Did you hear about the fare hike? Do you believe the TA (Transit Authority) wants bus and subway riders to pay an additional 25 cents starting January 1, 1992? That would be the single biggest increase in the history of the subway system.
Well, believe it. The TA has announced that they want to charge us $1.40 for a token. If the hike goes through, it will cost the average rider $130 more a year.
“I think it’s ridiculous,” said Ming Chen, 14, of Humanities HS. “I don’t think they should raise it, I think they should decrease it.”
Joe Rappaport, coordinator of the Straphangers’ Campaign, which works to improve services for subway riders, agreed. “Most people would argue that the fare isn’t worth $1.15, so I’m sure it isn’t worth $1.25 or $1.50,” Rappaport said.
A lot of teens I talked to said that if the fare goes up, people just won’t pay it. Lateefah Alleyne, 14, of Humanities HS, said, “Nobody’s gonna wanna use the train.” Carrie Yip, 14, also a student at Humanities, said, “When you raise it again more kids are going to hop the turnstiles.”
Higher Fare, Fewer Riders
They’re probably right. After the MTA raised the fare from $1 to $1.15, the average number of weekday riders dropped by more than 8 percent. It’s sure to drop again if the fare goes up to $1.40. “People may decide to take their cars,” Rappaport said.
So, you may be asking yourself, why is the TA raising the fare, again? The answer is because of their $263 million budget deficit. A deficit happens when you spend more money than you make. One of the main reasons for the deficit is that the amount of tax money the state has been collecting has dropped off because of the recession.
But there are other ways to deal with this besides raising the fare. The city’s Transit Authority (TA) could cut back on some of its expenses, like the number of high-paying management level jobs. Or, the Governor and state Legislature could give a larger share of the state’s transportation budget to the TA.
Rappaport said that raising the fare will hurt the whole city, not just those of us who use public transportation. For one thing, more people will probably start taking their cars to work. That means more traffic jams, more smog, and dirtier air.
And, if it becomes harder for people to get to work, more businesses may leave the city. Mass transit keeps New York going; without it, this city and its economy would fall apart.
Only In New York
This fare hike also discriminates against city residents. MTA (Metropolitan Transportation Authority-the state agency that oversees the TA) officials have said they are not going to raise fares of the LIRR (Long Island Railroad) and Metro-North commuter trains. New Jersey officials aren’t raising the fare of the PATH trains either. If people in the suburbs don’t have to pay more to get around, why must we catch a bum deal?
Governor Cuomo, Mayor Dinkins and legislators in Albany can stop a fare hike by giving the TA more government money for the city’s transit system. But so far, Governor Cuomo hasn’t done anything to prevent the fare hike and many people feel he has let New York City down tremendously.
Amy Russo, 15, of Humanities HS, said, “I think he should wait awhile.” McKinley Jones, 15, of St. Agnes HS, said, “I’d ask him if there’s a better way instead of raising the fare.”
This fare hike will affect everybody, especially college students and the elderly. As Rappaport explained, “The city colleges raised tuition and now the students have to pay more to go to school, work, and back home.” Lateefah Alleyne said, “It would affect me because it would affect my mother and she would have less money to give me.”
And what if this deficit gets worse? Will we see the fare rising to $2.00 someday?
$1.40 for a Token: What’s Fair About This Hike?
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.