Cops and Teens: Can We Meet Each Other Half Way?

Nagib Nabi, 17, of City College, was on his way to a party one night when he was stopped by a squad car. Nagib says the cops accused him of throwing a bottle at them. He told the cops that he hadn’t done anything but they started frisking him anyway.
The cops “tried to intimidate me by calling me ‘sp-c’ and other insulting names,” Nagib said. “I was asking why they were doing this to me, and they threw me on the wall, and as I turned around they hit me with the baton on the back of my head,” said Nagib. Eventually, they let him go.
Because of this experience, Nagib thinks that most cops “see teens as criminals.” Now, whenever Nagib sees a cop, “what’s on my mind is if he’s going to come up to me and ask questions like I’m a suspect.”
Lots of teens share Nagib’s impression of police officers; they have what Officer Dennis Fitzgerald of the 10th precinct in Manhattan calls a “bad guy stereotype” of cops.
Who’s Stereotyping Who?
In fact, a lot of the tensions that exist between cops and teens seem to come from the fact that members of each group feel that they are unfairly stereotyped by the other.
Rose Negron, youth officer at the 42nd precinct in the Bronx, said that teens seem to feel that the police “don’t understand them…that we’re abusive… and that we pick on them.”
The cops I interviewed felt these generalizations were unfair. It also bothered them to hear that teens feel most cops stereotype young people.
Officer Beverly Riggins, who works in the Police Department’s personnel bureau as a recruiter, said, “I myself don’t have stereotypes of teens, because I grew up in the urban community, and I know what being a teenager in New York City is all about.”
Karen Delancey, the youth affairs officer at the 10th precinct in Manhattan was another cop who said she doesn’t prejudge teens. “I gotta see them, I gotta meet them…I gotta know them,” she said. “I can’t generalize them, it would not be fair.”
It’s Not Like On TV
The officers I spoke to said that another problem for them is that most teens don’t know much about what they really do on the job. Officer Riggins said that “the teens have negative ideas based on television programs; our jobs are nowhere near what television portrays.”
Officer Delancey agreed. She said that people call the police whenever they “can’t handle the situation” they’re in. A lot of the time, there’s no crime involved-people call when they lock themselves out of their cars or when their kids are having a fight they can’t break up, for example. In fact, much of a police officer’s job involves “keeping the peace”-responding to all kinds of problems.
“People call us because their toilet is stopped up,” Delancey said. “You don’t see that on the news, do you?”
But the cops admitted that they’re not always so friendly when they’re dealing with someone who has committed a crime.
“If you’re on the wrong side, you’re going to have dealings with us,” said Officer Negron. “And of course those dealings are not always going to be positive…In general, I deal with youngsters when they’re in trouble, so yeah, there are tensions.”
But Negron added that when she works with kids who are involved in the Police Athletic League (PAL), “there are no discipline problems or tensions.”
The cops I spoke with said they’d like teens to remember that being a police officer is not an easy job. They have to do a lot of different things, deal with all kinds of people, and handle dangerous situations.
Officer Riggins advises that “Before you assume what a police officer’s job is or what he should be doing, find out the facts, and [don’t] take someone else’s word for it.”
Become a Cop? No Thanks
When asked, most teens I spoke with admitted that being a cop was a tough job. I asked if they would consider becoming cops when they were older and they all said “no.”
Shamik Bernard, 16, said, “It seems dangerous. Everybody’s carrying guns now.” Nagib agreed: “In the future the job is going to get worse because of the drugs and guns and stuff,” he said.
Gerald Felix, 19, of City College, was the only one who wouldn’t consider it solely because of his negative feelings about cops. “That’s public enemy number one,” he said.
Other teens expressed feelings about cops that were more mixed. “Some of them are nice, they’ll talk to you, but some of them have an attitude,” said Shamik. “I have nothing against them, though…’cause you know, sometime you’re going to need their help.”
Cindy Ming (not her real name), 18, has had several encounters with cops-some negative and some positive. For example, one day she was sitting in a bakery drinking coffee with her friends, when a police officer came in. The cop pulled a young man from Cindy’s table, smacked him on the back of the head, and left.
“Nobody did anything,” said Cindy. “We just sat there and watched the cop walk out.”
Cindy said she “really hated” cops for awhile after that and a couple of other bad experiences. But there was another time, she said, when “there was a problem at my house and two of the cops that came by…were very nice.” Now she sees “some of them as being helpful.”
Respect Each Other
The cops I spoke to want teens to give them the benefit of the doubt-to not assume that all cops are bad based on stereotypes and hearsay.
“We’re not out there to antagonize or oppress, we’re out there to maintain the peace,” said Officer Fitzgerald. “We’re into going out there on foot to see how the community ticks…Trying to maintain a friend image.”
Both cops and teens agreed that both sides have to make more of an effort to treat each other fairly. “The cops have to be less aggressive and teenagers have to cool down about the cops,” said Nagib. Officer Delancey agreed. “I think the cops and the teens have to come to a happy medium,” she said.
Gerald Felix advised cops to “try to understand how teenagers feel toward them, and try to ease the tension.” As for teens, they should “try to respect [cops], they’re the law.” Cindy said that both sides could “try to be a little more polite” to each other.
James O’Neal, the director of Legal Outreach, an organization that helps teenagers understand the workings of the criminal justice system, may have put it best: “The most important thing is [that] cops and teens not act based upon fear but…interact based upon mutual respect.”

SIDEBAR: Know Your Rights
If the police stop and question you you should remain calm and not make abusive statements or gestures. If you don’t feel good about what’s happening or you think talking could get you in deeper trouble, tell the police you want to have a parent or a lawyer present before you answer any questions. They may not like that, and may try to provoke you, but stay calm. You have the right to remain silent until you get legal advice. If you feel the police have mistreated you, don’t lose control. You can memorize the police officer’s badge number, record the time and place of the incident, and his or her physical description. Then make a complaint by calling one of the following numbers. (You don’t have to give your name.) Who to call: o For complaints against the police call the Civilian Complaint Review Board at 212-323-8750 o To find out about the Precinct Youth Councils and help improve relations with the police, call your local precinct-get the number by calling 212-374-5000 o If you have information about a violent crime call Crime Stoppers-at 212-577-TIPS. You don’t have to give your name.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.