.
Mentors and Role Models
But the thing he seemed most concerned about was not helping to create more youth programs or giving more money to the successful youth programs that already exist. The thing he talked about most was his belief that young people need role models and mentors to give them a sense of what they can achieve.
Giving young people what they need, Curtis said, is “a lot more than providing programs out in the community… You can learn by contact with someone, without someone actually paying an executive director out there to run a program.” For example, Curtis said, he’d like to get big corporations to sponsor retreats “where inner city youth come together and learn proper etiquette, learn what it’s all about to go on an interview, learn\hear success stories from corporate officers and presidents and those who retain a level of success.”
No Real Agenda
What’s the bottom line with this guy, you’re asking? Commissioner Curtis didn’t really seem to have a specific agenda. When it came to discussing the problems that teens face, he mentioned “crime, single parenting, in some instances, lack of role models” and “hopelessness, despair, no opportunity for jobs.” But he didn’t seem to have any ideas about what DYS could do to help teens solve those problems. He talked a lot about helping young people “channel their energies” and “reach their fullest potential” but without saying how he would make that possible. Commissioner Curtis made pretty speeches but he had no real agenda.
DYS Commissioner’s Message: Programs Are Good But…
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.