The Pros and Cons of Catholic School

As a freshman at Brooklyn Tech HS, Vanessa Morais, now 16, was cutting class and generally messing up. Because it was a school of more than 3,000 students, Vanessa said that her teachers seemed to be less willing to help her and didn’t notice when she wasn’t in class; they had so many other students to deal with. “I wanted to get the hell out of there-as far [away] as possible,” said Vanessa. “I felt that I would have a better chance in a smaller school. A school where I would be considered a person and not a number.”
The following year, Vanessa decided to attend St. Jean Baptiste, a small parochial school of about 430 students. She says she’s happy with her decision. She knows the teachers and the teachers know her.
All three of the students I interviewed who had experienced the two worlds of public and Catholic schools said that given a choice they would take the latter. Tanya English, 16, of Julia Richman HS went to Catholic school in junior high. She says it’s not so much that the education is better, it’s just that there are fewer distractions and more discipline. “In a Catholic school, the teachers have more control over the students,” she explained.
Tanya feels that, at her school, the students are a big part of the problem. “Classes are overcrowded with people who just don’t care…people who are talking and disrespecting the teachers,” she said. “It’s not that Julia Richman is a bad school, it is the fact that Julia Richman accepts anybody from anywhere.” She gave the example of a student that came there from Rikers Island-Tanya was shocked. “People may enroll, but they don’t attend,” she added. “It brings the attendance down and gives us a bad rep.”
Students Share the Blame
While Tanya admits that a few of her teachers just don’t give a damn (she recalls one teacher saying “I’m going to get paid whether you learn or not”), she thinks that most try but have a hard time dealing with the students who are just going to school for fun.
“In Catholic school the people who are popular are the people with good grades,” she said. “But in my school the people who are popular are the ones who get pitiful grades and act like retarded fools…In order to survive and be successful you must be a self-motivated person and do what you have to do, otherwise you’re just another lost person.”
Maria Rodriguez (not her real name), 17, of Cathedral HS, said that the public school that she attended (LaGuardia HS) was “too loose of an environment…In LaGuardia many people couldn’t give a sh-t if they learned or not,” she said. She too complained of overcrowded classrooms and teachers who didn’t always give her the encouragement she needed or pay attention when she cut class. “The teachers at my [new] school take more of an interest in me and that makes me want to achieve more,” she said.
Too Much Uniformity
But Maria admits that parochial schools aren’t perfect. At Cathedral, Maria has to wear a uniform every day. She says in one way it’s a good thing because you don’t have to worry about what everyone else is wearing but it also takes away your individuality and creativity. “Private school tries to keep everyone unified,” she said. “Like the uniform, it doesn’t allow you to express yourself.”
Vanessa said that although her new school gives her the attention she was missing at Brooklyn Tech, she wishes St. Jean Baptiste offered more advanced placement and honors courses like they had at Tech. Maria agrees. Even though she says there’s a “strong interest in education” at her school, she’d like to see more competitive courses.
Academically, Vanessa believes Tech was a better school than the one she goes to now. In English and History “you do a lot of writing at Brooklyn Tech,” she said. “At St. Jean Baptiste there is an emphasis on grammar.” She also wonders why her school offers Physical and Earth Science in your freshman year while many other schools offer Biology. Brooklyn Tech also offers programs in medicine, advertising and many other things that prepare students for college. And Vanessa doesn’t like the way St. Jean Baptiste groups or tracks people according to a placement test they take in their freshman year. “Why are there only five people in a Calculus class?” she asked. “Why don’t we have more honors classes?”
To Each Her Own
There are also fewer activities and sports at Vanessa’s new school. If you are an “outgoing” type of person you might be happier at Brooklyn Tech, she said. But for her, it was important to have the individual attention and discipline offered by a Catholic school. “It all depends on the individual,” she said.
Tanya said she wishes she could go to another school-“any school except Richman.” She remembers Catholic school as being a place where you didn’t have to worry about uncontrollable students because not everyone could get in. “People in my school have a lot more distractions and pressures to deal with-everyday life in school, home, and community,” she said. “In Catholic school it’s just easier to learn.”

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.