Alternative HS: It All Depends on You

My high school is filled with almost 3000 students and unconcerned and unmotivating teachers. I used to feel like I was just taking up space in the dull, overcrowded classrooms. But in the second half of my senior year I finally managed to escape. I joined the Executive Internship Program and started getting the credits to graduate by writing for New Youth Connections.
Like me, a lot of teens around the city have found alternatives to their regular high schools. Barry Sparrow, 18, switched from a vocational high school in Staten Island to Manhattan’s Urban Academy where he says he’s “not just a number…[Here] everyone is taken as an individual.”
Expressing your individuality is possible at a place like Urban Academy partly because it only has about 100 students (one tenth the number at Barry’s old school.) There are 20 small, alternative high schools in all five boroughs. Students have the chance to work closely with their teachers, get treated with greater respect and learn in non-traditional ways.
Staying Out Of Trouble
Some students are referred to these schools because they missed classes, got into fights, or had other kinds of trouble at their old schools. But of the more than 275 students who came to alternative high schools in the last two years, after being suspended or thrown out of regular schools for “violent assault or weapons possessions,” not one has gotten into serious trouble at her new school.
Asked why he thought that was, Nef, 18, of Satellite Academy, said his school is “like a little family…Everyone gets to meet one another. [There’s] less chance of conflict.” Tangier Wilson, 16, also of Satellite Academy, added that because of all the attention students receive it’s possible to “nip problems in the bud.”
In addition to knowing one another, the students at Satellite have a role in most of the decisions that get made, including what students are accepted into the school. For that reason they tend to feel responsible for one another. “We look out for each other,” explained Dalmasi D. Ruiz, 19. “We try to keep [each other] out of trouble.”
Ed Reynolds, principal of West Side HS, where most of the students are older and have gone to an average of two to three other high schools previously, cited another reason: “If you treat [people] with respect, 99.9% respond with kindness.” For Donald Powell, 19, a student at West Side, that’s the biggest difference at an alternative high school. “Here they treat you like an adult,” he said.
People Gave Up On Me
Alternative high school students call teachers by their first names and have a different kind of relationship with them-both in and out of the classroom. “[Before] I was just a kid who went to the school,” explained one student at Urban Academy, “They treat me like I’m a lot more mature here…[The teachers are] all really cool. They’re smart and they treat me like I’m smart.”
Nef said that at his old schools “people gave up on me. I was a total basket case. Here they treat me like I’m smart.”
“I like teachers that care,” added Tangier. “Having somebody behind you makes you want to do better. You don’t want to disappoint them.”
But going to a school where everybody knows everybody can also have it’s drawbacks. “Gossip spreads fast,” said Tangier. “You got to keep your business to yourself.”
A Close-Knit School
For Alan Dichter, principal of Satellite Academy, that’s not always a problem. “If you want a school where you mind your business and they mind theirs,” he warned, “don’t come here.” Dichter boasted that his students sometimes have the same teacher two or three times so a strong personal relationship develops.
Still, some people need what a big school has to offer or are just more comfortable there. “We don’t offer [as wide] a variety of classes [as] a big school,” cautioned Dichter, “In certain areas…we might not be able to help [students] out.”
If it’s true that there’s less to choose from at an alternative high school, at least what they do have is not just more of the same. Many of the courses they offer have names like “The Influence of Latin America and the Caribbean on the South Bronx,” “Sexist Society,” or “Politics and Money.” In addition, students take courses at local colleges, get credit for helping to run the school, and do work in the community.
Satellite student Nicole Stoll, 17, got credit for working as the school secretary. Besides that she did “Peer Counseling” and worked on video documentaries at the Educational Video Center (EVC). Students like Tangier, Dalmasi, and Nef, who serve on the student government (CORE), help hire staff, set school discipline policy, and interview kids who apply to the school. They help design new classes and even serve as “co-teachers.”
…They Miss Me
At Urban Academy, everyone does a half day of “Community Service” per week. Matthew Gross, 15, works at a homeless center. Barry works at a local junior high school. He says the children he works with “look up to me. If I don’t come they miss me.”
Urban Academy co-director Ann Cook classes emphasize asking questions. “We want them to use their minds,” she explained. According to Matthew, this also involves “a lot of writing.” In spite of this, Matthew says that Urban Academy is “not very aggressive. [You’re] not pushed very hard.”
As with most alternative high schools, students at Urban Academy don’t get grades, only credit. Barry explained that in his experience, you’re “not penalized” if you don’t hand in your homework when it’s due. (On the other hand, you might not get the credit either.) A lot more responsibility lies with the student. “It’s all about who you are. [You] make it how you want it. It all depends on you,” said Nef. “You can’t come to [Satellite Academy] and feel it’s the easy way out,” warned Nicole.
Check Them Out
If you’re thinking of dropping out or want to make a change, talk to your guidance counselor about alternative schools or check the “Directory of Public High Schools.” Be aware that most of these schools have long waiting lists and require an interview. Ed Reynolds recommends first finding out “as much as you can about the school. Visit the school for half a day, check it out for yourself…Interview the school as they’re interviewing you.”
All of the students I talked to prefer their alternative high schools to the ones they came from. “I love it here,” said Brenda “B” Rodriguez, 18, of Satellite Academy. “It’s a big change…I don’t cut no more, don’t have problems with anyone. I’m into school now.”

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.