Communication Is the SMART Way at Humanities HS

Last term a girl in my school got killed. It was very sad. Jessica (not her real name) was young and vibrant and everybody knew her or at least knew of her.
The day that her death was announced, the school was in an uproar. Everybody was just floating around and not going to class. You could hear her friends’ cries echoing throughout the school. I could even hear them in the gym in the school’s basement.
As I was leaving my class that day I saw a group of girls running in the hall screaming, “She went that way, she went that way!”
I didn’t know what was going on, so I grabbed my friend who was running with them. She told me they were chasing a girl who made a nasty remark about Jessica’s death.
“What did she say?” I asked.
“She said she didn’t like her anyway and she’s glad she’s dead.”
“Who said that?”
When my friend told me, I knew it couldn’t be true. Alysha (not her real name), the girl they were chasing, was one of the nicest girls I knew. She was in my class and she came in smiling and bright every morning. She was known for being quiet and keeping to herself. I couldn’t see those words coming out of her mouth.
Rumors and More Rumors
“Did you hear her say that?” I asked my friend.
“No, but somebody overheard her talking to her friends and they told us.”
“I didn’t know you knew Jessica.”
“I didn’t really, but I have to go,” she said, and then she ran off to join her friends.
I got angry. The next day I heard even more outrageous rumors as to what Alysha said. The rumor that girls were out to kill her for what she supposedly said about Jessica was the `Aim’ in all of my classes. I noticed Alysha didn’t come to class and I found out she was being kept from school by the principal for her own safety.
This rumor thing had blown the situation totally out of hand. It was finally resolved a couple of days later when Alysha came back to school and there was a meeting with her and the other girls.
It turned out that what Alysha actually said was that she didn’t know Jessica and therefore she couldn’t relate to her death.
That incident is over, but I always felt that the confrontation could have been avoided had they talked it out. Instead of getting angry at what they thought was said, they could have talked calmly to come to an understanding rather than resorting to violence.
Getting Smart
An anti-violence project called SMART (School Mediators’ Alternative Resolution Team) is underway in 15 high schools and one junior high school. SMART, founded in 1983, is an advanced mediation training geared to resolving school conflicts.
Jessie Kline, the teacher/coordinator of SMART at Humanities HS in Manhattan, works with 40 students to resolve school conflicts and says the program has improved the school atmosphere as students learn to respect their peers.
To mediate conflicts, students learn to use neutral language, “to speak in such a way that you’re not leaning to another side,” according to Savonna Campbell, 16, a SMART mediator at Humanities.
Erin Hickerson, 17, agrees: “It works so much because you have a better chance of coming to a resolution when you speak to somebody as a human being.”
But if neutral talking doesn’t work, the students resort to role reversal, which is getting each person to understand the other’s side.
There is also the cost of not settling. For example, if two people cannot resolve their problem and still want to fight, they can be threatened with suspension. However, Kline said, “we only use it as a last resort.”
Each mediator learns about students’ cultural backgrounds, which allows them to dispel stereotypes and prejudices in their work.
Positive Reactions
So with their mediation ammunition in hand, the students set out to solve conflicts. Ironically, most of the conflicts that arise are not racial. They are mostly “he-said, she-said, gossip situations, or people bump into other people and didn’t say sorry,” said Kline.
Sometimes there are even teacher/ student or parent/child mediation situations.
A lot of teachers and students have gotten smart, no pun intended. Even Chris Gallo, a school security officer, is a mediator. “I wanted a better way of dealing with children,” he said.
The student mediators seem positive about the whole program. Sharrod Fredericks, 18, thinks it’s vital. “I don’t think people could solve [their own problems]. It’s always about fights and stuff, but it’s also about pride.” Some people don’t want to give in, he said.
Hickerson, however, disagrees: “If everybody would sit down and listen…the majority of people I’ve mediated are mature enough to handle it on their own.”
But when I think back to the fight in my school, I don’t think they could have solved it on their own. Not only were they angry about what they thought they heard, they were angry about their friend’s death and needed a scapegoat. Also, they didn’t want to admit that they were wrong.
Just as I was concluding the interviews, I heard shouting in the hall. The security officer ran out and within seconds I heard his voice and then calm talking from the two shouters.
A mediator’s work is never done.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.