Native Americans Face Many Stereotypes

There are many Native American nations in New York State. Among them are the Six Nations of the Iroquois Confederacy, which includes the Mohawk, Oneida, Onondaga, Cayuga, Seneca, and Tuscarora nations. Two nations on Long Island are the Poosepatuck and the Shinnecock. There are many others.
Unfortunately, there are almost as many stereotypes of Native Americans as there are nations.
Alyssia Teamer, 17, a senior at Fashion Industries HS who is a Native American descended from the Blackfoot and Cherokee tribes, said, “One [stereotype] is that we all look alike. We all have red skin and long black hair, and that’s not true, because Indians look different according to their nation.”
‘Do You Still Live in Tepees?’
Margo Thunderbird, co-director of the American Indian Community House (AICH), which provides job training and counseling for Native Americansin New York City, said, “Peopleask stupid questions, like, `Do you still live in tepees?'”
Sequoyah Oxendine, 17, a Cherokee/Lumbee Native American and a senior at Humanities HS, said, “You see cartoons, and every single Native American goes around in a deerskin with a feather in their head, and it’s just not true.”
When asked about the types of discrimination he has faced, Paul Betancourt, 13, of the Academy of Environmental Science JHS, said, “Kids would come up to me and say, `Have you scalped anyone yet?’ They picture us with long hair [and] with a headdress. I give them the real facts. I don’t walk away, I just tell them what Indians are all about.”
In addition to negative stereotypes, Native Americans are confronted with many social problems: unemployment, poor health services, discrimination, and alcohol and substance abuse.
Two organizations working to improve the quality of life for some of the 14,000 Native Americans who live in New York City are the Native American Education Program and the American Indian Community House (AICH).
Variety of Services Provided
In addition to job training, AICH, located at 404 Lafayette St. in Manhattan, offers alcoholism counseling, substance abuse referrals, and has a pre-school, an art gallery/museum, and a theater.
The Native American Education Program, at 234 W. 109th St. in Manhattan, is a special project in the Board of Education’s Division of Multilingual and Multicultural Education. It offers classes that teach history and culture from a Native American perspective. A resource center contains films, slides, periodicals, books, and other educational materials, and field trips are organized by the program.
In addition, the program offers a visitation service. Staff members visit Native American parents and students at home or in school to solve any academic, attendance, or social problems the students may have.
Stephanie Betancourt, the program’s home/school coordinator and a Seneca Native American, said, “Native Americans have special cultural, educational, historical, [and] social needs. This program meets those needs.”
She added: “Racism comes out of ignorance and we try to turn it around by teaching.”
Annie Teamer, a home/school coordinator who is descended from the Blackfoot and Cherokee tribes, said that Native American self-esteem is raised through knowledge of history and culture.
When asked why he was proud of his culture, Paul Bentancourt said, “I’m very proud because [Native Americans] tried to do all these great things. They tried to save the earth as much as they could and they are still doing it today.”
Undisturbed for Centuries
Native Americans were the first people to live in North America. Archaeologists believe that they originated in Siberia and migrated to North and South America in search of game. Over the centuries they learned to farm and hunt. Their civilization prospered and remained undisturbed. Until 1492, that is, when Columbus arrived.
When the European settlers came to the new world it would have been very easy for the Native Americans to wipe them out, because in many cases they didn’t have any food and few weapons to defend themselves. Instead, the Native Americans offered friendship and help.
It took very little time for the Whites to increase in great numbers. Besides giving Native Americans diseases, the Europeans also destroyed their most sacred values. The land was very important to the Indians, because they believed that everything-including the land-had a spirit or supernatural force. They felt that people, animals, and the land were united as one.
This is why they believed that humans could not own the land. But they soon found that the European settlers were setting up fences and killing Indians who trespassed.
When the settlers didn’t depend on the Indians for survival anymore, they tried to force them to adopt English customs, laws, and religion. At Plymouth, Massachusetts, for example, Indians were forbidden to hunt and fish on the Sabbath.
Movie Stereotypes
It didn’t take long for the Europeans to stereotype Indians. Some of the settlers idealized them as “noble children of nature” while others called them “savage devils.”
Hollywood movies played a great part in the way Indians were viewed. They always showed the Indians attacking and scalping White settlers.
Alyssia Teamer, the Fashion Industries senior, said it bothers her to see Native Americans shown in a bad way “because they portray us as savages when it’s not true.” She continued: “Native Americans are upstanding people like everyone else.”
In reality, treaty after treaty was broken by the Whites. The Indians were given land to live on, but when the U.S. government wanted that land, they drove the Indians away.
In 1675 the New England tribes went to war with the Whites. King Phillip, the Wampanoag leader, was caught and the “religious” White people of Plymouth cut off his head and mounted it on a pole. It was displayed on that pole for the next 25 years.
Another example of White oppression was the famous “Trail of Tears” in which the Cherokees, under the Indian Removal Act of 1830, were forced to sell most of their land and move to a reservation. Thousands of sick and old people fell dead by the roadside and were not allowed to be buried by their relatives.
Indians leaders like Sitting Bull and Crazy Horse, who led the Cheyenne and the Sioux to victory over Custer at the Little Big Horn in 1876, were portrayed as cutthroats who killed the White soldiers mercilessly.
What is often ignored is that they were fighting for their land which was promised to them by the U.S. government. Custer’s exaggerated reports of gold in the Black Hills of South Dakota, an area sacred to Native Americans, caused flocks of Whites to trespass that region in their search for wealth. The Indians tried to resist the army, but in the end were pushed out of the hills.
‘Find Out the Truth’
The majority of Indians today do not live on reservations or in tepees. They live like everyone else.
Stephanie Betancourt said, “We’ll always be part of [this] society, but we will keep ours.”
Sequoyah Oxendine said, “I feel my people were very brave. You know, going into battle and knowing they will die. Even now they haven’t submitted and my people didn’t sell each other out. I want to be proud of my people and do something for them.”
Stephanie Betancourt added: “don’t sit back and take Native Americans for granted. Try to find out [about them]. Go to people who are reliable sources. don’t be embarrassed to ask. You have to find out the truth. What you read and see is not always the truth.”
Contact: American Indian Community House, 404 Lafayette St., N.Y., N.Y., 10003, 212-598-0100; Native American Education Program, 234 W. 109th St., Rm. 507, N.Y., N.Y., 10025, 212-663-4040.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.