Sometimes it’s hard to sort out the presidential candidates. They all sound so good on television, but who knows what these people are really like? Campaign promises are important, but we’ve been disappointed too many times.
Since the experiences we have shape the decisions we make, I think we need to look closely at the way the candidates have lived their lives. Is someone who has never lived in a city going to be able to create an effective urban plan? Is someone who only went to ritzy prep schools going to do anything to improve public education? Although we can’t expect our president to have experienced everything, we can look for someone who has experienced something of what life is like for ordinary Americans.
Brown: Born to Run
One of the phrases that has been turning up a lot in Jerry Brown’s campaign is “We the People.” Brown portrays himself as an ordinary guy, running for president. He knows our pain, our struggle. Or so he claims.
But let’s look at his life for a minute. Jerry was born into the world of politics. His father, Pat Brown, was the governor of California from 1958 to 1966. He went to a private prep school in San Francisco (no public school for Jerry) and decided that he wanted to be a Jesuit priest. He spent 3 1/2 years at a seminary but then decided he would be better off in politics. So it was off to the University of California, where he got a degree in classics, and then on to Yale Law School in 1961. (How much do you want to bet that he didn’t have to worry about financial aid?)
He did take a few months off to work in the civil rights movement in Mississippi in 1962. Then he went back to Yale, and got his law degree in 1964. After graduation, he clerked for a California supreme court judge, traveled through Latin America, joined a prominent law firm in Los Angeles, and eventually became governor of California, just like daddy.
Not Your Typical Politician
But Brown does seem to have rejected a lot of the trappings of political success. For example, when he was governor of California, he refused to live in the mansion and ride in the limo.
Now, as he runs for president, Brown is shunning the common practice of accepting large donations from private corporations. Instead he got an 800 line, and invited people to call in and make contributions of $100 or less. As a result, he doesn’t owe the big corporations or the political hierarchy anything.
One of the more interesting parts of Brown’s campaign is his proposed tax policy. As it stands now, there are many ways for really rich people to get out of paying taxes. Jerry’s “flat tax” plan replaces the several federal taxes that we have now with one 13% income tax. There will be no deductions, and no confusion.
Economists disagree about who will benefit more from the flat tax-the rich or the poor. But the threat of losing their loopholes is sure to antagonize a lot of wealthy people and you won’t often find a presidential candidate willing to do this. That’s because presidents, as a rule, are filthy rich. Why would they create tax laws that would hurt themselves, their families and business associates?
George the Previleged
Which leads us to the most privileged of them allâ
George Herbert Walker Bush.
His father, Prescott, was a wealthy investment banker, and a Republican senator from Connecticut. He was brought up in Greenwich, Connecticut. How very, very posh, dahlings. Is it any surprise that he became the 41st president of the United States?
No public school for little Georgie Herbert Walker. He attended Greenwich Country Day school, and then ultra-preppie Phillips Academy.
At this point, Bush’s life begins to show alarming signs of becoming a cheesy romance novel. I never thought that people like this really existed.
World War II has swept the land. George-the-Brave became the Navy’s youngest pilot. He flew 58 combat missions, and was shot down once, but George-the-Lucky was rescued by a submarine.
He met and married Barbara. And then it was off to Yale. (Yes, another Yale man.) George-the-Smart managed to graduate in only three years with a B.A. in economics. While at Yale, he was a member of the secret society Skull and Bones (kind of like a fraternity for rich WASPs).
After graduation, George and his family moved to Texas, where he worked in the oil business.
Enter George-the-Politician. Bush made an unsuccessful bid for the U.S. Senate and then ran for and won a seat in the House of Representatives.
President Nixon was impressed by George, and asked him to serve as the chairman of the Republican National Committee.
From the CIA To the White House
After holding several government positions under Nixon and Ford, including the directorship of the C.I.A., Bush returned to the private sector-for a while.
During the 1980 elections, Bush ran against Ronald Reagan for the Republican presidential nomination. He was very critical of Reagan, calling Ron’s economic policy “voodoo economics.” However, when Reagan won the nomination and asked Bush to run with him, his offer was eagerly accepted. Bush served as the vice president until 1988, when he was elected president.
Now Bush is running for reelection. As president, he’s taken us through a devastating recession and a mini-war. Polls indicate that he is not as popular as he once was. What will he bring to the presidential election of 1992?
I hope he’ll start to think about the American people and their day-to-day lives. He’s clearly out of touch. For example, at a trade show display of supermarket equipment earlier this year, Bush was surprised to see the electronic scanners that cashiers use to read prices. That should tell you how long it’s been since George has had to run to the store for Barbara. As a matter of fact, I think that you would have to go back a few generations of Bushes before you could find one that actually had to perform the task of food shopping.
Clinton: Out of Arkansas
Finally, there’s Bill Clinton, who was raised by his mother in Arkansas. If living in Arkansas isn’t a liability then I don’t know what is. But at least Clinton went to public school. It’s his higher education that is illustrious.
He got his Bachelor of Science in International Affairs at Georgetown University in Washington, D.C. He won a Rhodes scholarship (probably the most prestigious academic award you can get). He then went to Yale (are you noticing a pattern here?) and got his law degree. That’s where he met his wife Hillary, also a lawyer. After graduation, he became a professor of law at the University of Arkansas.
And then the leap into politics. Clinton became the governor of Arkansas in 1979. He wasn’t re-elected and joined a law firm. But he got a second chance in 1983, and has been governor of Arkansas ever since.
Clinton’s Ethics
While in office, Clinton learned that his brother was involved in a major drug dealing operation and authorized his arrest. This is impressive. He didn’t use his influence to save his brother’s behind.
But his ethics in other areas have been questioned. He’s rumored to have had extra-marital affairs, fudged the truth about whether he had ever smoked marijuana (“I didn’t inhale”), and appears to have sleazed out of serving in the Vietnam War. And even though Clinton speaks out against racism all the time, he has been caught golfing at an all-white country club.
To his credit, Clinton does seem aware of how hard it is to pay for a college education these days. He wants to start a national fund from which any American can borrow money to pay for college. They will have to pay it back, either out of their income over time, or by doing a few years of national service, as a police officer, teacher, child care worker, etc. It’s like R.O.T.C. without the military.
In addition, Clinton wants to create a national apprenticeship program, so that high school graduates who don’t go to college will be able to get work skills.
Of course, you shouldn’t judge the candidates on their backgrounds alone. It’s just as important to find out where they stand on issues that are important to you. But it is worth giving some thought to whether they’re likely to know anything about how you live and what kinds of policies and programs would make your life better.
Can Anyone Grow Up to Be President?
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.