Teenagers Can Learn to Stop Fights

You have probably seen a situation where two teens start to fight and a crowd quickly gathers and starts yelling “Fight! Fight!” and making things worse. But have you ever seen teens stop a fight or calm a conflict?
At the EARS program in the Bronx the conflict managers are teenagers. Yes, teenagers from age 12-16. They heard about EARS, through their school and friends. They had to complete two days of training which taught them how to resolve conflicts.
Don’t Take Sides
Most of the teens said that the first problem they encountered as conflict managers was being “neutral.” This means that when they help resolve conflicts, they can’t take sides, be disciplinarians, give orders, or be judgmental.
“It makes people feel more at ease, you’re not giving them opinions and you let them solve the problem,” said Kevin Richard, 14, Chelsea HS.
According to Elena Quitcon, a coordinator-trainer at EARS, teens who work at EARS must have the willingness to change negative behavior or just help somebody. They also have to keep conflicts strictly confidential. Some have to be on duty during lunchtime or after school, and it helps to be articulate and a good role model. Richard continued, “During the interview (for the job at EARS) you’re tested on if you can communicate and relate to a person.”
From California Courts To Bronx Schools
EARS was started in 1985, in the Bronx, and was modeled on a program in California. It was started by a lawyer who wanted people to sit down and talk to each other instead of going to court. Marcy May, the director of EARS, was the first person to be trained. She and Quitcon brought the program to New York where they felt it was needed most.
“I felt the problems were so immense (in society) that I wanted to contribute something,” said Quitcon.
EARS trains teens to avoid conflicts by using special skills. According to Quitcon, people can solve conflicts through denial (such as drinking, drugs, or suicide), confrontation (fighting, arguing, screaming), or problem solving (talking out the problem with someone). EARS trains teens in the problem-solving approach.
Many of the conflicts that teen trainers resolve are fights between teens. They also try to improve the quality of their schools by reducing suspensions and teen violence.
Michelle Gibson, 14, JHS 80, learned how to calm things down: “At first if someone was to have a fight, I would encourage them, now I discourage them to fight.”
Teens Can Resolve Conflicts
Quitcon thinks conflicts can be resolved by encouraging teens to use conflict resolution skills. “Our motto is ‘Let us help you help yourselves.’ It’s peers helping other peers.”
Quitcon added that since adolescents are the conflict managers at EARS, “We have mixed reactions [from adults]. Some approve, others don’t.”
Some adults feel that teen conflict managers might take away their authority and they feel threatened. But she said that when adults see how the teen trainers handle themselves, they react positively.
“Not only adults are capable of accomplishments, but teens can do it too,” said Hazel Bowe, 16, from JHS 80.
Some teens mentioned that they’ve helped friends cope with problems and resolved fights. A lot of the teens improved their family life, because they were able to speak to their parents a lot better. They also felt the program helped reduce conflict in school.
“I’ve been in that school [JHS 80] for four years and I’ve seen quite a lot of fights, but since the conflict resolution program, the fights have gone down, it’s helped a lot,” said Heather Galloway, 14, also from JHS 80.
“Before I joined the program I used to have a bad attitude, I used to say ‘What you staring at?’ or ‘Get out of my face,’ but now I’ve changed and I have more friends from my positive attitude,” she added.
Joe Cintron, 15, from JHS 45 mentioned the positive response the EARS teen trainers get after giving a presentation: “We went to City-As-School HS…They really liked the process and want us back. This one kid hugged everyone.”
The teen conflict managers feel that all teenagers should be involved in programs like EARS. “It helps a lot, all teens can do something to help someone else, also to help yourself…it kind of gives you a good feeling,” said Galloway.
Note: EARS stands for Effective Alternative Reconciliation Services.

SIDEBAR: Skits Show How to Chill Conflict
The EARS conflict managers, who are all teenagers, do 20 hours of training in the schools they visit. Part of the training consists of conflict skits. These skits are not only short and amusing but serious as well. Good Listening In one skit a girl (who we’ll call Mary) goes up to another girl (Jane) in school, and tells her she has a problem she wants to discuss. Jane tells her she is late for class and doesn’t have any time. In the middle of Jane’s statement, Mary tells her she is pregnant. Jane doesn’t even bother to listen and says she will talk to her later. So Mary gets no help in resolving her problem. They do this skit over again the right way: Mary goes to Jane and tells her the problem she was having. Jane doesn’t have any time but is willing to listen. When Mary tells her she is pregnant, Jane repeats it to make sure what she heard was correct (This is what they call “paraphrasing.” It basically means repeating in your own words what the other person said to be sure you’re communicating.) Since Jane is running late, she tells Mary to meet her in a designated place after school, so they can talk about it. Skits like this compare helpful and unhelpful ways to deal with conflicts.
He Said, She Said
In another skit, two participants from the audience are sent out of the room. A person in the room (Joe) is read a robbery report. This report includes where the robbery took place, what the robber looked like, and what he was wearing. After Joe is read the report, one of the participants out of the room comes back in. Joe then gives his version of what he remembers (which isn’t very much). The first participant then has to tell the second participant what she remembers. The second participant then has to tell the third, and so on, one by one until the very end when the robbery report only consists of what the robber was wearing (and that isn’t very precise either). But that’s the fun of the whole robbery report. It shows that when a story is passed on from one person to another, there are bound to be some details lost which may sometimes distort the story. This is how rumors get out of hand. The students learn how to effectively paraphrase, listen, diffuse anger, and understand eye messages. The interaction of the teen managers with the student audience promotes understanding. The students listen and try to understand because these are teens just like themselves.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.