The Answer Isn’t Black or White

Around my block, people come up to me and ask the famous question, “What are you?” I get really upset when they ask that, because what they are really asking me is “Are you Black or White?” I have a hard time answering that question.
I know I confuse a lot of people because I have features from both my Black father and my White mother. People are just filled with questions. I get a lot of stares.
When they ask me the question, I say, “What do you mean?” My hair is blond, my skin is very light, and my eyes are hazel. Does that make me White? So what about the slang I talk and the kinky texture of my hair? Does that make me Black?
In my group home, the majority of residents are Black. When I first walked in I was scared, because of past problems I’ve had with people who were confused about my race.
Made to Feel White
Now I’m not so much scared, but just trying to be me. It’s hard trying to be me, because people want me to choose one race over the other.
I am close to a lot of the girls in my house and in my agency. Some of my closest friends are the girls I was once afraid of when I first came to the group home.
When we talk to each other there is nothing that separates us. We talk about the racial problems in Crown Heights and the rest of the city. We talk about our family problems and just about anything else that friends talk about.
But my other Black friends who are outside of foster care often make me feel White. The other day I was in a coffee shop with some of my friends. Our waitress happened to be White. My friends complained about everything from having a spot on a paper napkin to the coffee not being hot enough.
I asked them why they were being so mean to the waitress. One of my friends said, “Now that slavery is over, it’s the White people’s turn to suffer.” She turned to me and said, “Shell, you don’t know nothing about that.” When my friends get angry, they will accuse me of being the “other” race. I felt so hurt that I just got up and left my friends sitting there.
Some people on the street look at my Black friends and try to figure out what I am. They assume that if I am hanging out with Black people, of course I’m Black. But when I hang out with my friends who are Puerto Rican, right off the bat they assume I am Puerto Rican. I always get stares from people trying to figure out what I am.
But what if I’m hanging out with friends from different races? Those people who were wondering before must be really confused now.
The ‘Other’ Race
I get a lot of funny comments when I go for a job interview. On the applications they always ask about my racial background. They say it is optional and if I don’t answer, it’s okay. I always mark down the space “other.”
But then they always ask what race I am in the verbal interview. I get upset because I don’t understand what my racial background has to do with the job I’m applying for. When the interviewer asks me what I mean by “other,” I tell him/her that I am part of the human race. I feel it is impossible to choose between the two races.
Many times I’ve heard from family and friends that the “Black genes” in me dominate. A friend once told me she could show me what she meant. She had two cups. One was filled with black paint and the other one was filled with white paint. She mixed them both together and asked me what color I saw more.
I told her I saw the black paint more than the white. She said since the black paint dominates over the white, the “Black genes” in my body dominate over the “White genes.”
She showed me this experiment because she felt that I should know that I am Black. In an earlier conversation with her, she thought I was “acting like a White person” because I was talking to her all proper and correct. She told me I should learn how Black people act and that’s why she showed me the paint. I don’t think that paint and humans should be compared like that.
And I really don’t understand why she thought I was “acting White.” I was acting the way I always do around anyone, Black or White.
So I’m Black, but what about my White side? Do I just forget about it? Can I forget about my White mother? That is not possible. But I can’t forget about my Black father either.
It’s crazy when the KKK talks about sending all the Black people back to Africa. So what happens to me? Will half of me get sent back to Africa and the other to Israel? (My mother is Jewish). That will be kind of messy.
I think people in general just look at me and want me to choose. To be honest, I don’t know how to choose.
‘Oreo’ and ‘Zebra’
I first became aware of the racism problem was when I was in elementary school. There was another girl in the class who was also interracial but her features were all White. They really never questioned her. But the kids in my class were always asking me what I was. Really not knowing what they meant, I just ignored them. They teased me, calling me “Oreo” and “zebra.”
But being interracial meant more than name calling. It also meant fights.
I used to go to school with White girls who lived in a part of Brooklyn called Gerritsen Beach. When I went to their houses, I saw graffiti on the walls of old, rundown houses saying “White Power.”
My first taste of what that really meant was when I had an argument with one of the girls I went to school with. I think what caused the fight was that the girls found out that I was half-Black and now thought that I was “acting White.” Before they thought I was all-White because I made sure they never saw my Black father. I was afraid of what might happen if they found out.
But when one of the girls found out, she told the kids who were in the White Power gang. Well, I couldn’t fight them all, so I grabbed one and beat the living daylights out of her and the rest of the girls left me alone.
When I was in a Residential Treatment Center upstate, everyone knew I was proud to be from an interracial family.
But some of the newer girls did not like that I could get along with everyone on the campus. They wanted everyone to stick to their own race. So they planned to jump me. My friend overheard them, and I went to their room and told them that if they had a problem, they should bring it outside.
I sat on the bench outside the cottage and waited for them. They never came outside. I later found out that they changed their minds and took their anger out on a staff and then AWOLed from the RTC.
But I was not always so lucky in fighting about my identity. My days when I was in Spofford, I was jumped in the showers because I told a girl it was none of her business what I was. Unfortunately, I lost that fight. Later I found out that the girl told her friends that I was a White person “trying to be Black.”
Hispanic Stereotypes
I’ve not only gotten into fights for “acting White” and “acting Black.” I’ve also had fights with people who don’t like me because they think I’m Hispanic.
My friends and I were hanging out in a park one day when a group of Black brothers came up to us and starting saying “Ay mommy,” an expression that is often said to Spanish women. Some of my friends thought what they were saying was cute. I don’t like being called “Ay mommy.” I am no one’s mommy and I feel it is disrespectful. I turned my back on them and tried to continue the conversation we were having before they came over to us.
One of the guys must have thought my turning away disrespectful because he started cursing me out, saying, “Who the f-ck do you think you are?” He reached over and grabbed my butt and said, “Puerto Rican girls are hoes and they like to be touched like this.”
When he tried to touch me again, I reached down and grabbed his crotch and said, “Yeah, and all Black people like ham hocks and corn bread.”
His friends were laughing at him and he was begging me to let go. After he begged for a while I let go, and my friends and I walked out the park laughing. When we got the other side of the park, he was still lying on the ground, yelling at his friends to stop laughing.
After what I did to the guy I felt kind of bad, but I was angry that he tried to label all Puerto Rican girls as hoes and sluts.
Best of Both Worlds?
Personally, I think that some people are always going to have something to say about my race or my races. As I said before, I am part of the human race.
I don’t think there should be labels such as “Black” or “White.” I could never understand why there are categories when people are more complicated than any category.
One advantage I have is that I know both cultures and I’m able to relate to both worlds. My mother and sister say to me, “You have the best of both worlds.” But I often don’t feel that’s true because of all the problems I’ve had in my past.
Sometimes I think the only thing I’ve learned from being an interracial child is how to fight.
I have changed in the way I deal with people’s stares and questions. When I was younger, I always wanted to fight every time someone tried to ask me a question about my background. Now I try to remain calm and answer their questions. But if I feel they are trying to disrespect me, I ignore them.
I wish things could be different between the races, but we would have to go back a lot of years just to correct some people’s ignorant mistakes. Racism is alive and kicking, especially for people who are the products of interracial families.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.