He Wanted More than Friendship

It was my 17th birthday. My mom had taken me to the store to buy me my present-an electric guitar. We were walking home at around 9 p.m. when, to our surprise, this man on a bicycle pulled up and started talking to us.
“Hey, is that an electric guitar you have?” he asked me.
I said, “Yes,” even though I was wondering, “What’s it to him?” I tugged mom to communicate that I wanted to keep moving and ignore this guy. But mom, being the open person she is, wanted to stay and chat awhile.
“You play a lot, huh?” he asked.
“Yes,” I said.
“I play a lot too,” he continued. “I listen to Jimi Hendrix, Eric Clapton, some blues guitarists, and vintage rock guitarists.” He talked about how he hoped to improve his playing and play in a band someday. He introduced himself and shook my hand.
Two Guitarists
It seemed that this guy James (not his real name) and I had a lot in common. I thought to myself: Wow! How fate works in mysterious ways. I’ve had the good fortune to meet a genuine guitarist who can help me with my music and teach me playing techniques. I was very excited about this and said a thing or two about my interests. I said that I too listened to Jimi Hendrix and some other rock guitarists. He said that maybe we could jam together some day. I said, “O.K.”
“Wow! This is great, finding a female who is in the business. I’ve been unable to find someone I can communicate with.” Then he started telling my mom and me his life story-that he lived by himself because he lost his mother earlier in the year and his sister was away at college. As he went on talking, I wondered, what is he telling us all this for?
I looked at mom, hoping she would get the idea that this guy might be a bit disturbed and perhaps we should walk away from him. But no, mom was too taken in by his life’s misfortunes to leave.
What’s Your Sign?
James struck me as an intelligent individual, but I couldn’t help but wonder, was he sick in the head? First he talked about music, then he moved on to his dead mother, and now he was talking about astrology. He said that he believed in the stars and how they have the power to bring people together. He said that it was no accident that we met; destiny made it happen.
Mom smiled, but I thought, O.K., it’s time to go, he’s getting too astrological on me. Just then I heard him saying, “I know, you’re a Scorpio, right?” Surprised, I said “yes” and asked him how he knew. His response was, “I saw it in your eyes.”
I told him that it was my birthday and that the guitar was my present. He said he wanted to give me a gift also. I told him that he didn’t have to, but he insisted. We exchanged phone numbers and addresses. I felt a little uncomfortable doing this, but mom insisted. I wondered why she was being so trusting. We didn’t know who this guy was; he could be a loony. People don’t just meet other people on the street and tell them their life’s history. It was too weird.
The conversation ended and mom and I headed home. I asked her why she encouraged the conversation. She looked at me, smiled, and said, “Be courteous. Who knows, maybe he can help you in your music career.”
A Book and a Poem
A few days later, I received a belated birthday present from James. It was a guitar chord book. He also sent me a card and in it was a poem entitled, “I Met” which he had written about our encounter. In it, he described how lovely my eyes were and how mysterious I was.
I was flattered but then I thought, gee, I shouldn’t let it go to my head. It is rare for a guy to tell a girl about her eyes and all, if he’s just wanting friendship. I hoped that he wasn’t looking for something more.
I called James to thank him for the gift and we spent two hours on the phone with him telling me about his dead mother. I thought, let go of it already, she’s dead. I wanted to hang up the phone but I thought, let me be courteous like my mom brought me up to be. I felt the least I could do was listen to him, given all the bad luck life had dealt him.
It seemed like James was very depressed and down all the time. He even said that he had lost the thrill of playing music, but he found it again when he met me and saw my eyes. He said they were inspirational.
Constant Phone Calls
The very next day, around 5 o’ clock, he called me and spoke about how much of an influence I’d been on him artistically. I modestly said, “Thank you.” Then he started to get a little more personal. He kept saying, “I wish you were my age [he was 27], so we could hang out and have fun. A lot of the girls I used to go out with were not artists like myself. But you play and I like that about you. I also like your eyes.”
After that, he’d call five, six times a week and talk to me for a very long time. Mom, although she thought of him as a nice guy, became very annoyed at his many calls to the house. It began to bother me too. I wondered, doesn’t he have anything better to do? Why does he keep calling? Does he like talking to me? But I never asked him any of these questions. He kept hinting that he was interested in more than just friendship but since he never really came on to me, I pretended I didn’t notice.
This went on for about three weeks. We never saw each other, we only talked on the phone. He often played the guitar over the phone to me. I would critique his music. He was good, but not great. I thought this friendly relationship with him could continue just on a music level, because that was what we had in common, playing the guitar. I thought, James is an interesting guy. He speaks intelligently and seems to have a goal in life. I thought of him as good intellectual company.
What Does He Really Want?
But as time passed, what he had to say became more personal. He’d say things about how he wished we could be together and jam together, making great music. Was he throwing another hint? What did he mean by “together”? He didn’t say anything more, so I kept my cool. I still thought I could learn a thing or two from him concerning guitar playing techniques.
My mom suggested that we invite him over to share our Thanksgiving day feast since we had plenty of food. When I called to invite him, he spent an hour telling me how he’d never again celebrate holidays. He made that decision because of his dead mother. I argued with him, saying, “Your mom would want to see you happy. Even though she’s dead, you shouldn’t just give life a rest. There are things to see, places to go, things to do. Life is meant to be lived.”
He thought about it and decided I was right. He came over and ate a heavenly meal with my family. Afterwards, we played guitar. We jammed together and he taught me a few things, like how to bend the sound of a chord while playing.
An Invitation I Had To Refuse
The next day, he called to thank me for inviting him over.
“I really enjoyed the meal,” he said. Then he told me he was going to a Jimi Hendrix remembrance day. “Want to come along?”
“No, I won’t be able to make it.” I really wanted to go, but I didn’t trust being out alone with him. I thought it might give him the impression that I wanted a relationship with him and that maybe he would try to come on to me.
He went back to talking about his music and how long he thought it would take him to perfect his craft. Then he said, “You were my inspiration. You help my music a lot. I wish you were my age. I’d like our relationship to last, maybe we can jam in a studio together. Also on a romantic level as well.”
Even though I had suspected he felt this way, I was surprised to hear him come out with it. I had to let him know that I only saw him as a friend. If he failed to comprehend this, I knew our relationship would have to end.
“James, I don’t know what I’ve done or what I’ve said to give you the impression that we have something going, but you must understand that we don’t,” I told him. “I’m not feeling what you’re feeling. I only see you as a friend. If you want to take it to another level and make the relationship more than it is, then we can’t be friends anymore.”
“But when you invited me over your house, I thought that meant something,” he said. “I’m really attracted to you Lisa, and I feel we should be together.”
“It meant nothing when I invited you over for Thanksgiving. It wasn’t even my idea. I didn’t want you to come, my mom insisted.” I told him again that I wasn’t interested in him and hung up the phone.
Why Me?
It bothered me to hear James say he was attracted to me. I’ve always lived by the theory that a person attracts a reflection of herself. Since I thought this guy might be mentally disturbed, was it possible that I could be that way too? Was that why I attracted him?
I told myself that I wasn’t crazy. There was nothing wrong with me. If anyone was nuts it was him. I thought how crazy it was for this 27-year-old guy to think I wanted to get with him. What a jerk! I tried thinking back over our phone calls. I wondered if I had said anything to encourage him. As far as I could remember, the only thing I ever did on the phone was listen to his woes.
Maybe that was it, I thought. Perhaps I was too courteous and patient. I was too polite and gave him too much of my time. Maybe no one ever gave him that much time except his mother. Maybe I kind of reminded him of her, always there when he needed to talk. And maybe I really did influence his music somehow.
Over the next few days, I felt a bit remorseful for the way I treated James. I was also worried that he might do a crazy thing like show up at my house with a gun to kill me, or make crank calls to my house just to upset me. Recently someone has called my house a few times and not said anything when I picked up the phone. I think it might be him but I can’t be sure.
This experience has taught me that you can’t be too friendly and patient because people, particularly the male species, might take it as an invitation to a romance that doesn’t exist. This wasn’t the first time that I wanted friendship with a guy who wanted something more.
I haven’t entirely given up on the men in this world, I just hope I don’t meet another James. In the future, if I’m ever walking down the street by myself and a guy on a bike starts talking to me, I’ll say, “Sorry, I can’t stop now. I’m late for a party.”

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.