If You’re Not Careful: Trade Schools Can Rob You Blind

“They guaranteed that I’d get a job after graduation. They made it sound so good…a high paying job. I needed one. I just came out of high school and didn’t know what to do. I didn’t want to go to college yet. I was really scared,” said Nadine Lynch, describing how, at age 17, she fell victim to the trade school trap.
Fresh out of high school and confused about her future, she began searching for work.
A newspaper ad for a job in telemarketing caught her eye and, after an interview, she was given the position.
However, she was told she needed additional training in general business to keep the job. She was sent to American Hi-Tech Business School in Manhattan to attend classes during the day and to work after school.
After taking an exam which she found very easy, she was told that she was eligible to enroll in the school. Nadine was directed to a financial aid office where she was asked for a copy of her parents’ income tax return.
The tax return was reviewed and she was told that she was unqualified for a grant and was in need of a loan.
The school’s financial aid officer took out a loan of more than $8,000 for her from Citibank and Chemical Bank. Nadine never went to the banks herself.
Ivy League Tuition for Worthless Classes
Meanwhile, her parents weren’t aware of Nadine’s situation. They thought her classes were free.
Nadine attended the classes at American Hi-Tech but never did go back to work. They told her she needed a license in order to work and that she would be notified when it arrived.
She was never notified. For a month she called back, but was informed that her license still hadn’t arrived.
Nadine stopped calling. “I gave up,” she said.
Meanwhile, Nadine’s classes at American Hi-Tech-for which she was paying the equivalent of an Ivy League tuition-weren’t satisfactory. Some of the teachers didn’t speak English very well and some of the typewriters in her typing class didn’t work.
In fact, she didn’t do any work in her typing class. She said her teacher would spend the class time talking. Nadine remembers some of the students in her class asking the teacher why the class was so expensive.
“He wouldn’t directly answer the question. Some of the students dropped out,” Nadine said.
Luckily, Nadine informed a former teacher of her circumstances and she was able to obtain a refund because her financial aid officer wasn’t licensed. If the officer had been licensed, Nadine would not have received a refund and would have had to repay the $8,000 loan.
Nadine was lucky. Now, she works at a real estate company as a part-time worker. She plans to attend New York Institute of Technology this fall.
Phony Recruitment Tactics
But there are many thousands of students throughout the city who aren’t as lucky as Nadine. These students, also eager for a bright future but taken advantage of by trade schools, fall into deep debt for courses that are virtually worthless.
The manipulation of students starts with how they are recruited. Many trade and business schools use false advertising and bait and switch advertising (the tactic used on Nadine-luring students with the phony promise of a job).
Some trade schools hire students to go to their high schools and give out surveys; in this way, addresses and phone numbers are obtained. Calls are made to homes to recruit students. Potential high school dropouts are then lured into these schools.
Recent Federal legislation requires people on welfare to get job training in order to receive aid payments. This requirement could cause the recruitment rates of trade and business schools to increase drastically as they prey on the poor and vulnerable.
“Trade schools have been standing outside welfare offices trying to recruit people. They’re licking their chops,” said Martha Bright, community relations assistant at the Center for Law and Social Justice at Medgar Evers College (CUNY).
The tuition costs for these trade schools are exorbitantly high.
Betsy Imholz, an attorney who monitors trade schools at South Brooklyn Legal Services, said, “It runs from $3,000 to $14,000 for a six month to 15 month course. Schools figure out the cost. They take the poorest student, take the maximum money they can get from grants and government loans the student is qualified for, and that’s the tuition cost.”
Imholz also said many schools tell their students that they’re “government covered,” but they don’t tell the students that this package includes loans that they must pay back. Some only realize it when they graduate-the bills come in and they’re obligated to pay.
42% Dropout Rates
According to Interface, a public policy research organization, trade schools have an annual dropout rate of 42%. This is no surprise considering the conditions in these schools.
Imholz said the schools may not have enough equipment or obsolete equipment. The teachers may not be qualified and classes may be overcrowded because the trade school had recruited so many people. When students drop out, classes are pushed together.
Refund policies are unfavorable to students. When a student drops out after attending classes for only a short time, she might be entitled to some money, but the school usually gives the student the run around. The student is left responsible for paying back the whole loan.
If the student doesn’t repay it and defaults, her credit is damaged: she can’t get future grants or loans.
But don’t banks care that they aren’t repaid?
“Banks are in the business of making money, the government has built in protections for them,” said Bright.
Aren’t there any laws to protect the students?
Lack of Enforcement and Loopholes
Imholz explained: “There are extensive laws, the problem is there can be more, they can be better. There are two problems. One, the government is not enforcing the ones now. Two, there are some gaps in the law that can be filled in.”
Bright said the major problems were inadequate personnel and lack of law enforcement by the State Education Department.
In 1986, for instance, the State Education Department issued a pamphlet on how to make a complaint about a trade or business school. Instead of putting it in areas available to students, they gave it to trade schools. The trade schools were told to make copies of it and distribute it to students.
“Is that a serious effort to protect students?” asked Bright.
Because so many trade schools exploit their students, you must be very careful if you’re considering one. First, find out about and take advantage of free or low cost, high-quality government programs. Visit high schools which have adult education courses.
A Student is a Consumer
Take Imholz’s advice: “Being a student is being a consumer. Shop for the best service…Take your time…Think carefully. It’s going to affect you for the rest of your life if you make a mistake.”
If you are already in a trade school and you want to drop out, go to the school office and formally submit your withdrawal. Notify the bank and keep a copy of all withdrawal forms and all records and documents.
To make a complaint, call the State Education Dept. and ask for a complaint form. When you receive it, fill it out, and attach any documents about loans and explain what your complaint is. According to the law, the department is supposed to notify you within 60 days. However, due to inadequate personnel, you may be notified a little later.
Make copies of your own form and also send it to other agencies, such as the U.S. Department of Education and the New York State Higher Education Services Corporation.
Recently, there was a State bill that tried to reform the trade school industry, the Proprietary Schools Reform Act of 1989. It did not pass in the current legislative session.
Bright said that there are powerful, well-connected lobbyists who are advocating for their schools. Even if you don’t plan on attending a trade school, it’s important to care about where your tax dollars are spent and to support a strong reform act.
Bright suggests that concerned individuals “should write to their assemblymen about support of that bill. It’s the Republicans that are not supportive of these changes. They need to hear from their constituencies. They need to hear from people who have their votes.”

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.