“The best searches start by looking inward,” explained Monique Devane, associate director of admissions at the Northfield Mount Hermon School in Massachusetts.
Devane, a former admissions officer at Brown University, explained that too many students are worried about “who’ll take me” instead of saying to themselves: “Wait a minute, I’m the consumer here.” She said to keep in mind that it is your time and money that’s being spent.
In addition to Devane, I spoke to several other experienced college counselors: Ed Bell, the assistant vice chancellor for student affairs at SUNY’s New York City Office of Student Recruitment; Gillian Rosenfeld, director of the Options College/Career program in Manhattan; Henry Summers, director of the Options program in Forest Hills, Queens; and Nadine LaGuardia, the college advisor at Urban Academy. They answered some common questions about college.
SUNY vs. CUNY?
What’s the difference between SUNY and CUNY?
SUNY, which stands for State University of New York, is a system of 64 schools scattered all over the state. Most SUNY schools offer housing for students who wish to live on-campus. But SUNY colleges also have tougher admissions requirements than the local, CUNY schools. In fact, when you apply to the SUNY system, there’s no guarantee you’ll be accepted anywhere.
That’s why it’s a good idea to apply to CUNY (City University of New York) even if you know you want to go out of the city-just in case. If you’re a high school graduate or have your GED (General Equivalency Diploma) and you get your application in on time, you’re guaranteed placement in at least one of CUNY’s 18 schools. They call this “open admissions.”
CUNY schools are what Bell describes as “commuter colleges” because there is practically no housing available and most students live at home. Due to the fact that they’re located right in New York City and have an open admissions policy, the student body tends to be more diverse than at state schools.
A lot of people think that CUNY schools are for people who aren’t smart enough to go to a state school. This is not true. Bell, who represents SUNY, says that academically there’s really no difference between the two. The number of students for every teacher (student-faculty ratio) is similar as well.
Private Colleges
What about Private colleges? Can I get into one? If I did, could I afford it?
According to Devane, private schools are not necessarily any harder to get into. Because they don’t depend as much on government money they can be more flexible about who they take. They are more likely to look beyond grades and SAT scores than state schools.
They also have a lot of money to give away. Rosenfeld says that when looking at a private school, one should “never really think too much about the cost.” Private schools do cost more, but Devane says that, given the right financial aid package, they can actually be cheaper than state schools. She said students shouldn’t be scared off by the initial price tag, but should look at “the before and after financial aid price… The price tag could look very different.”
Big vs. Small
What’s the difference between a big school and a small school? A college and a university?
In a larger school, classes tend to be bigger and you don’t always get to know your teachers or other students that well. On the other hand, there are usually more on-campus activities, more facilities, and more course offerings.
At a large school, you get less personal attention and may feel lonely and isolated. You need to know that you can survive in that kind of environment.
Smaller schools are more intimate, with smaller classes. You’ll have more contact with teachers and will get to know more people. It’s harder to get lost in the crowd.
A college is a two or four year school that usually offers just one degree. A university is a collection of colleges and graduate schools offering a bunch of degrees on a bunch of different levels (BA, MA, Ph.D, etc…).
College professors tend to give you more attention and are more teaching oriented, whereas the university professors are often more into their research.
Two-Year vs. Four-Year
What’s the difference between two and four-year colleges?
Two-year schools offer mostly job-related training. They tend to have an older student body and less campus spirit. They are also smaller and offer a limited number of programs. But, according to Rosenfeld, a two-year school is a terrific place to start if you’re not sure you’re ready for a four-year college. They give you a great opportunity to build up your skills. Many students do that and then end up transferring to a four-year school.
College Major
What if I don’t know what I want to major in?
According to Devane, this isn’t a problem-“as long as you’re committed to finding out.”
Admissions officers don’t look down on you for not knowing exactly what you want to study. To Devane, “It means you’re really open.” At a four-year college you have a couple of years to make up your mind.
Narrow the Search
I have no idea at all where I want to go. How can I narrow down the search?
“First of all, you’ve got to understand yourself,” says Bell. He suggests that students actually sit down with a pen and paper and list the different factors that are important to them.
Think about the cost, location, size-whatever is going to make you happy. You don’t want to spend four years someplace where you’ll be miserable.
Even if you don’t know exactly what you want, Devane says everyone has some criteria. It might be something like sports, religion, or a kind of campus atmosphere but, she says, “Every school on your list should meet those criteria.”
Can I Get In?
I know what school I want to go to but I’m not sure I can get in.
If you really think you know where you want to go, then you should definitely apply. But don’t limit your choices.
Devane says the best thing to do is pick six schools. At least two should be ones that you’ll most likely be admitted to. Two should be schools where you have a good 50-50 chance, and two can be schools where you have a shot but there’s no way of knowing if you’ll get in or not. Whatever you do, don’t get trapped in what Ms. Devane calls “the Perfect College Syndrome.” She says a lot of students come to the conclusion that, “There’s only one school for me.”
Devane insists that’s probably not the case. It’s like saying, “There’s only one girlfriend for me.” She explains that if you can only decide on one college, you should identify what it is you like about that school and look for other schools that have the same things. Don’t pour all your effort into getting into that dream school and neglect your other choices.
Other Factors
What if I don’t meet the school’s admissions requirements? Are there other ways I can get in?
Because they have to answer to the taxpayers, SUNY schools have a definite bottom line for admissions. Each school has set minimum SAT scores and GPA’s (grade point average). However, there are also ways around that.
One of them is the Educational Opportunity Program (EOP) for low-income students who don’t meet the minimum standards. Be careful with this though-even when applying under EOP there’s still a bottom line. And not everyone who applies under EOP gets in that way either.
Another way is to be considered on the basis of a “special talent.”
Private schools are a lot less rigid in their requirements. If they really want you they don’t even have to look at your SAT scores, for example. But they do want to be sure you can handle the work-and so do you.
Everything You Always Wanted to Know about College (But Didn’t Have Anyone â
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.