Greater Recognition for Non-Whites: Educators Call for Cultural Diversity iâ

Have you ever wondered why your social studies class only seemed to give half the story-the European side-when it came to history? Have you wondered why people of color have been invisible in your textbooks?
It seems that the people who run the school system have finally begun to wonder, too.
The State Education Department now recognizes that a multicultural curriculum is lacking throughout the state. This has a special impact on the New York City school system, where 80% of the students are Latino, native American, Asian, or African-American, reflecting a world population which is also primarily non-White.
A task force commissioned by the state recently found that the current curriculum “had a damaging effect on the psyche of young people of African, Asian, Latino, and native American descent” because it “systematically distorted, marginalized, or omitted” non-European contributions to American culture.
The task force report (“A Curriculum of Inclusion”) made nine specific recommendations to give greater recognition in the curriculum to the contributions of non-White cultures. These recommendations were presented to the Board of Regents on February 16. The Regents voted unanimously to proceed with the development of the plan.
Strong Reactions
Educators had a wide range of reactions to the report. “I feel that the conclusions reached by the report are accurate in stating that the current curriculum is written from the Euro-centric perspective, and excludes, and in many cases distorts, the true history of people of color,” said Diana Caballero, director of the Puerto Rican/Latino Education Round Table and a member of the state task force.
Asked if she felt the current curriculum gave enough recognition to the contributions of Latinos, Caballero replied, “Absolutely not. Our people are pretty much invisible. For Latinos, it lumps us all together in one category as if we’re all the same.” She noted that the current state curriculum omits historical information about Puerto Rico.
“I didn’t like the report,” said Diane Ravitch, professor of history and education at Columbia University’s Teachers College. “The reason I’ve criticized the report is because it has an angry tone. I think the people who wrote the report want to put down Whites and Europeans. We all have to live together without bias.”
Ravitch served on a committee of 20 teachers and scholars who revised the history curriculum in California from kindergarten through the 12th grade. “They now learn about great men and women from all cultures,” said Ravitch.
Asked what New York State could learn from California, Ravitch replied, “I think what New York State can learn is that California put a very strong emphasis on world history.”
Elliot Salow, director of social studies at the Board of Education, said: “There are many parts of the curriculum that I support. We should include the `left out’ history.” Like Ravitch, Salow had some misgivings about the report: “I disagree with the tone of the report…But overall, it sent a strong message of inclusion.”
Support for Diversity
Other educators supported both the tone and content of the proposed changes.
“The tone was strong for a very good reason,” said Evelyn Kalibala, director of multicultural education at the Board of Education. “It’s a subject that has been ignored for a very long time.”
Jack Kuo Wei Tchen, associate director of the Asian-American Center at Queens College, said that while he fully supported the basic recommendations, “What I’m concerned about is that the curriculum cannot be a celebration of everybody’s diversity and everyone’s contributions. It has to be more than that. For it to be good history, it has to look at how `We The People’ has been defined over time. Race, class, and gender have all been factors in who counts as a citizen, and who doesn’t count.”
Margo Thunderbird, co-director of the American Indian Community House in Manhattan, said, “Revising the current curriculum is a cultural imperative…I hope when the time comes to do the writing [of the curriculum] they hire people of color.” She also said that since many non-White cultures have an oral tradition, the writers of the new curriculum shouldn’t be limited to people with traditional academic degrees.
The members of the Board of Regents played a major role in reviewing the Task Force’s report.
“The Board of Regents is responsible for the development of curriculum materials that are recommended for use in schools around the state,” said Adelaide Sanford, the only Black member of the Board of Regents, which has the final say in adopting the changes.
“The Commissioner is in the process of presenting to the Board of Regents a detailed plan for the development of possible revisions,” she said, which the Regents will then vote on.
Creating Self-Esteem
In discussing the proposed new curriculum, educators spoke about the failings of the current one.
“‘A Curriculum of Inclusion’ indicated clearly that African-Americans, Hispanics, native Americans, and Asians were not adequately included in the current curriculum,” said Sandford.
She said the current curriculum is damaging to all students, but particularly to children of African ancestry whose history has been distorted in textbook materials.
Another Regent, Mimi Lieber, agreed that the current curriculum “Is damaging to all students.”
One argument in favor of curriculum revision is that it will increase the self- esteem of “left out” minorities. But Ravitch said, “I don’t think schools should teach racial pride.”
On the other hand, Salow said that while there are no conclusive studies to support it, he believes that “students who feel better about their own culture do better in school.”
Kalibala added that second-generation Asians in the public school system aren’t doing as well as those born in Asia because they don’t see themselves reflected in the current curriculum.
The “Curriculum of Inclusion” is for all students in the state public school system, educators agree.
“Certain ethnic groups that are White are excluded, too, and should be included,” said Salow.
Some also argue that a well-rounded curriculum would reduce racial tension.
Nona Smith, director of Project Excellence at the Metropolitan Council of Branches, NAACP, said, “We need to know about one another…this kind of recognition of the contributions of all ethnic groups would create better human relations and therefore better race relations.”
Need For Independent Study
One might wonder just how much you can put into a history textbook. Not every cultural group can be included, and it would be almost impossible to give everybody an equal amount of time.
To address this problem, most educators interviewed said they believed that students should try to get away from textbooks and do their own research.
“If you really want to know more about history, you’ll have to dig much deeper than textbooks,” said Ravitch.
Salow agreed: “I’m suggesting to get away from textbooks, to get a variety of perspectives about the things we study.” Salow said that students should read books which are actually written by members of the ethnic group they are studying so that the “voice” is authentic.
Sanford said students who read on their own about other cultures will be “energized and motivated by the experience.”
We have to admit that the proposed “Curriculum of Inclusion” can’t change history, but by acknowledging non-White contributions to American society many omissions will be corrected. As Ravitch explained: “You have to have an honest approach to history.”
Salow issued a warning note: history, he said, is never going to be completely balanced because it “Is not a pie to be sliced equally between each ethnic group.” Most often, he said, it’s the story of the victor.
The United States is unique because of the diversity of its population, drawn from countries and cultures throughout the world. This diversity is part of our nation’s strength. Or, as the revised California curriculum states: “In a world torn by ethnic, racial, and religious hatred, the U.S has demonstrated the strength and the dynamism of a racially, religiously, and culturally diverse people, united under a democratic political system.”
“All of us have to broaden our viewpoints,” Salow concluded. “We do have to include more cultural and ethnic groups…The problem is, where do you end?”

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.