The SAT: What Good Is It?

There I was in my SAT vocabulary class at school going over portions of old tests when I came across this: “Baseball is to diamond as football is to…” I pondered the different choices until my head hurt, but none of them seemed to fit. I just couldn’t figure it out. Then my teacher hit me with the answer: GRIDIRON.Gridiron? I thought. Isn’t that some kind of traffic jam? I don’t know anything about football.
Each year nearly 2 million of us are forced to go through the anguish of preparing for and sitting through the Scholastic Aptitude Test (SAT). The question is, what for?
“School to school, the grading systems vary,” explained Stephen Manella, an admissions counselor at New York University who helps evaluate roughly 10,000 applicants every year. “I think you need some form of standardized test.”
According to Anne Buckley of the College Board, which administers the test, “[The SAT] is the most objective way of assessing how well a student will perform [in college].”
Trivial, Irrelevant, and Biased
But not everyone agrees about that. Bob Schaeffer, of FairTest, the National Center for Fair & Open Testing, said, “The questions are trivial, irrelevant, and biased. There’s little relationship between general intelligence and scoring high on the SAT.”
Many of the students I interviewed also talked about bias-bias against women, people of color, the poor, even people of different religions. “It’s definitely not fair,” said Tara Chasnoff, 17, of Edward R. Murrow HS. “A lot of the questions have references to churches and Christian-oriented subjects. Most of the questions on the math [section] are geared toward male preferences. Practically all [of them] have something to do with sports.”
Tara also recalled questions having to do with “fine arts,” something she said poor people are not exposed to. “There are no questions on any other culture besides White culture,” she continued. “The test is undoubtedly White oriented.”
Rich, White Boys
The experts tend to agree. Bob Schaeffer says the person most likely to score high on the SAT is “a kid who’s a practiced test-taker. Someone who has been coached. White males get the highest scores-rich, White boys.” Though he believes the test makers at ETS come from diverse backgrounds, he says that the SAT questions are tailor-made mainly for people of a specific culture: upper-middle to upperclass White males from suburban and coastal regions.
Even NYU’s Stephen Manella, whose college requires applicants to take the test, concedes that if you’re poor, “you have to work harder to do well on [the SAT] than if you were from an affluent area. It’s also a question of the use of language and dialect. But I don’t think it’s an insurmountable disadvantage.”
You don’t even have to be poor to be disadvantaged when it comes to taking the SAT. According to John Katzman, founder and president of the Princeton Review, an organization which coaches students to improve their scores, “Women have better grades in high school and college than men. They make up 52% of the college population.” And yet their SAT scores imply that they are going to do worse than their male counterparts. When you look at college grades, he added, the test also “vastly underpredicts for Blacks.”
I Felt Like a Herb
This is more than a problem of just getting into a good college; the SAT works on students’ self-esteem. “Girls get higher grades, but they get lower scores,” said Schaeffer. “They think if they score low they’re dumb.”
That was true for Tara, who had a 94 average, saw her SAT scores, and got depressed. “It was very discouraging,” said Tara. “I [felt] that I wasn’t as smart as I thought I was.”
And it’s not only a problem for girls. “I felt like a herb,” said Danny DeJesus, 18, of New Utrecht HS.
Students who feel this way about their scores sometimes don’t even bother to apply to competitive colleges. “My friends who got low scores on the SAT’s seemed to play themselves down,” said Jennifer Constant, 18. “These are kids that are going to be successful some day. Now it seems that they don’t have as much faith in themselves as I do in them.”
Issues of fairness aside, “students are just tested to death,” said Marilyn Varsa, a college counselor at Option, an organization that offers free college counseling. “[The SAT] is a source of great anxiety. I’d love to see it done away with.”
How To Prepare
Unfortunately, that’s not going to happen any time soon. So what’s a high school student to do?
“We advise students to take the more advanced courses,” said Anne Buckley of the College Board. “There’s a strong relationship between the types of courses a student takes [in high school] and SAT scores.”
Even if you’re a poor minority woman who took all the wrong classes in high school and can’t afford an expensive SAT coaching course, there’s still hope. “That person should become as familiar as possible with the SAT,” advises Schaeffer. “Reading books, looking at previous tests.” He said they should also look into low-cost classes and practice at home.
If you still don’t feel you’ve done well enough on the test, don’t let that discourage you. Most admissions officers recognize that, as Marilyn Varsa put it, “You can be a very strong student in high school and not do well on your SAT-or vice versa.”
And if you take it more than once, they’ll count your high scores. Katzman recommends that you should work to change the system. Write to State Senator Ken Lavalle and Assemblyman Ed Sullivan, the two local politicians most involved in changing the test. (Their address is: Legislative Office Building, Albany, NY, 12247.) When you get to college, he thinks you should work within the school to make them drop the SAT as a part of the admissions process. “Kids get pissed off about [the SAT],” said Katzman. “Then they take it and they forget about it.” He believes young people ought to get more involved and stay that way.

SIDEBAR: Are Prep Courses Worth It?
The SAT gives you 145 multiple-choice questions to answer in only 120 minutes. That’s less than a minute per question. “They don’t want you to think,” says Bob Schaeffer, of FairTest. According to Schaeffer, the kids who get the highest test scores are not necessarily the most intelligent but the practiced test-takers, the ones who have been coached.
Coaching helps you learn the test-taking skills and techniques necessary to boost your score. It helps you understand how the test works (that the questions get more difficult as you go on, for example, but are worth the same number of points). It helps you decide when to guess and when not to and when to skip over questions that take too long to answer.
Students also learn to look for “root” meanings when they don’t know what a word means and how to “plug in” numbers to find the correct answer.
Tara Chasnoff, 17, of Edward R. Murrow HS, took the Princeton Review SAT prep course as well as working there over the summer. Armed with their techniques, the second time Tara took the SAT she boosted her score by 80 points. “It did help a lot,” she said. “I walked into the SAT knowing how to tackle the questions…I got accustomed to the SAT prep course’s techniques.”
Unfortunately prep courses are not cheap. The most popular ones range in cost from $565 to $695 for a six to ten week course.
John Katzman, founder and president of the Princeton Review, admits that courses like his don’t help make the SAT any fairer. “The kids we’re working with are upper-middle class kids,” he said. But he added that his company had come out with a series of books that contain their best coaching techniques and that financial aid was also available.
Some schools and community organizations offer low cost and free prep courses. For more information call Options at 212-873-6600 or ask your college adviser.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.