Many times in my short high school career, I have had teachers in my program whom I simply hated. It was much more than a personality clash. I am certain many other students have had this experience as well. A lot of teenagers dislike school not because they despise their courses, but, more importantly, because they reject teachers they do not like.
Teachers are very important to an adolescent in high school because, in many cases, they represent an authority figure, a mentor, a confidant. But what happens when the teacher fills none of these roles?
What makes a good teacher? What makes a bad teacher?
Sheelagh, a junior at Stuyvesant HS, said, “A good teacher is made by other factors [in addition to] teaching ability: personality, care for students, and a positive attitude towards teaching. Occasionally, a teacher who doesn’t have these factors is good, but students usually don’t like them at the end.”
Patience and a Sense of Humor
Many students feel the same way. They maintain that a good teacher must follow stringent guidelines.
Sheelagh said the best teachers “drill you and test you to make sure you know the subject. If you don’t understand that subject, they will get help for you. If most of the class doesn’t understand, that teacher will teach it over.”
Heather, a high school junior, stated that a good teacher must have “ability, patience and creativity.”
Julia, a sophomore, explained that a good teacher “Is patient, never loses his temper, and has good knowledge of the material.”
A high school teacher interviewed said that a good teacher must have a “sense of humor, [be a] good actor, [and have the] ability to entertain as well as educate the kids. If you keep them entertained, you keep their attention.”
Many students feel that there are a lot of bad teachers throughout the New York City public school system, characterized by such adverse traits as clock watching, egotism, and incompetence.
These bad teachers often dislike the kids and try to make them suffer by assigning loads of homework and by conducting extremely boring classes.
The students interviewed described these bad teachers with such sinister terms as exploitative, perverted, and maniacal; and with lesser words such as boring, lazy, stingy, and vulgar.
Doing the Job For the Money
Heather said a bad teacher is just “doing the job for the money, not to educate.” Julia said that these teachers are too rigid and have “no plan for teaching the class.”
Many students who end up with bad teachers are not able to do anything to change their situation. Switching out of a class sometimes proves to be trickier than just bearing with the teacher for a semester.
A lot of students emphasized the necessity of a good teacher for a “quality” education. If a teacher shows that she is just doing the job for the money, or is too strict or conservative or dislikes kids, students will sense this, and class performance will most definitely drop.
A good teacher will put the student at ease, present the material in an understandable way, and show down-to-earth concern for her pupils.
Sheelagh said, “A good teacher knows her students and makes herself available to her students when they need help.”
She continued, describing one of her good teachers: “He makes sure we know the work without having us fall behind. He gives tests at fairly regular intervals, so we won’t forget what we have learned two weeks ago.”
Dave characterized a good teacher as one who is “loose and a good grader.” On the other hand, Reshmi, a classmate of Dave’s, believes that “some of the most difficult teachers are sometimes the best teachers.”
Importance of Respect
A high school dean agreed, saying that well-liked teachers “may be buying popularity with good grades.”
Although a number of students interviewed believed that “difficult teachers are sometimes the best teachers,” the general consensus fit Dave’s definition: “loose and a good grader.”
When a teacher is “loose” and grades easily, she is almost always the favorite when it comes to student programs. Most students prefer a teacher who grades easily and teaches well. This particular combination generally results in a high grade on one’s report card and passing the Regent Examinations with “flying colors.”
Some teachers feel that flexibility is a very important factor in determining a student’s success with a particular teacher. They feel that when a teacher teaches in a set way, it is up to the student to change and adapt to this way. There are always several students per class who like this method, or adjust to it to make the best of their class time.
Respect is also a very important factor. When a student does not have respect for a teacher, she will not pay attention to what her teacher has to say; if she does not pay attention, she will not learn.
Respect works the other way, too. If a teacher does not respect her students, she will not teach with the proper attitude necessary for her students to assimilate the information.
A student said: “A bad teacher scares the kids into learning. A bad teacher doesn’t take the time to make sure students understand the work completely; the syllabus [is] more important to them.”
So, if you are ever programmed to a class with a teacher who steers off the subject or who, as one student told me, drones on about his dead wife, a high school dean offers this advice: “Request a transfer to another class, or do the best with it and tolerate it for a term.”
What Makes a Good Teacher?
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.