Boarding Schools: City Kids Find a Way Out, a Way Up

If you ever saw “The Facts of Life,” on TV, you probably think that boarding school is a snap-a home away from home complete with substitute Mom, where students spend more time hanging in the dorm than sitting in the classroom. But New York City kids who go away to school find that the real thing is very different from the TV version. Classes are demanding, it’s hard to make friends and, if you’re Black or Hispanic, you really feel like a minority.
Nevertheless, Tasha Sherene Spann,17, a student at Suffield Academy in Connecticut, believes that “all of the stress, tension, and homesickness” she has endured will pay off in the future. “If somebody told you that you would live on an island for four years and study this one book and after you would become rich and famous, wouldn’t you do it?” she asked.
Most city kids who go to boarding school think they are starting down the road to a better life. They think the experience will help them get into good colleges and get good jobs. “You go into these schools to make money,” said Gevian Dargan, 18, a recent graduate of Deerfield Academy in Massachusetts. “The whole point of this…is to better yourself.”
A Way Out of the Neighborhood
Kendra Hill, 16, of MacDuffie School in Massachusetts, wanted to escape the fate of the many young girls in her Bronx neighborhood who ruined their lives by having children at any early age. Boarding school seemed like a way out. Jose Gonzalez, 16, a senior at Loomis Chaffee School in Connecticut, wanted to get away from his neighborhood and get a good education at the same time.
Most of these teens got into boarding school with the assistance of programs like A Better Chance (ABC) and the Albert G. Oliver program, which help gifted students of color get into prep schools. Although the programs try to prepare kids for the transition to private school, urban minority students have many adjustments to make when they get there.
Relating to people from different backgrounds is probably the biggest adjustment boarding school students have to make, but there are lots of others. For one thing, the schoolwork is usually a lot harder than what they are used to. “It’s much different from public school,” Jose Gonzalez said. “I had to work really hard…so many demanding courses.” Michelle Billy, 17, a student at Andover, said she was always considered a nerd at her junior high in Queens. Now, doing well is “a struggle.”
Another problem is being separated from your family. Caroline Lugo, 18, a recent graduate of Suffield Academy, said she got so homesick sometimes that she would even cry when they served spaghetti at school because it reminded her of her father’s spaghetti.
Students from New York also miss the city atmosphere. They have trouble getting used to life in the “boonies.” Most boarding schools are in small towns that don’t have a bodega on every corner. Entertainment is limited to one movie theatre showing the same movie for three weeks at a time. What they do have are grass and trees and a relatively crime-free environment. Wadiya Peterson,16, of Suffield Academy in Connecticut, described the town where her school is located as “crazy quiet” but “pretty.”
The peaceful atmosphere isn’t the only nice thing about going away to school. Living away from home means that, in addition to learning their school subjects, students also learn how to be independent.
Greater Independence
“It has made me more mature,” Tasha Spann said. “I can now make my own decisions without having to ask somebody if I am correct about it.” Her sister Tesha, a student at Miss Porter’s School in Connecticut, agreed. “[My parents] think I’m growing more responsibly each day,” Tesha said.
Another aspect of boarding school that city students like are the close relationships with teachers. “That was a great thing,” said Jay McMahon, a recent graduate of Westtown School in Pennsylvania. Students see their teachers not only in the classroom but on the athletic field, in the dorm, and even at meals. Michelle Billy said, “In junior high school you didn’t call up a teacher if you didn’t understand.” At boarding school, you can.
No Regrets
If they had it to do over, most of these students said they would go back to boarding schools. Despite the problems. Gevian said it is an opportunity to “further along your education.” Wadiya said the diversity at Suffield has given her a new outlook on people. And Tesha believes her experience at Porter’s has turned her into “a determined and diligent young woman.”
Caroline Lugo sums it up best. Caroline went to Suffield not only for education, but to get away from the drugs in her neighborhood. Even though she wanted to go, she was very homesick. But she stuck it out, graduated, and is now attending NYU.
Caroline feels she has been “prepped for college” both socially and academically. She knows how to get along with students of different backgrounds, is not afraid to approach her teachers, and feels she can express herself much more freely than she could before. “I wouldn’t trade it for the world,” she said.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.