Chancellor Fernandez on the Curriculum and School Reform

Schools Chancellor Dr. Joseph A. Fernandez was interviewed by New Youth Connections on April 30. The following NYC reporters participated in the interview: Matthew Sweeney, Latysha Place, Fitzcarl Reid, Tonya Leslie, Jean-Daniel LaRock, Mohamad Bazzi, and Njemile Davis. A partial transcript follows.
Matthew: What are your top three priorities for the New York City public school system?
Fernandez: Number one is reducing the dropout rate… Secondly, reducing the disparity between-academic disparity-between minority students and non-minority students. And then the third is to try to put back into the schools some of the curricula and extra-curricula, at least, that was in there back in the late seventies.
For example, every school should have a newspaper, every school should have a library. There are schools in the school district-the school system-that don’t have libraries. Those are the kind of things we have to infuse back into the schools.
Matthew: What do you see as a goal for the dropout rate?
Fernandez: It’s one thing for me sit in this office and say, okay, we’re going to reduce the rate by 5 percentage points and then for the people out in the field to tell you that’s too difficult a task. So we’re looking for anywhere between [a] 2-5 percentage point reduction each year. That’s our goal; that’s what I’m shooting for.
Right now we have an overall dropout rate of about 30%…but within different groups, some are represented more than others.
For example, Hispanics have the highest dropout rates, followed by African- Americans and, of course, followed by Whites. Among the Whites, it appears that the Italian-Americans probably have the highest dropout rates…
Latysha: Except for a few select schools, most high school newspapers are poor in quality and not published regularly. Is there anything you can do to revitalize the waning high school press?
Fernandez: It’s not like I’m going to sit here and tell you that we’re gonna have all kinds of dollars to play with. we’re not. However, there’s a model which we have developed which is the shared decision-making/school-based management, which basically gives schools latitude with their budget…If the school decides that that’s one of the key things that’s very important to them, and I think a lot of the schools will, particularly if they have student input, then they have the right to redirect some resources.
I’m not in the position yet to say every school will have a newspaper…but ultimately, when all of the smoke settles, we have to have…at least a core extra-curricula/curriculum program at every school. I mean it shouldn’t really differ regardless of where a school is situated-what kind of parental support you have or community support.
Tonya: Most high school students I’ve spoken to have not received any drug education…
Fernandez: Have not received?
Tonya: …or not a very strong drug education program at all. What are your plans to improve and enforce the present drug education program and services in schools?
Fernandez: We have mandates from the feds on that. As I said to you earlier, that’s one of the places we get federal funds for-there’s a substance abuse program.
Incidentally, I’m surprised at that because there’s two things that you should be aware of here in New York City. Number one: there’s a national survey that was recently completed that shows a decline, at least in the schools, in terms of drug use, sales and so forth-about 17% nationally.
Secondly, you’re all familiar with the Gill Commission? The Gill Commission is a local commission that was put together by the mayor and the Board of Education to look at corruption, crime, so forth in the school system. And they put in undercover policemen in the schools-senior high schools.
They expected to go in and find all kinds of drugs going on in the school and that’s not what they found. They found a lot of it going on outside of the schools, but in the schools themselves, it was limited in terms of the activity that was taking place. That doesn’t mean that we’re out of the woods with this thing, obviously…
So we’ve put several things in place: we’ve said that we want to have our work places drug free. So starting September, all employees that come to work in New York City schools have to take drug screening. Right now that’s not the case. I could be a future teacher and I would come to New York City schools and I wouldn’t necessarily get tested…
The other thing is we’ve looked at what’s called drug-free schools where we try to force the sellers away from the schools and that was something that was experimented with in New Jersey where they talk about drug-free [school] zones… If they’re going to be involved in any kind of drug trafficking, it has to be at least 1,000 feet away from the school. I can’t tell you how effective that has been because the jury is still out on that.
Now, programatically, we’ve put a monitoring piece in place here to look at what we call compliance. We can’t go out and monitor all 1100 schools, obviously. But there are mandates out there [on] what schools are supposed to be doing in terms of substance abuse. It’s very disconcerting that you say that students you’ve talked to have not gotten any instruction at all.
Mohamad: How would you make sure that all schools are following these drug education prevention programs?
Fernandez: You don’t. That’s what I was saying. You can’t possibly monitor 1,100 schools, you do like any auditor does, you do spot monitoring, you do sampling. And when you start finding problems, then you start correcting those problems…
Njemile: How can more alternative high schools be introduced in the system? I go to an alternative school that offers a broader and more flexible curriculum.
Fernandez: First of all, I think our schools are too big. I’m a firm believer that you gotta make the schools smaller. Now physically, we can’t do it because our schools are all so overcrowded. But what you can do [is] schools within the school. A lot of districts across this country are looking at that, where they create smaller schools within schools, with their own teachers, their own students, and everything else. Particularly in middle schools, I might add.
I believe again, getting back to the school-based management, one of the important things about it is that schools will be able to profit from those kinds of recommendations. They’ll be able to say, look, we’re too big, we’ve got 3,000 kids here, and we’d rather break it up into schools of 1,000 each with its own staff and its own curriculum and its own portion of the building to do those kind of things in.
Mohamad: Recent reports indicate that your programs in Miami are not working as well as hoped…
Fernandez: Let me ask you where these reports came from.
Mohamad: …and you got an incomplete from the Miami Hearald in an article that appeared on January 1st. Now you sort of began to get into school-based management. Can you give us your personal…
Fernandez: I can show you also an editorial from the Herald where they gave me an A+. But you have to understand that there were very bad feelings that I left Miami. They just gave me a new contract so they felt that that kind of betrayed them…
I can show you evaluations that show that what we’ve been doing there is working. In fact, I can show you books written by educational specialists. This reform we’re doing is not only in Miami and New York…Everyone that knows anything about education believes that schools are failing the way they’re structured now. The make-up of the student body has created needs…
When I went to school, we didn’t have to deal with homeless kids, we didn’t have to deal with AIDS…We have 25 crack babies born every single day here in New York City. That’s the equivalent of a kindergarten class. If they survive, by the time those kids get to school, think of the needs and the services that those particular kids have to have.
Sixty-three percent of our kids are poor in New York City. That’s about one out of every seven. It’s projected that by the year 2000, it’ll probably be one out of every four…Poor kids need a head start. That means you have to have early childhood programs in there.
Why do you have the highest dropout rate among Latinos? Because they can’t speak English, so they become very frustrated…That’s why you need a very good bilingual program, and English as a second language.
When you put all these pieces together, we’re trying to operate like we did 20, 25 years ago and we can’t operate that way anymore. We gotta open up our schools differently.
Mohamad: So what you’re saying is school-based management and shared decision-making will bring us back to where we used to run schools 20, 25 years ago?
Fernandez: Twenty, twenty-five years ago you didn’t have the student population you have now. That’s the point I was trying to make…What we’re trying to do right now is try to find a different way that we can operate our schools so we can provide the programs that the kids need.
Now how do you do it? You ask your experts out there, you ask the teachers in the classroom. You ask any teacher in the classroom and they’ll criticize what they have to teach in terms of the curriculum. They’ll say, if I had my way, I wish we could do it this way. I’m suggesting that schools have the ability to shape it the way they think they have to shape it, like they did at her [Njemile’s] school. That’s exactly what happened with her school. We turned it over to the administration and the teachers and the parents and that’s how they shaped that school.
we’re suggesting that you make that available to all the schools that want to be a school-based management school-so they can shape it the way they think they need it.
NYC: Dr. Fernandez, could you define school-based management/shared decision-making in a way that our teen readers can understand?
Fernandez: School-based management/shared decision-making basically is a bottom-up rather than top-down philosophy. It allows people at the school site, not in the central office or the Chancellor’s office, but at the school site, to determine what goes on at the school. It gives them a latitude with the budget; it gives them latitude with staffing; and it gives them latitude with control over time.
In the high schools, it should involve students, it should involve teachers, it should involve parents and of course the school administration. More often than not, decisions are made without students being involved, without teachers being involved, and yet teachers are the ones that have to deliver those programs. And what we’re saying is that there is a wealth of talent out there that can be tapped into that we haven’t tapped into before.
Mohamad: How will students be involved?
Fernandez: It will vary from school to school. School-based management is not a neat package which says every school will look like this, some schools will look like this. It will vary, okay? So now each school will decide how they’ll involve the student population…And then there will be training sessions…Will there be students on the training level or will it be student government? That’s something each school will decide.
Njemile: Well, will there be a minimum number of students involved?
Fernandez: Well, specifically, it’s not a number. Neither are there a [specific] number of parents. The only reason there’s a [specific] number of teachers is because I had to work within the contract…the existing UFT contract which was here before we got here…which says 75% of the faculty has to vote to participate. In order for it to be school-based management, you need 75% of the faculty, you need the parent organization to sign-off, you need the principal to sign off. [If] any of those three pieces are missing, the school can’t become school-based management.
Our reason for that is that if the faculty is not going to want to participate, you can’t make it happen. If the principal does not want it to be a school-based management school, you can’t make it happen.
Jean-Daniel: How will school-based management/shared decision-making affect relationships between schools, community organizations, and public agencies?
Fernandez: I think there will be a major impact, because the whole idea of school-based management is to use the school differently. Right now, for all intents and purposes…schools operate 8:00 to 3:00. Why aren’t senior high schools open until 10:00 at night-all of them-not just some of them?
Why aren’t they a focal point where people can go and use the gym, athletic teams, you know PAL, or various organizations? Why can’t we have bilingual classes for our large immigrant class here that wants to learn English? Why can’t we have vocational training going on? Why can’t we have youth groups meeting there?
I mean, you name it, it could be there. And the school, at one time in the city, when I grew up in the city…we had everything going on at the school. We fell away from that because of hard times. But we’ve got to return it to the point where schools serve as the focal center…even if it means providing the health services at the schools, unemployment services at the schools.
Njemile: What is the Board of Education doing to make its adult staff-teachers, principals, administrators-more reflective of the racial and ethnic makeup of the student body?
Fernandez: Well, the board just passed [an] affirmative action plan…It’s a very strong plan because it has what’s called manifest under-representation. When you show that, it’s department by department…And if you are manifestly under-represented, I can set a quota on you, which is the first time that we have introduced quotas.
In the past, it’s basically “Hey gang, we’ve got [an] affirmative action plan and we’re all going to try our very best to get things to change.”
But you know, that doesn’t always work that way-you got to put teeth into it.
Now, the other thing we’ve done…we’ve created several internship programs for minorities, so that we can get minorities from the pipeline in terms of being school administrators. And when I mentioned the career ladder for paraprofessionals, most of our paraprofessionals are minorities…By offering college scholarships to many of them, which is what we are doing and letting them work at the same time, we’re bringing them back into the field as teachers.
Beyond that, our recruiting in primarily the Black universities and colleges across this country, our recruiting in Puerto Rico for Latinos, our going to heavily Hispanic hot spots like Miami, parts of Texas, part of California, in Chicago where we know there is a large Hispanic population…
But that still won’t fit at all, so we have to grow our own teachers…That’s why we have to go to school-based management/shared decision-making…Why aren’t kids going into teaching?…Who wants to be hassled serving lunchroom duty or doing unnecessary paperwork, doing things that a professional normally wouldn’t do? So we have to improve the workplace for teachers. And the whole issue of improving the workplace for teachers is giving them some input and some control of what is going on in the schools…
Mohamad: Most public schools scrounge for money while at the central Board of Education there is enough money to pay for high salaries, like yours, and to spend over $1 million for your home. Now how do you justify this?
Fernandez: First of all, it is not my home, it’s the Chancellor’s home, okay?…Every college president in New York City has a Chancellor’s home. Okay, so it’s not unique. But that is something probably better put to the school board and ask them why they did it.
All I know is that when I was approached about coming here, certain things were offered to me in terms of the Chancellor job. Now, I was making in Miami-since you want to get into the personal stuff I’ll be glad to-my salary in Miami would have been comparable to what I am making here. I was approached to come here. I didn’t come after this job, they came after me.
I’d like to think that they came after me because of the job we were doing in Miami in terms of what was going on in terms of restructure. I committed to being here through 1993, and then we’ll talk after that to see if I want to stay…
As far as the central office…when we took over there were 5,200 positions-that includes everybody, not just administrators. We’ve got that down-between what we’ve cut out and the transfers of the construction authority-down to about 4,600 positions…So we think we’ve streamlined it, we’ve flattened it considerably.
Tonya: How does your experience as a dropout affect your perspective as an educator?
Fernandez: …I don’t blame the school system for my situation. I feel that probably, in my circumstance, I was in too large a school-I was in Commerce High School, which was [on] double session and there were over 4500 students. I didn’t feel that I could make a contact or connection with a teacher, for whatever reason. I mean, don’t ask me to explain, this is how I recall it now. And my connection was primarily with the group of students that were not interested in staying in school…A one-on-one mentor, or at least not too many people at the same time, I think it could have probably turned me around. What turned me around was the military.
Tonya: So are you going to implement a mentor program in the schools?
Fernandez: Yes, that’s a very big program that we have in place. I just went to speak this morning to a group at CUNY. I served as a mentor for a student in [a] middle school. We’ve asked the business people to give time to serve as mentors. We have some very influential people that have agreed to adopt entire classes and take them under their wing. But you’ve got to follow through on it. It’s like being a big brother to somebody or a big sister.
Fitzcarl: Just one more thing. How come gay and lesbian history was not mentioned in the proposed curriculum revisions?
Fernandez: The whole issue is not intended to be left out…But you’ve got to understand that they’re [curriculum and instruction people at the state level] not sitting down right now and saying today that by next year all of our curriculum will be multi-cultural-it won’t be. They’re taking segments of it at a time.
Jaime Escalante, the teacher in California…the way he got those Mexican-American kids so involved is he showed them the major role that their ancestors played in developing mathematics. It was one of the key things. You can’t miss that message there…We have no idea of that when we teach mathematics.
I used to be a high school math teacher. It was never part of the curriculum. You never give a perspective in terms of how these things came about and who was involved with it. It’s basically isolated, it’s not throughout the whole thing, and that is what we’ve really got to do…
You’ve got to do it everywhere. You’ve got to do it in health, you’ve got to do it in math, you’ve got to do it in science, you’ve to do it everywhere.
NYC: Are students helping shape the curriculum?
Fernandez: There are students that are sitting on that committee.
Tonya: How much power do they have?
Fernandez: Well, I can’t answer that because I am not a member of the committee, but they’ll have a tremendous input. People are going to listen to what students have to say. The day and age when people don’t listen to students is gone. And the day and age when we try to keep parents out is gone. It’s just a matter of convincing everybody that is the case.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.