New Mayor, Old Problems: What Dinkins Faces as He Takes Office

On November 7th, New Yorkers elected David Dinkins to the second toughest office in the U.S.-the Mayor of the City of New York. As the city’s chief executive, he will face problems that have haunted past mayors for years, as well as new problems that will arise as New York enters the next decade under new and diverse leadership.
After a gruesome campaign, during which the candidates’ backgrounds instead of city problems were debated, experts are worried about what lies ahead.
“We will not only have a new mayor, but a new charter, city council, and [schools] chancellor,” said Esmeralda Simmons, director of the Center for Law and Social Justice at Medgar Evers College in Brooklyn. “Yet, we have the same problems. These problems can only be addressed by a comprehensive agenda. We have to stop thinking about the personalities and begin concentrating on the issues.”
Mixed Priorities
At such a crucial time in the city’s history, it is difficult to single out the greatest problem facing Dinkins. This sentiment was echoed by experts within and outside city government.
“Drugs and crime are problems which must be addressed immediately by the new mayor because they’re on the minds of most New Yorkers. People don’t feel safe at night [because of] the drug rampage in the city,” said Herbert Block, former special assistant to Dinkins when he was Manhattan Borough President, and a member of the new mayor’s transition staff.
Citing several inter-related issues, Dr. Donald Smith, chairman of the dept. of education at Bernard Baruch College, stated: “Poverty among large segments of the city’s population, racism sparked by job discrimination and racial murders, and the complete destruction of the New York City educational system are all crucial problems which Dinkins will face.”
‘The real challenge is to get people to believe in the city again,” declared Dr. Roscoe Brown, president of Bronx Community College and a member of the Dinkins’ transition team “The people of this city must realize that New York can work for them.”
Education-A Top Issue
Our public school system is also undergoing many changes, with a new chancellor and other top officials taking control.
“It’s a great opportunity to deal with the high dropout rate, old school buildings, violence, crime, overcrowded classes, and the other problems that plague the school system,” said Block.
“We must have ‘schools of empowerment,’ ” urged Dr. Smith. “These facilities should provide young people with greater self-esteem. We have already lost many youngsters-some still in school-because we failed to meet their needs.”
Dinkins has proposed a ‘bottom up’ approach to improving our system through school-based management.
“The people who are affected most in city schools are the students, parents, teachers, and administrators. That’s why Dinkins believes that decision-making on the school level will work,” explained Block. “These reforms are not just campaign rhetoric. They will be implemented. Ultimately, things will change and people will see changes.”
Dr. Smith, however, criticized Dinkins’ plans: “What happens in our schools is more destructive than the crack that’s being sold to our children. I don’t think that the new mayor has a perspective which will help our youth.”
Healing Racial Tension
Dinkins has portrayed himself as a healer of the city’s racial problems, which flared again this past summer after the slaying of Yusuf Hawkins.
“The chief executive of the city sets a tone which the entire city follows,” remarked Block.
“The majority of the city wants to have racial harmony,” observed Jack Kelaher, a Dinkins transition staff member. “His success depends greatly on the media,” he continued, stressing media coverage of racially motivated attacks as a key to racial tolerance in the city.
“[The media] can be very supportive or destructive,” explained Kelaher, citing negative stereotypes of Blacks and Hispanics. He believes that racial tensions could be calmed if the media takes a more moderate and less sensational approach during Dinkins’ leadership.
Roger Wareham, project associate at the Center for Law and Social Justice, described some of the racial barriers facing Dinkins: “A historical problem in the city is that Latino and Black perpetrators are treated differently. The DA’s find it difficult to prosecute White perpetrators unless they are pressured by the community.”
Wareham also pointed out that the same holds true in incidents involving police harassment.
“Most people are turned off by the ineffective Civilian Complaint Review Board [that handles complaints against police], because it’s not worth the trouble to file a complaint with them and the DA’s are reluctant to prosecute police anyhow,” said Wareham.
Drugs and Aids Surge
New York City teens are also faced with many other problems. Drug abuse and the AIDS epidemic are surging among the city’s youth. The new mayor has to deal with these issues, which threaten the survival of the world’s greatest city. Dinkins will inherit an office that has suffered numerous defeats during the war on drugs and whose efforts to combat the AIDS virus have largely proved fruitless.
“We have to face the fact that teenagers are sexually active and that they are vulnerable to sexually transmitted diseases. That’s why we must teach them how to protect themselves,” urged Dr. Smith, stressing that good sex education is the key to dealing with the AIDS epidemic.
Block agreed, adding that anyone who deals with young people should have a commitment to teach them about AIDS and its prevention.
In the area of drug abuse among teens, Dinkins’ main proposal is to, establish drug free zones around all city public schools. These areas will be closely patrolled and monitored by local police, and drug dealers caught within the zones will face stiffer penalties. Dinkins also hopes to enhance existing drug education programs as well as encourage the development of new ones.
A Youth Advocate
Dinkins has been a youth advocate throughout his career as a public official. As Manhattan Borough President, he supported numerous programs and activities for city teens. His belief in youth empowerment led him to form a Youth Advisory Committee, composed of teenagers from throughout the city who advised him on issues concerning youth.
“We are committed to having a Youth Advisory Committee for the mayor,” Block said, explaining that the actual structure of the group is being developed at this time.
The election of the first Black mayor in the city’s history has affected New York in many ways. One of the most significant results cited by experts could be more opportunities for minorities, which could in turn lead to improved race relations. The entire city would profit from this.
“The Afro-American and Latino communities have better hopes in the city, as well as [for] better programs [in, the future],” observed Dr. Smith
“His election will spark optimism among minorities, challenge the business and private sector communities, and calm the friction between various groups of people,” said Dr. Brown of Bronx Community College.
Block echoed these sentiments, saying that Dinkins’ election would lead to a “kinder and gentler city.”
“In many communities-not just among minorities-there was a sense of pride because so many people were glad to see that anyone could win that top office,” said Kelaher.
Dinkins’ Qualities-Key to Success?
David Dinkins possesses many qualities and personal traits which have helped elect him mayor-and that will hopefully make him a good one. His ability to attract good people to city government is one quality which has often been noted.
“He will bring the best. He wants to get a representation of the entire city and he will make sure that there’s a balance,” promised Dr. Brown, who played a role on the transition team in selecting some of the new administration’s top officials.
Showing dissatisfaction with Dinkins’ major appointments, Dr. Smith said that he has the potential to bring in good people, but hasn’t yet put his talents to use.
“[Dinkins is] willing to focus on long-range issues and problems which aren’t always related to politics,” observed Kelaher, citing another quality which could be useful solving our city’s numerous problems.
In addition to the problems mentioned, Dinkins will be faced with many others, ranging from homelessness to health care. He will have to deal with these issues as soon as he takes office.
Block cited the crisis in housing, which has to be addressed by Dinkins’ agenda. “[There isn’t] enough housing for low and middle income families,” he explained. Block also mentioned crumbling bridges and roads, health care, and services for children.
“He only won by a small percentage and there are a number of people who want to undermine him,” said Dr. Smith, noting that Dinkins’ ability to govern would be an issue. “He should focus on getting all of the commissions and agencies to work together.”
The quality of life in the city was on Kelaher’s mind as he observed that drugs, crime, and other problems often result from poor living conditions. “If the millions of dollars used each year to fight drugs were used to improve people’s lives, then we would begin to solve some of our major problems,” he suggested.
There are many problems facing New York City and Mayor Dinkins will have to address them. Hopefully, he will more be more successful than past leaders, or the world’s greatest city may fall apart as it enters a decade vital to its survival. The time to begin working for change is now.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.