It’s seventh period math. School is almost over and the day has gone well-so far. It’s time for group projects, and your teacher’s paired you up with someone you utterly despise. You’re so busy shooting bullets with your eyes you can barely concentrate!
Although the two of you have had serious confrontations in the past, you decide that you’ll try to be civil about the miserable situation. But your “partner” is going out of her way to make your life a living hell. She’s giving you dirty looks and cutting you off in the middle of well-structured sentences with snide remarks.
You try to stay above her level but slowly she begins to pull you down. When she tries to pull your chair out from under you, you can’t help but turn around and try to pull out each strand of her hair-and the fight begins.
When you get to the principal’s office, he tells you about a new form of problem-solving at your school. A fellow student called a mediator is going to sit down with you and help resolve the problem. The process is called conflict resolution.
At first, you’re not sure what to think. You have to promise not to cut each other off, not to curse, to try and be as honest as you can, and to try to come to an agreement. The mediator you’ve been assigned is in your Spanish class, and you wonder how he could possibly be of any help. He asks each of you in turn to explain what happened, and you do-grudgingly.
But eventually you begin to feel more comfortable. You tell the mediator how the two of you never really got along in the first place, and how you felt she was out to get you from the beginning. She agrees, and both of you realize how little you really know about each other. The student mediator helps you to agree that a collaborative project might not be so bad.
Create Win-Win Solutions
Conflict resolution enables people to talk openly about misunderstandings. While they may not want to become best friends, they may need to establish a working relationship, and conflict resolution attempts to make that happen. Student mediators help to create solutions that are win-win, or equally beneficial for both parties.
“In the past my response to any conflict was self-righteous, that I was right and the other [person] was wrong,” said Jason Warwin, a 17-year-old mediator at Central Park East Secondary School (CPESS) in Manhattan. Warwin said he learned a lot from the conflict resolution program in his school: “In order to resolve a conflict peacefully, it is helpful to establish a win-win situation.”
“I learned matters could be discussed maturely and intelligently,” added Melvin Cruz, 17, another student mediator at CPESS.
The program was started in 1988 at Central Park East Secondary School by Tom Roderick, executive director for Educators for Social Responsibility. Starting with a group of about 20 student volunteers, it has since expanded to 50 students-10 from each grade. Students and faculty of CPESS participate in 20-hour training sessions and monthly follow-up sessions which promote effective mediation and intercultural understanding.
“One of the skills of leadership is to be able to mediate conflicts and to help people to work together,” commented Jill Herman, teacher and liaison between faculty and students.
Student mediators are trained to develop good listening skills, the ability to paraphrase (restate what was heard during a conflict), and a certain diplomacy when mediating, so that one student doesn’t feel less important or less fairly represented.
Rules For Mediation
Before mediation can take place, the participants must agree to certain rules. There is no cursing, name-calling or interrupting allowed during mediation, and disputants must agree to resolve the conflict.
Mediators ask the disputants to explain what happened, and to think of ways they would like to see the problem remedied. The process is not over until a consensus is reached-even if staying away from each other for a while is the only resolution the people in conflict can agree on.
Mediators learn to be non-judgmental- they are taught not to use phrases like “you should” or “you have to” when attempting to resolve a conflict. They also learn how to overcome biases, how to avoid pre-judging a dispute, and how to work with other mediators.
All information about a conflict must be kept totally confidential. Without this guarantee, it would be difficult for disputants to trust mediators.
Student mediators engage in two to three hour afternoon training sessions about once a month. Sometimes weekend retreats are arranged for intensive training. At these gatherings, students discuss problems or questions they might have as mediators, share experiences, and support each other.
On a recent field trip, student mediators talked about stereotypes which often cause conflicts.
“Many conflicts arise out of clashes between different groups and cultures,” said Herman. “Having a better awareness of these different groups and cultures helps [us] to be better mediators,” she added.
Stereotypes Can Lead to Conflict
“Everyone has stereotypes against people. Everyone was making jokes about homosexuals, blacks, women…I found out that I was a little prejudiced against homosexuals,” admitted Maryam Washington, 16.
By identifying stereotypes, mediators learn how they contribute to conflicts.
Acquiring the skills to mediate conflicts without violence is very empowering. Student mediators are respected more by their peers because they help them resolve conflicts without intervention by adults.
“Within the school environment the traditional role of discipline has been afforded the teacher, yet through conflict resolution and mediation, students have now been empowered to control their own self-discipline,” said Warwin.
But creative conflict resolution works only for students who want help.
“I feel mediation is a good strategy when the parties involved agree to resolve the conflict,” Warwin said. “When this premise is not established, conflict resolution will not work.”
Some students have come to mediators unwilling at first to make any kind of compromise. They are not ready to really hear what the other person has to say.
“Most people have better talking skills than listening skills,” Herman said. “It’s important to be a good listener. When you don’t listen, you misinterpret what people say. By restating them we really know what we heard. These are good skills in life because you can clarify a lot of things.”
Conflict resolution is well worth implementing in any school. For more information about the Creating Conflict Creatively Program, call Linda Lantieri at (212) 260-6290 or Tom Roderick at (212) 870-3318.
Student Mediators Help Both Sides Win
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.