Why I Feel Invisible

Just the other week, I had to fill out a questionnaire when I was registering for college classes. It included some questions on your racial and ethnic background. The information was optional, but I thought it wouldn’t hurt to answer.
When I saw the choices I had, I was first amused and then angered by the school’s ignorance. The only categories were: White, Black, Hispanic, American Indian, and Asian or Pacific Islander. There wasn’t even a box marked “other.” They seemed to have forgotten about the land that lies between the East and the West. For a while I contemplated drawing my own box and checking it. For the millionth time, I felt invisible.
My ancestry is largely Far and Middle Eastern. Being part Arab and part Asian, I have always felt left out of discussions about race. America is a place where people have been trained to see in Black and White. For that reason, the shades of gray get lost. In spite of intense concern with racism, for too long the struggles of people from the Far East (China, India, Japan, etc.) and the Middle East (Saudi Arabia, Syria, Iraq, and many others) have been of secondary importance.
A Black and White Debate
When the subject of racism or civil rights comes up-at school or wherever-it usually turns into a heated debate between the Blacks and the Whites. If I try to join the discussion, my comments are not taken seriously. Other people seem to think that I am unaffected by racism and am not qualified to voice any opinions on the subject. It’s as if they were telling me, “This doesn’t really concern you, so keep out.” They seem unaware that Arabs and Asians are also victims of racism.
Much of the fault, I think, lies with the government and the media. They take extra caution to avoid stereotypes and biased portrayals of Blacks and, increasingly, Hispanics. I’m not trying to say that racism against Blacks and Hispanics no longer exists. But if members of those groups are publicly offended, people notice and there is a huge outcry.
On the other hand, Asians and especially Arabs are rarely depicted as anything other than stereotypes and this is still acceptable to most Americans. Asians are either gang members or nerds; Arabs are either bomb-throwing terrorists or bizarre religious fanatics.
We’re Not All Saddams
Both the government and the media can get away with overlooking-and even spreading-these stereotypes. I noticed this during the Gulf War when many Americans were whipped up into anti-Arab fervor. They seemed to forget that the “enemy” in that case was Saddam Hussein. They turned against all Arabs. I was forced to listen to constant complaints about what “my people” were doing in the Middle East and I’m not even an Iraqi.
The people who confronted me didn’t seem to understand that not all Arabs are Saddam Husseins and that most Arab countries had sided with the U.S. against Iraq. If you were an Arab, you were the enemy. I was afraid that I would be attacked by anti-Arab mobs if I voiced my opinions on the war. Even now, I am the subject of occasional jokes about terrorists.Personally, I don’t know a single Arab who is a terrorist. And I, myself, happen to be against violence altogether.
This kind of behavior wasn’t new with the Gulf War; it has been going on for decades. During World War II, for example, Japanese people received this treatment. The American government placed about 130,000 Japanese-Americans in concentration camps. Since the Japanese had bombed Pearl Harbor and were our enemies in the war, people were afraid that the Japanese people living in our country were really spies. The government’s solution was to just lock them all up, even people of Japanese ancestry that had been born in the U.S. and considered themselves Americans. (How ironic that at the same time we were fighting the Nazis’ racist regime.)
Many Japanese people were forced to live in these camps for several years. They were torn from their homes, their families, and their jobs. No compensation was made to them. Finally, in the late 1980s, almost 50 years later, the Supreme Court decided to award survivors and their families $20,000-hardly a compensation for their great losses and suffering and years of neglect. We didn’t lock up German- or Italian-Americans during World War II even though we were at war with their homelands as well. It was a pure act of anti-Asian racism.
Movies Full of Stereotypes
The media reinforces the idea that Arabs and Asians are threatening and dangerous. In big box office films as well as on television, many screenplay writers fail to do their research and follow stereotypes.
In the movie, Not Without My Daughter, the main character is portrayed as cold and cruel. The movie could have focused on the human interest aspect of the story-an Iranian man faced with the terrible anguish of having to choose between his homeland and family on the one hand and his American wife and their daughter on the other. Instead, we see a man who holds his loving wife and daughter hostage for more than a year; a man who beats his wife without logic or reason; a man who fits perfectly into the mold of a stereotypical Middle Easterner.
Though Robin Hood: Prince of Thieves is a slight improvement, the opening scene shows Moslem Arab conquerors senselessly slaughtering Christians and Moslems alike. They are supposedly barbarians who don’t know any better. Even the comparatively light-hearted animated film Aladdin managed to send a similar message. The lyrics of one of the songs described an Arab country as a place “where they cut off your ear/If they don’t like your face/It’s barbaric, but hey, it’s home.”
Countless other movies inaccurately portray all Arabs as leading primitive, nomadic lives in the desert. Although there are a few nomads in the deserts of Arabia, there are many wonderful cities that have all the modern conveniences of the West. Baghdad, the capital of Iraq, was the world’s biggest educational center long before the births of famous European universities like Oxford and Notre Dame. But could one ever guess that from watching movies and TV? It just looks like one big desert full of people in head dresses and white robes.
Karate, Corpses, and Bruce Lee
Asians are done a great injustice by the media too. If someone mentions watching a “Chinese” movie, the first things that come to mind are karate, corpses, and Bruce Lee. They are shown killing anyone and everyone in the name of honor and avenging another’s death. It may be true that Asians have a greater sense of honor than Westerners, but that does not make them immoral. These feelings of honor contribute to their tremendous respect for family and elders and a desire to never let them down.
Asians don’t go around killing people for the fun of it. They have a lot of respect for human life, perhaps even more than Westerners do. So what if there are Asian gangs? There are gangs within every ethnic group. But moviemakers seem to disregard this fact. I’ve seen plenty of television shows and movies in which the hero is out to stop a menacing Asian gang. It has gotten to the point where Asian films only ring one bell in people’s minds-violence.
The Larger Struggle
But these negative portrayals of Asians, Arabs and other invisible groups get very little attention. It’s as if people think we can get rid of discrimination against Blacks, then move on to Hispanics, and then, maybe someday, we’ll get to the other groups who experience racism. But it doesn’t work that way. In order for one kind of racism to be addressed, they all must be addressed. What it comes down to is that Blacks, Asians, Hispanics, Arabs, Indians-all of us-are not engaged in separate, confined struggles, but are all part of one larger struggle.
When I say that I am part of an invisible class, no one believes me. But when I mention the idea of having an Asian History month or an Arab History month, it falls on deaf ears. Hurt and angered, I am turned away again only to walk invisibly among my fellow Americans.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.