I hate school clubs based on race and ethnicity because they don’t accomplish what they were established to do. They draw the students away from society and create a sense of pride solely for their club, solely for their race, when pride should be directed toward something more specific than creed, color, or national origin. And, more importantly, they limit the students to a small circle of friends during high school.
The supposed objective of clubs such as the Asian Student Organization, the Greek Club, and the Black Awareness Club is to teach the members about their ethnic backgrounds.
But in my school, parties seemed to be their main function: parties that I couldn’t attend because I wasn’t a member of their racial or ethnic group. I wasn’t able to experience their presence and they didn’t get the opportunity to experience mine.
The clubs, from what I saw, didn’t mingle with other people from outside the group. They hung out with members, dated members, and only talked with other members. Their only friends were the people of the club.
A Beautiful Mosaic
The variety of students they could have met in my school was astounding. My school didn’t have to teach culture because culture was there, surrounding us on all sides. Mayor David Dinkins has said New York City isn’t a melting pot, but a beautiful mosaic. Being with people of different backgrounds will provide knowledge that a book can’t offer. I can’t begin to tell you what these club members missed out on.
If a student wants to study a subject that is not offered in the school program, then she should start a club that deals with the history of humanity, that admits members from many backgrounds. These clubs should allow their members to pursue independent studies and present their projects to the club.
Knowledge of other cultures as well as their own would be accomplished. To turn this group of people into a beautiful mosaic would be the objective of my idealistic club, a club I would have pride in.
To be able to conquer racism, we must teach the children of our society to accept everyone. My idealistic club would teach students to know more about humanity, their world, and the diverse people they live with on this earth.
Some students criticize those who haven’t learned other languages, or studied African or Asian History. But how can they say this and still approve of racial and ethnic school clubs?
The world is more than one section of society, one group of people. The world is a beautiful and enormous place. There are many different forms of literature, art, architecture, science, and history.
I won’t say that learning about only your own culture is wrong, but I will never say that it is right. Only horses wear blinders, and people shouldn’t be afraid to look in all directions.
Ethnic School Clubs Are Wrong
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.