Speakout on Gays and Lesbians

Are You or Aren’t You?
Are you gay or straight? How can you be sure?
(ÀEres homo o heterosexual? ÀC—mo puedes estar tan seguro/a?)
Frank Tsai, 18, Benjamin N. Cardozo HS: Straight. I never had any sexual desires with the same sex and never wanted to. I hope I never do.
Andy Montaya, 17, Brooklyn Tech HS: I’m gay. I’m sure I’m gay because ever since I’ve had sexual fantasies, they’ve been about men. I’m only sexually stimulated by men. It’s always been like that.
Elaine Yu, 18, Benjamin N. Cardozo HS: Straight. It’s a feeling thing. It’s something inside of you. I can’t imagine marrying a girl.
Michael Haz, 19, Baruch College: Yo se que soy homosexual porque desde mi infancia me atraen las personas de mi mismo sexo. Me siento m‡s confortable y libre cuando comparto con homosexuales como yo.
Carlos Singh, 16, Jamaica HS: Straight, because I don’t have romantic sexual feelings for no homeboy.
Juan Rojas, 18, International HS: Yo soy heterosexual y puedo estar seguro porque las œnicas personas que me atraen sexualmente son las del sexo opuesto.
Can You Tell?
Can you tell if someone else is gay or straight? How?
(ÀSe nota la sexualidad de una persona? ÀC—mo?)
Carlos Singh: Yes, because a gay person walks feminine, and their voice is sissyish.
Aikel Salazar, 16, Queens Vocational HS: No, you can’t. Well you can’t judge people by appearance. Unless they are extremely out of it and dress like a girl or something.
Michael Haz: Yo tengo meses que comparto mucho con homosexuales y he aprendido que mirando a los ojos se puede saber si es homosexual uno. Muchas personas piensan que ser afeminado es ser homosexual, pero eso no es verdad. Yo he salido y conozco a [hombres homosexuales] que son completamente masculinos.
Andy Montaya: You can never tell someone’s sexual orientation by looking at them. Unless the word straight or gay is all over them. However I sometimes feel, or pick up, gay vibes. That is, I “feel” that someone is gay.
Mary Magsanoc, 15, Jamaica HS: You can’t tell if a person is gay or straight; just like you can’t tell if a person has AIDS.
Eboni Justice, 17, Andrew Jackson HS: To tell you the truth, no. The only way I can detect that someone is gay, is if they come up to me and tell me.
Keisha Scott, 15, Far Rockaway HS: No. Different people present themselves in different ways so you can’t tell.
Do You Know Any?
Do you have any gay friends? Would they tell you if they were?
(ÀTienes amigos que son homosexuales? ÀTe dir’an si lo fuesen?)
Sa–a Eddings, 17, Far Rockaway HS: I have gay family members, but they’re just like family.
Andy Montaya: Yes, I have many gay friends. Most friends come out of the closet to me. They tend to trust me.
Jade Beckham, 17, Brooklyn Tech HS: I have tons of gay friends.
Michael Haz: Dir’a que mis œnicos amigos que saben mis cosas personales son homosexuales. Creo que no me dir’an porque la critica y el miedo a esta sociedad no deja que muchos homosexuales expresen sus sentimientos abiertamente.
Eboni Justice: No, not that I know of, all my aquaintances like guys-not girls. They ain’t funny honey. I don’t know, it’s up to them if they want to tell me if they’re gay or a lesbian. It’s all up to them. I’m not going to force it out of them.
Yessenia Rosario, 16, International HS: Yo nunca he tenido amigos homosexuales o amigas lesbianas. Tampoco creo que me lo dir’an si lo fueran, pienso que les dar’a vergŸenza.
Some of My Best Friends Are. . .
How would you react if your best friend told you she/he was gay?
(ÀC—mo reaccionar’as si tu mejor amigo/a te dijera que es homosexual?)
Sarah Yu, 18, Benjamin N. Cardozo HS: As long as they’re not attracted to me. At first, I would feel uncomfortable. Then I would get used to it.
Carlos Singh: I wouldn’t respect them. If I found out Tyrone was gay, I’d say, OK dude, it’s alright. Then I go behind his back, tell my boys, and we jump him.
Mary Magsanoc: I would try to understand what they have decided and just be a friend.
Yessenia Rosario: Si mi mejor amiga me dijera que es lesbiana yo me llevar’a una desilusi—n bastante fuerte. Yo me alejar’a de inmediato de ella.
Sonia Penny, Far Rockaway HS: I would be shocked, terrified, and at first I wouldn’t believe her. I would ask her why she chose to be gay.
Sharlotte Spencer, 15, Graphic Communication Arts HS: I would say get the f-k out my face, I don’t want to see you no more. That’s if it was a girl. If it was a boy I would say that he has problems and he’s supposed to like girls.
Julie Persaud, 16, Queens Vocational HS: I would support them. They would still be my best friend. Unless they make a pass at me.
Andy Montaya: If my best friend told me he or she was gay, I’d feel happy for him or her-that we could share intimate thoughts. I’d also feel sorry that he or she would probably suffer a lot. I’d still love them, just as much.
Sa–a Eddings: I’d be mad ‘cuz then we couldn’t go to the mall looking for guys.
Gays at School?
Do you have gay people in your school? Gay teachers?
(ÀHay homosexuales en tu escuela? ÀMaestros?)
Mary Magsanoc: I don’t know. It’s none of my business.
Juan Rojas: En mi escuela hay maestros homosexuales. Cuando me entere me quede un poco asombrado pero despues me acostumbre a la idea.
Jade Beckham: Yes, my school has a gay/lesbian/bisexual club. There are a lot of them. We also have a great deal of homosexual teachers.
Alejandro Castro, 18, International HS: En mi escuela hay maestros que son homosexuales. Yo pienso que eso est‡ mal porque ellos son los primeros que dicen que son el ejemplo y hay que ver que ejemplo nos est‡n dando.
Andy Montaya: There are many gay people in my school. We also have gay teachers but I don’t know if they are out [in school]. I do know they are out, I’ve seen them at gay events.
Elaine Yu: There is a great chance because Cardozo is very diverse. There are all types of people.
Teachers?
How would you feel if you found out one of your teachers was gay?
(ÀC—mo se sentir’a si te diera cuenta que uno de tus maestros es homosexual?)
Jae Choi, 18, Benjamin N. Cardozo HS: It wouldn’t really matter. As long as they are good teachers. If they hit on the students and talk about homosexuality with no relation to the subject they’re teaching, it matters.
Nidhi Singh, 16, Benjamin N. Cardozo HS: I don’t think I’d feel any different. It’s just a teacher-student relationship. It’s not personal so it doesn’t matter.
Andy Montaya: I would be so happy to know one of my teachers was gay.
Julie Persaud: It won’t bother me, I guess-if they acted normal.
Shirley Xiao, 18, Benjamin N. Cardozo HS: That’s outside my life. It’s their business. It wouldn’t bother me.
Sharlotte Spencer: Nothing. I would feel normal, but I wouldn’t want to be around them.
Andre Long, 18, Queens Vocational HS: Different and odd. I feel that sometimes teachers will have to show their emotions to the students.
Yessenia Rosario: Yo me sentir’a muy mal porque la verdad es que a m’ no me gustan esas personas. Yo pienso que si Dios hizo la mujer para el hombre y el hombre para la mujer Àpor que ahora viene a hacer todo lo contrario?
Carlos Singh: I would get out of his class.
Fate or Choice
Is it possible to turn gay or turn straight? Is it something you can choose?
(ÀEs posible convertirse en homosexual o heterosexual? ÀEs algo que se escoge?)
Sa–a Eddings: I think sexuality is learned, your not born with it!
Sonia Penny: It depends on how you feel towards the opposite sex. It burns within you. Some people act gay for fun, or they cannot be satisfied with the opposite sex,
LaShawn Derby, 16, Far Rockaway HS: I think it’s something you know from the very beginning. When you hear about people who are married and they just find out that they’re gay, I think they knew it all along.
Jae Choi, 18, Benjamin N. Cardozo HS: It’s not possible. To please people, they might turn straight from the outside. It’s a feeling. It’s like telling someone who’s straight to turn gay.
Shirley Xiao, 18, Benjamin Cardozo HS: You can’t choose. It’s natural, inherited. If you have feelings for the same sex, it’s just natural.
Michael Haz: Nadie se cambia por nadie. Por lo tanto ser homosexual no es una decisi—n que se toma de la noche a la ma–ana. Ser homosexual es un instincto que llevas contigo.
Julie Persaud: Yes, people choose if they want to be gay or straight. They choose what sexual partner they want.
Andre Long, 18, Queens Vocational HS: Yea, it’s possible. Because you got a lot of bisexual people out there who like the opposite and the same sex at the same time.
Yessenia Rosario: Si tu quieres ser homosexual lo eres desde peque–o y si quieres ser heterosexual eres as’ desde peque–o.
Mary Magsanoc: No. I think it could be hereditary and I don’t think people choose to be; it just happens.
Fate or Choice
Is it possible to turn gay or turn straight? Is it something you can choose?
(ÀEs posible convertirse en homosexual o heterosexual? ÀEs algo que se escoge?)
Sa–a Eddings: I think sexuality is learned, you’re not born with it!
Sonia Penny: It depends on how you feel towards the opposite sex. It burns within you. Some people act gay for fun, or they cannot be satisfied with the opposite sex.
LaShawn Derby, 16, Far Rockaway HS: I think it’s something you know from the very beginning. When you hear about people who are married and they just find out that they’re gay, I think they knew it all along.
Jae Choi: It’s not possible. To please people, they might turn straight from the outside. It’s a feeling. It’s like telling someone who’s straight to turn gay.
Shirley Xiao: You can’t choose. It’s natural, inherited. If you have feelings for the same sex, it’s just natural.
Michael Haz: Nadie se cambia por nadie. Por lo tanto ser homosexual no es una decisi—n que se toma de la noche a la ma–ana. Ser homosexual es un instincto que llevas contigo.
Julie Persaud: Yes, people choose if they want to be gay or straight. They choose what sexual partner they want.
Andre Long: Yea, it’s possible. Because you got a lot of bisexual people out there who like the opposite and the same sex at the same time.
Yessenia Rosario: Si tu quieres ser homosexual lo eres desde peque–o y si quieres ser heterosexual eres as’ desde peque–o.
Mary Magsanoc: No. I think it could be hereditary and I don’t think people choose to be; it just happens.
Changing Times?
Do you think people’s attitudes about gays and lesbians are changing? How?
(ÀCrees que las actitudes de la gente est‡n cambiando acerca de este tema? ÀC—mo?)
Carlos Singh: No. A lot of people think the way I do, which is straight up bash ’em. This gay thing won’t get far. They’ll be pushed back into the closet before you know it.
Mary Magsanoc: No, no, no…There is a lot of gay bashing in this country. [People] use them as a joke when they should be taken seriously.
Juan Rojas: Ahora mismo las actitudes sobre este tema est‡n cambiando bastante. Ya los estan aceptando y tom‡ndolos m‡s en cuenta.
Andre Long: Yes, because at one time, people used to physically hurt gays and lesbians. And plus it was a happily kept secret. Within the last 10 years gays have [moved] themselves from being secretly kept to a big population group.
Sharlotte Spencer: No, they should not give gay people respect. Gays are nasty. God didn’t make girls [to] like girls and guys [to] like guys.
Aikel Salazar: I don’t know. It’s hard to tell, like a lot of people don’t like gays and lesbians. They think they’re strange.
Michael Haz: La homosexualidad es un tema que est‡ en las primeras planas de los medios noticiarios…La homosexualidad ha dejado de ser un tabœ en nuestra sociedad actual.
Jae Choi: People are hostile to gays, especially people who go to church. [But] people are talking about it more. Things are changing.
Frank Tsai: Attitudes are definitely not changing, mainly because of religion. The U.S. is mainly Christian and they believe that homosexuality is a sin.
LaShawn Derby: I don’t think that, for the most part, ideas have changed. But with all the publicity gays and lesbians have been getting people are not as outspoken in voicing their disapproval.
Sa–a Eddings: Yeah, as the gays are speaking out more. People are listening to them. Before they were in the closet, now they’re out!
Nidhi Singh: Not really changing. But people are more open about it. Gradually, very gradually they’ll change.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.