There Are 20 Sides to Every Story

Some of the names in this story have been changed.
Last year I was sitting in class beside my friend writing notes to her on my hand. One note said “I hate Michael” and, unluckily for me, this girl Erica saw it. For some twisted and sick reason she went and told Meredith, this school bully, that I had a note on my hand that said “I hate Meredith.” And it didn’t stop there. Erica told her friends that I said Meredith was a fat bitch and that she was ugly. I had never even met the girl.
The next day, friends of Erica and Meredith kept coming up to me and asking me if I really did say those things about Meredith. Someone told me that Meredith wanted to fight me! I couldn’t believe it. Why was Erica doing this to me?
Then it came to me. Erica and I hadn’t been getting along ever since I started going out with this guy she liked. “How stupid can you get?” I thought. “She’s doing this because of a guy!”
Who Would She Believe?
I realized that this “I said, she said” thing was making life difficult. There were too many people involved. I had to talk to Meredith. This was going to be tough. It was like facing Goliath himself! But if I didn’t face her now and try to explain everything then there was sure to be a fight. I was scared. You would be too. I was the sh-t on the concrete and Meredith was this big foot getting ready to smoosh me!
I asked one of my friends who did know her to introduce me to Meredith. She was confused and upset and didn’t know who to believe, me or Erica. Meredith and I talked about it for a while. I told her my side of the story. Then she told me she didn’t want to fight me because she was already in a lot of trouble in school. But there were so many people besides Erica involved in this. We had to find a way to stop the rumors.
The next day Meredith and I decided to go to the dean’s office. We tried to explain everything to the dean in the order that it happened. He thought it was complicated because of all the people involved. We had to find a way to break it down so that everybody could see how it all started. Not only were Meredith’s friends pressuring her to fight me, but my friends were pressuring me into fighting Meredith. They all said that if Meredith came up to me and started accusing me of things, that I should just pop her! Meredith and I had to make our friends see that all of that talk was bullsh-t because Erica started the whole thing.
A Meeting With the Dean
The dean, Meredith, and I came up with an idea. The next day Meredith and I went around to all the people who Erica had involved in her little gossip triangle of lies. We told them that the dean would like to talk to everyone involved. When we finally got to the dean’s office everyone had a different story. Some said that the message on my hand was totally different than what Erica had originally told them. There were even stories about other people that they knew, besides Meredith.
The dean said that everyone involved had to be in the room at the same time. We all sat around this huge round table. Each person then had her chance to tell her piece of the story. I thought that no one should be able to change her story and the dean agreed. This was to make sure that nothing became more complicated than it already was. Each of the people in the room was given time to question the person who was talking about her part of the story. There were questions like, “Who told you this, Erica or Stephany?”
The Truth Comes Out
It became quite clear during all these testimonies that Erica had made the whole thing up. When my friend told everyone what the note on my hand really said, it was even more believable. But Erica kept denying the whole thing. She kept saying that the only reason they were doing this was because they wanted to see her get jumped. But Erica must have been lying. These were her friends taking my side. Erica still insisted that I said those things. I thought to myself, “She must really hate me.”
Everyone finally learned the truth about it, and “O mi gawd” was Erica in trouble: two weeks of detention from the dean and a promise from Meredith that her ass would be finished in this school. Meredith and I became friends and to me she was no longer a threat. The conflict group did help a lot because we ended up not fighting over a situation that now seems immature to me.
This process can work for nearly anyone. Get everyone’s cooperation and find a teacher, counselor, or someone else you can talk to. Sometimes it is better to talk things out rather than to just fight. It brings us one step closer to being mature adults.
I feel this is a successful way to solve problems of any kind, but you have to make the decision to do it on your own. People have to realize that not wanting to fight doesn’t make you a pussy. I guess the only person who really should be mad at me is Michael, because he was the one the note was really about.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.