Columbus: Did He or Didn’t He?

On Monday, October 14, Columbus Day, school was closed and you probably thought, “Great, an extra day of rest.” Maybe you figure nobody deserves a holiday more than Christopher Columbus.
But what do we really know about this guy? Was he “a tall, stubborn, and well-seasoned sailor from the Italian port of Genoa?” like the textbooks tell us or a small-minded, greedy, and well-seasoned rapist from Spain? Or both?
Did he think kindly of the “Indians” he met here and trade peacefully with them, or did he rob them blind and kill them off by the thousands? And what was it like to be an Indian in 1492?
If you’re as confused about all of this as I am maybe you should recheck your history. Next year will mark 500 years since Columbus sailed the ocean blue. But before we start celebrating, we should stop and think about who, what, and why we’re celebrating-or whether or not there’s anything to celebrate at all. Maybe we should be mourning these last 500 years.
Paul Betancourt, 15, of A. Philip Randolph HS, whose Seneca Indian ancestors were here long before Columbus arrived, was in kindergarten when he was first told about the so-called discovery. “[Columbus] was presented as a hero for discovering new land that people had been living on for thousands and thousands of years,” said Paul. “Back then, I really thought he discovered it.”
A Bunch of Bull!
Adilah Najiy, 16, of Washington D.C., says that Columbus was presented to her as “the greatest man that ever walked the face of the earth besides Jesus Christ.” But now Adilah says she knows better. “It’s a bunch of bull!” she said. Robert, 16, agrees. One thing he says his teachers left out was the way Columbus “was looking for a way to get to India…made a mistake and called [the native people] Indians.”
“They should tell us [he] discovered it by accident,” said Paul.
According to the book Columbus: His Enterprise-Exploding the Myth by Hans Konig, the entire tribe of Arawak Indians was wiped out within 25 years of Columbus and his men first landing on the island of Hispaniola (now Haiti and the Dominican Republic). Most of the young people I spoke to didn’t know about that.
“It doesn’t surprise me,” said Richard Farrell, 22. “He was a murderer, he was a liar…a rapist and a racist.”
“I think he’s a dog,” Adilah added. “And murderers should not be given credit for anything but a crime.”
Of course there’s more than one version of the story of who found America first and what they did when they got here. Ivan Van Sertima, author of They Came Before Columbus, presents evidence that Africans may have come here before Columbus. The book includes pictures of stone figures from pre-Columbian (before Columbus) Mexico with African features and drawings that are very similar to African gods.
Different Points of View
Avram Barlow, an American history teacher at Urban Academy, an alternative high school in Manhattan, uses this book and other materials like it in his classes. “I don’t use any one textbook,” he explained. “I generally don’t like the text book. My philosophy is that there are a lot of things that are not in the text- book-I stress a number of different points of view.”
I asked Barlow why so many kids find history such a bore. “The material is not relevant,” he said. “[Students] are not allowed to express their feelings because of the way it’s taught.”
Barlow also said that “a lot of [teachers] are lazy.” But he added that not all of the responsibility falls on them: “[Students] have to read. Go all the way if you’re serious about it.”
Just as everybody doesn’t teach the events of 1492 exactly the same way, not everyone recognizes” Columbus Day.” In Mexico and South and Central America October 12 is commemorated as “el D’a de la Raza [Day of the Race].”
“La raza,” according to Konig’s book, is a mixture of Spanish, Indian and African: “These children of conquerors and slaves are the only achievement of the conquest, the only wealth it produced,” writes Konig.
Tell the Truth
Richard, an African American, doesn’t think we should have “Columbus Day” here either. “Why should I celebrate a day named after a [European] who contributed to my ancestors’ downtrodden experience?” he asked. Paul thinks we should “celebrate it by telling the truth” for a change.
So what can we, the youth, do to change the way these events are taught and remembered? Writer and labor activist Bill Fletcher says that educating ourselves is a big part of it and that “teens from different cultures and ethnic groups need to learn from each other’s cultures and ask questions.”
Fletcher’s own view about Columbus Day is this: “Beginning in 1492 a great tragedy began in this planet-the deaths of millions of Native Americans, the deaths of millions of Africans, and the dehumanization of Europeans. 1492 is a year that’s mourned forever. We should always take pride in those who resisted. Those should be the real heroes, not barbarians like Columbus.”

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.