A Woman’s Place Is Not in the War Zone

In past wars, American women have served their country as nurses, doctors, and members of combat support and maintenance staffs-not by fighting side by side in combat with men.
Today, even though women in the military have the training and the job opportunities to fight in a war, I still believe that they should not have to fight unless they want to.
The law in the United States restricts women’s role in combat units, but women in the military are trained to defend themselves in case they are in combat situations. These laws have been on the books since 1948 for good reasons.
Traditionally, men have defended their country and protected women and children. Let’s not completely break this tradition. Just because women want equal rights doesn’t mean that they want equal opportunity to fight. Women should have the option to choose whether they want to be in combat situations or not.
There are physical and biological differences between men and women which won’t change no matter how much training women receive. Women are not built like men and are not as strong as men. Some military equipment requires strength because it was not designed with women in mind. Furthermore, the routine of carrying a 120-pound rucksack day in and day out in rough terrain may be difficult for some women to manage.
How Do Others Feel?
And what about public opinion? How would Americans feel about women coming home from war in body bags? More women soldiers are deployed in the Persian Gulf than in any other military conflict. If there is war, there will be thou-sands of body bags containing women and thousands more will be maimed and disabled-physically and psychologically.
Also, many women in the military have children. Who will raise their children if they die? I understand that fathers and other relatives can do the job, but I feel children have more of a need for the mothers who gave birth to them.
This doesn’t mean that women who want to fight won’t have the opportunity. Women participated in the invasion of Grenada in 1983 as military police, Air Force pilots, signal and communications officers, and helicopter crew chiefs. Also, in December 1989 when the United States invaded Panama, Captain Lynn Bray led a military police unit (which included men) in a combat operation.
Whether they go in combat or not, I’m sure that women realize the risks they take when they volunteer to join the military. The additional risks of fighting in a war should be limited to those women who choose to take them.
Let us first worry about women having equal rights in the workplace before we worry about their rights to die for their country on the battlefield.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.