Students Protest Katzman’s Remarks By Bernadette Butler
On Wednesday, March 14, about 300 people, most of them high school and college students, marched in a protest rally to City Hall. They called for the dismissal of the chairman of the City Council’s education committee, Arthur Katzman.
The rally was prompted by recent remarks by the 85-year-old chairman in a newspaper interview: “The children of European-born parents brought with them a love and respect for learning…that helped to keep up the character of our schools. With Black and Hispanic children, there appears to be no liking of learning.” Katzman later apologized for the remarks.
The racist nature of Katzman’s statement outraged not only Blacks and Hispanics, but Whites as well. Many ethnic groups were represented at the demonstration.
‘Arthur Katzman’s Gotta Go’
At a meeting of the African-American history club at Julia Richman HS, my fellow students and I were very offended when we read Katzman’s remarks. We decided to join the protest rally to City Hall and helped to give out flyers informing other students about it.
So I was among the demonstrators who carried signs, handed out leaflets, and chanted: “Hey, Hey, Ho-Ho, Arthur Katzman’s gotta go!”
Organized by Professor James Blake of Borough of Manhattan Community College, the main objective of the demonstration was to force Mayor David Dinkins to respond to us: we wanted Katzman to resign and we wanted the city to recognize our demand for an equal, non-racist education.
By protesting, we defended our love for learning and our concern about the quality of the education we’re getting. Non-white students make up 80% of the New York City public school system, so Katzman’s attitude could directly impact his decisions as chairman of the education committee. We can’t allow him to further endanger the poor education we already receive. Our goal is to either educate him or get rid of him.
We had a permit to peacefully march to City Hall. When the police told us that we could not go up those steps, we took over the streets and blocked traffic for about 20 minutes. We were determined that our message be heard.
Surrounded by Cops
Prof. Blake was escorted into the building by Cynthia Jenkins, a Queens member of the State Assembly. On his return, he told us: “No one is allowed to go in, and if they do so, they will be arrested.”
As we gathered to listen to Blake, the police surrounded and intimidated us with their guns, night sticks, and billy clubs. At this point, some students left, but those whose commitment was strong refused to turn back.
During the rally, a 19-year-old student was arrested. A group of students who were at the demonstration plan to support him in court.
Blacks and Hispanics are an important constituency of New York City. At 18, everyone-even students-has the right to vote. Elected officials and the people they appoint must treat all students with respect.
Mayor Dinkins, if you really were sincere when you made your campaign promises, help Black and Hispanic students get equal treatment by our educational system and the leaders who represent us.
Dump Arthur Katzman!
Students Protest Katzman’s Remarks
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.