Can you imagine your best friend dying in your arms? That’s what happened to Yvette. Her best friend, Maribel Feliciano, was stabbed to death on the subway when the two girls were on their way home from school.
When I asked Yvette to tell me about what happened, she sounded sad, but also very calm and strong. This is her story.
On September 18, Yvette and Maribel, both 15 and students at the High School of Fashion Industries, were on the C train on their way home to Sheridan Avenue, East New York. They always rode this train home from school together without any problems.
But that day they didn’t feel comfortable, they felt something wasn’t right. “We were about to get off the train because we were the only Hispanic girls,” Yvette said. Then, before the train got to the next stop, four girls surrounded them. Yvette says that one of them threatened Maribel saying, “You’d better run or we’re gonna stab you.”
Maribel didn’t want to appear to be a coward or look like a sucker so she said she wouldn’t run. The girl who had threatened her hit Maribel in the face twice. Yvette, in defense of her friend, hit the girl back. The girl pushed Yvette down on the floor.
“That’s when the other girls pulled Maribel down by her hair and one of the girls stabbed her,” Yvette said. “I tried to help Maribel by grabbing her hand, but Maribel let go of it and fell. I ran for the conductor and when I got back Maribel was on the floor spitting up blood.”
A man took off his shirt and gave it to Yvette. She used it to put pressure on Maribel’s back to try to stop the bleeding.
At the precinct, the police broke the news to Yvette that Maribel was dead. But Yvette says she already knew. “I remember when I was younger and I asked my mother why, in the movies, people spat up blood and she said it meant they were dead. That’s how I knew Maribel was dead,” she told me.
Yvette says that she was asked to identify the knife which the police found on the subway tracks. She was also asked to identify the girls who attacked Maribel. She picked them out of a line up. Two were 14, the others were 15 and 16. Yvette said the 15-year-old was the one who stabbed Maribel.
The media said that the girls wanted to rob Maribel for her earrings but Yvette told me that’s not what happened. “I don’t know why they started with her. I heard a rumor that four guys dared the girls to start with us,” she said.
Yvette said she’ll never be able to forgive the girls who killed her friend. “They knew what they were doing, there wasn’t no remorse,” she said.
Scared, Angry, and Upset
Although Yvette wasn’t hurt physically, this whole experience has been very traumatic for her. She says she was afraid to go school after it happened. “I was scared, I felt angry too, and I felt very upset,” Yvette said. Her mother is also scared and rides the train to school with Yvette every morning.
Yvette thought that people would be understanding about what happened but she discovered that many people had it in for her. She told me that some of the people at Maribel’s wake and funeral wanted to jump her because they thought she had run off and left Maribel instead of helping her. But Yvette said that Maribel’s family stood by her, saying, “We’d rather our daughter die in the arms of a friend than an enemy.”
Yvette also heard a rumor that 200 kids who knew the girls who attacked Maribel wanted to come and finish her off too.
Yvette says that things have cooled off a lot, but she still hasn’t gotten over Maribel’s death. She gets therapy every Friday and she has supportive family members that do whatever they can to help. “They don’t leave me alone,” Yvette said. “When I’m alone I think about Maribel and I get depressed.”
We Used To Eat Pancakes Together
Yvette said that she thinks about Maribel all the time. “Maribel was very funny, very short, and she had a Miss Piggy nose,” Yvette recalled jokingly. “She wouldn’t give up nothing without a fight.”
Yvette remembered how Maribel used to come pick her up in the morning. “My mother makes pancakes every morning and before we left for school we’d split the pancakes.” So now, every day at breakfast, Yvette remembers her friend. “Everything I do reminds me of her,” she said.
Yvette has met a lot of people because of what happened but she believes nobody can take Maribel’s place. “She was my best friend and only friend, nobody can replace her.”
SIDEBAR: A School Mourns
Maribel Feliciano, 15, a sophomore at the HS of Fashion Industries, was killed September 18 on the train going home from school. Her death was a shock to every-one at the school. Many students found out about Maribel’s death when they watched television the night she was killed. Antonia Carmona,15, was a friend of Maribel’s. “I found out in my house, I saw her picture on the TV and I started crying,” Antonia said. “I couldn’t believe it, it was a shock to me.” Others heard about it when they got to Fashion the next day. “I didn’t know it was her until I came to school,” said Angelina Velez, 15. “I wanted to cry because she was my friend.” Dean Linda Bessellieu said Maribel’s death had “a grave effect” on the school. Principal Charles Bonnici said trained counselors talked to the students about what had happened. They also had classes on death and dying. “The school response was immediate,” Bonnici said. In many cases when a student dies this way, their schoolmates get roused up and rowdy. But both the principal and the dean said that there weren’t any after school tensions or other incidents following Maribel’s death. Many people at Fashion worry that this incident will give the school a bad reputation. But Bonnici said that students shouldn’t be afraid of the school because of what happened to Maribel. Fashion is a “safe school and neighborhood,” he said. “We can control the school and neighborhood but not the subways.” Angelina feels the same way. She said, “I just want people to know Fashions isn’t a bad school and that Maribel wasn’t bad.” This city has lost many of its young to unnecessary violence and now it has lost another. “We are gonna miss her,” said Antonia. “We ain’t gonna forget her. We can forgive but we ain’t gonna forget. She’s gonna be with us forever.”
