Changing Schools: It’s a Fight But You Can Win

Last summer, I made the decision to transfer to public school. For four years before that, I attended a religious Hebrew school, better known as a Yeshiva, which teaches you religion and then urges you to practice it.
What made me want to leave were all the restrictions: school didn’t end until 6 p.m.; it was all-boys and there was a dress code requiring full-length pants (no jeans) and a shirt with collar and buttons.
But transferring wasn’t as easy as I thought it would be. I couldn’t just walk into Brooklyn Tech and say, “I am here! Take me!” Even my parents didn’t have any suggestions to offer. I tried to fight my way into the principal’s offices of such prestigious Brooklyn schools as Edward R. Murrow, and Midwood, but I was never able to get past the security guard. Those guys were there to protect the principal from any intruders, and they took their job seriously.
A Long Wait At the Board of Ed
Eventually, I decided to go to the root of the problem-the Board of Ed. It took me about 10 phone calls to find out that the people I needed to speak to were “on hiatus” from their headquarters in Brooklyn (at 110 Livingston Street). So I had to drag myself and my busy mother all the way to their temporary Manhattan headquarters at the Comprehensive Night HS on Second Avenue (an hour subway ride away from my Bensonhurst neighborhood).
When I got there, I had to spend over two hours waiting on line only to find out that the only place they would allow me to transfer to was my zoned school, and I had no desire to study there. The school was OK, but I wanted to go somewhere with a prestigious reputation, and solid SAT averages, and that just wasn’t the case with my zone.
When another one of my school friends, who was very serious about leaving as well, was referred by the Board of Education to John Dewey HS in Brooklyn, I accompanied him, and had a chance to talk with the guidance counselor.
Dewey is an educational option school, where the schedule is very flexible, and students have a lot of say about how their schedules will look. Students there have free time during the day, which they can use for lunch, independent study, or just hanging out. Luckily, I had my transcript handy, and the guidance counselor assured me that my grades were good enough.
Help At Last
My image of a public school guidance counselor was that of an overworked, burnt-out stiff buried in paper work. But this guy couldn’t have been nicer.
He was also efficient. The day after I met him, the paperwork was finished, and I was officially a member of the John Dewey student body-five days before school began. Later on, during the first week of school, when I had no idea what was going on, he helped smooth my transition from the calm and quiet Yeshiva to the noisy and crowded Dewey.
Less than a month had passed since I first started plotting my “escape.” Every day had been filled with tension, despair, endless hours on lines and on the subway, and, of course, patience-testing telephone calls. At a certain point, I understood that there was no turning back. I had spent so much time and energy that it would have been ridiculous for me to and allow the bureaucracy to have its way.
Only the Persistent Survive
It was only then that I learned what “cutting through red tape” really means-a long process where only the persistent survive. Although public school wasn’t everything I expected, I did get the two things I coveted most: independence and individuality.
The valuable lesson that I got out of this was not to give up, and that’s my advice to all of you who want to transfer schools- find out all you can about different places from friends and family; choose schools where you think you will have the easiest time fitting in; keep bugging the bureaucrats until they cave in.
You might feel uncomfortable calling the same people again and again even though they refused to help you, but remember-it’s their job to help you, and it’s your responsibility to make sure they do their job well.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.