At the beginning of eighth grade I decided I wanted to attend Brooklyn Tech. I planned to become an architect- a nice little goal to set for yourself when you’re 12. Life-long objectives change frequently at that age. But I wanted to become an architect and I was going to design the next Taj Mahal.
I started taking architecture in Brooklyn Tech at 15. But after a year I realized that I hated it. Yet if I left architecture to study a different major, I would have to attend Brooklyn Tech for another year. My other option was not to take a major at all, and Tech had nothing to offer me outside my major.
When I decided to transfer from Tech to City-As-School last September, the counselor in their admissions office couldn’t have been more familiar with the process. At that point, he had probably memorized the Tech address and phone number. Accepting Brooklyn Tech students who were transferring out in droves had become routine.
A Wave of Transfers
Harold Serper, the admissions counselor at City-As-School Brooklyn, said, “We have been getting a load of applicants in the past two years…almost one-third of the [transfer] students come from Brooklyn Tech.”
Brooklyn Tech is frequently compared with the almighty Stuyvesant and the prestigious Bronx High School of Science. So why did I, along with masses of my peers, leave?
Serper said, “I think an awful lot of kids come because they shouldn’t have gone [to Brooklyn Tech] in the first place. Junior high schools tell them to go there. The Tech major is too technical. I think the kids also get lost at Brooklyn Tech…The students should have more information about the school.”
Serper continued, “I have found that some of the kids from Brooklyn Tech come here and do the same thing.”
So the problem sometimes exists in the student and not the school.
I remember seeing a statistic: 99% of Tech graduates go on to college each year. I see now that this statistic is misleading. Those who graduate will go on to college, but how many actually graduate from Tech? According to Board of Education statistics, only 63.5% of the original freshmen class got their diplomas in 1987-compared with 81% at Bronx Science and 83% at Stuyvesant.
Betty Chau, a 17-year-old honor student at Tech, said that students “before they come to Brooklyn Tech, think it’s really easy and they start cutting out, and they can’t stop. So sooner or later, they get thrown into Truancy [a dropout prevention program] and have to stay another year.”
Many students blame teachers for their dissatisfaction.
“Not all the teachers really care about the students. Some of the teachers look down on the students. So that comes out in their teaching and when the students do not do well, it’s not always their fault,” said Scott Matthews, 17.
A Lack of Information
From my experience at Tech, teachers frequently give this advice to the problem student: leave, go to a different high school, and find yourself there. But it’s a cop-out which offers no encouragement to students.
“There are some teachers who don’t belong here,” agreed Armie Arnique, 16, an honor student. “Sometimes there is a lack of communication.”
Students also complain about guidance counselors at Brooklyn Tech. “My guidance counselor [at Brooklyn Tech] said it would be better to get my GED because I had 16 credits, and I was 17 and [only] a junior,” said Rohan Balgobia, 18, who transferred to City-As-School Brooklyn. “City-As-School gave me 20 credits in one year.”
At the root of the problem is a lack of information. Most students don’t know much about Brooklyn Tech, but apply because it is easier to be accepted there than to any of the other specialized schools. In any case, it beats their zoned school.
“When I applied here, I really didn’t know much about Tech,” said Arinque. Obviously, that didn’t make a difference because she’s happy with her situation and will probably graduate with honors.
Alex Ganiaris, a 17-year-old honor student, said one of the pros of Brooklyn Tech is “the fact we have majors…” But he also added, “I really didn’t know anything about Brooklyn Tech [when I first applied here].”
Now as contradictory as it may sound, Joseph Cuzzocrea, a guidance counselor at Brooklyn Tech, said, “They do have a major orientation program. We do have pamphlets about the school…they permit the parents to walk around the school and they permit the parents to ask any questions about the school.”
While information is available, too many students don’t make the effort to get it. So why do students want to go to a school they didn’t bother to find out about?
‘Lesser of Two Evils’
“I passed the test you have to take and my zoned school was Lincoln and I didn’t want to go there,” said Raymond Terena.
Asked why he attended Brooklyn Tech, Matthew Bautista, 16, said, “One of my older siblings attended the school.” He added that this was the only specialized school he was accepted to.
“I think any student who passes the exam to get into Brooklyn Tech can do well here, if they go to the orientation and they read the pamphlets. Our principal, Mr. Tobin, will answer any questions parents may have about the school,” said Cuzzocrea about the admissions procedure. But he added that a student must want the Tech diploma-a question that cannot be truly answered on any entrance examination.
Asked if a student may attend Brooklyn Tech as a negative choice, Cuzzocrea stated, “They come here because they’re afraid their school won’t offer them a proper education. It’s like the lesser of the two evils.”
Cuzzocrea commented favorably on the curriculum and the status of Brooklyn Tech: “We have both the academic as well as technical science and math oriented courses, as opposed to most schools that have just the academic or just the technical.”
Brooklyn Tech does have a wide range of technical and science majors. But the rigor of these majors is what many students have difficulty coping with.
Specialized Majors
Many Brooklyn Tech students stated that the great advantage of the school is the option to choose your own major-a particular field that a student can focus on during her final two years in the school. Examples of majors include aeronautics, the bio-medical program, chemistry, computer science, and electrical engineering.
But one of the drawbacks to the “choose your major” education is the process of selection. If you choose Tech’s impressive Computer Science Program, you will go through a more rigorous selection process than the standard admissions examination. You choose your major near the end of your sophomore year, so the first three terms at Tech determine your destiny. The cream of the crop gets their choice of majors, while the others have to eat what they’re served.
don’t get me wrong, all the majors at Tech are good. If a student is truly interested in her major-wonderful. But there are plenty of students who are just sweating it out, waiting for graduation day.
When asked about the supposed weight that a Brooklyn Tech diploma carries, Scott Rozany replied, “That and $1.15 will get you a token.”
But he also stated, “I feel that Tech has a better diploma because of alumni. They can get you into good industries.”
Cuzzocrea said this about the Brooklyn Tech diploma: “It helps if there’s a toss-up with another student because our school is more demanding. I’ll tell you when it hurts-coming from Brooklyn Tech, your average may not be as high because of the higher [standards of the] curriculum.”
Brooklyn Tech is a wonderful school. But Tech should not be overestimated or underestimated. To do well, one must make an absolute commitment to study a specific range of subjects.
Just as Brooklyn Tech should make a greater effort to inform prospective students about their very structured system, the students should take the responsibility to make an informed decision. To be offered a prestigious education is to be given a priceless gift, but students have to be prepared to accept the gift Tech has to offer.
Transferring in Droves: Do Tech Students Know What They’re Getting Into?
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.