Double Standards Cloud the Real Reasons for War

Double Standards Cloud the Real Reasons for War

The “naked aggression” the United States government is suddenly so concerned about is something I experienced long before the trouble started between Iraq and Kuwait. In 1982 my country, Lebanon, was invaded by its powerful neighbor, Israel. I remember the air raid sirens and the sky lit up with anti-aircraft fire. I remember the bombs falling around us and the Israeli tanks lined up in the streets.
Thousands of civilians were killed in that invasion. The Israelis claimed they were protecting themselves from Palestinian-linked “terrorists” allegedly working out of “bases” in the southern part of the country. But they not only attacked these hotspots, they seized most of the country and even occupied Beirut (the capital) where my family lived. They withdrew only after installing a friendly government and establishing a “security zone.” (During the same period, Syria, a neighboring Arab state and hideous human rights abuser, occupied parts of Lebanon and suffered no attacks from the U.S.)
Wasn’t that naked aggression? The whole world-except the United States-seemed to think so. The community of nations voted unanimously to institute economic sanctions against Israel like those recently placed on Iraq, but the U.S. used its veto power to block that and all similar United Nations resolutions.
What Makes Hussein So Special?
No one rushed troops to the Lebanese border so that they could liberate us. Why not? Israel had nuclear bombs, an air force second to none and a shameful human rights record. Where was the concern over its atrocities or expansionism? What is the difference between their aggression and Saddam Hussein’s, and why the sudden revelations about his checkered past?
The answer is simple: Saddam Hussein was as much of a criminal on August 1 as he was a day later when the Iraqi army stampeded into Kuwait. But on August 1, he was still an American ally-one of the good guys. No one questioned his record of countless human rights violations, his disregard for human life, or his iron-grip on power because he was advancing U.S. interests. Once that changed, story after story surfaced about Hussein, his ruthless regime and sinister plans.
Ever since he invaded Kuwait on August 2, Saddam Hussein has been portrayed as a brutal dictator bent on achieving what Hitler could not-world domination. While Hussein is clearly no Mother Theresa, comparing him to Hitler is just as absurd and very, very dangerous.
The Hitler analogy has worked; it created hysteria and rallied support for the war, but has done little to sharpen our understanding of important events or give us insight into the motives of Saddam Hussein. Let’s put aside the colorful comparisons for a moment and take a look at the facts.
Iraq Was Provoked
While not necessarily justified, the Iraqi invasion of Kuwait was provoked. Hussein’s selfishness and expansionist plans were not solely to blame as the Bush administration would have us believe. Iraq had legitimate gripes with the Al-Sabah family which ruled Kuwait.
For starters, the oil-rich sheikdom was greedy. Months before the invasion, Iraqi officials complained about Kuwait’s breaking its agreements with other oil-producing countries in the region. They charged that it was producing too much oil and driving oil prices down. This hurt Iraq’s economy, which was already devastated from an eight-year war with Iran. The Kuwaiti sheiks (not the general population) were getting richer at the expense of the Iraqi people.
Even as it hindered Iraq’s efforts to rebuild by manipulating the oil market, Kuwait refused to take a raincheck on its neighbor’s $12 billion war debt. Hussein felt, and justifiably so, that since he had spent eight years protecting the whole region from Iran’s Shiite Muslims, led by the Ayatollah Khomeini, that the debt should have been forgiven altogether.
Back then, Saddam Hussein was still working for the U.S. Ironically, if you really want to use the Hitler analogy, it was he who saved the world from a regime truly bent on world domination-Iran. Most of the Gulf states including Iraq are controlled by Sunnis, a rival Muslim sect. These countries have significant Shiite populations however, which could easily have been mobilized against the ruling classes (and U.S. interests) through Khomeini’s call for an Islamic-fundamentalist revolution.
It isn’t hard to imagine just how irked Hussein was when he was stabbed in the back by the very countries he had spent nearly a decade defending.
Whatever his motivation, Hussein didn’t show any intention of annexing Kuwait at the beginning. He appointed a temporary government in the early days of the invasion which included Kuwaiti parliament members and other officials. His actions suggest that he was planning to withdraw his forces and leave in power a new government more sympathetic towards Iraq (sound familiar? Israel did it in Lebanon. The U.S. does it all the time. Remember Panama and Grenada?).
Hasty Reaction
But the U.S. reacted too quickly and blocked efforts at any diplomatic solution by demanding an unconditional Iraqi withdrawal from Kuwait and the restoration of the country’s “rightful” government (the Al-Sabah family) before negotiations could even begin.
As if that weren’t enough to ensure the outbreak of war, the U.S. immediately deployed thousands of combat troops to Saudi Arabia (without U.N. approval) in what they called “Operation Desert Shield.” They claimed they were protecting the Saudis from a possible Iraqi invasion. But such an invasion was highly unlikely, according to U.S. intelligence sources quoted in New York Newsday. After all, Hussein’s army could have stomped right into Saudi Arabia as easily as it had overcome the Kuwaitis. The only thing standing in its way at the time was an imaginary line in the desert.
For those who still insist that this “monster” must be contained before he gets any stronger, consider this: By any measure, the economic embargo was weakening Iraq and its people. Oil exports, the country’s most important source of revenue, had been cut by 97%. Bush and his intelligence officials verified shortages of food, raw materials, and military parts, as early as late September, when the President appeared to have abandoned sanctions and was leaning toward military action.
Sanctions Were Working
Even if the sanctions weren’t enough to achieve Bush’s stated objective of an “unconditional withdrawal” from Kuwait, they certainly were enough to stop Hussein from threatening other countries.
Six months was hardly enough time to expect sanctions to do more than that. In South Africa the U.S. has given limited sanctions years to work and never urged the United Nations to give that country’s racist regime a deadline for ending apartheid or stopping attacks on its neighbors. The U.S. didn’t haul off and start bombing Johannesburg. Why not?
Examples of dangerous men and naked aggression abound in today’s world-on both sides of the Atlantic. Let’s not allow stale images of Adolf Hitler and concentration camps cloud our vision; the U.S. was hell bent on going to war since the very beginning and not for any of the reasons we’ve been led to believe.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.