What Teens Learn by Working with the Elderly

“All my impressions of the elderly were wrong, because I felt they would be cranky and old fashioned, but they weren’t, and I wanted to help them.”
This was what Paullete Ha, 15, Brooklyn Technical HS, learned by working in the Cypress Hills Local Development Corporation, an intergenerational program in which young people do light housekeeping for the elderly, shopping, gardening, and escort them outside the home.
Intergenerational Programs
Intergenerational programs like the one Paullete participates in brings young people and the elderly together in common projects. These programs are geared toward closing the gaps caused by the misconceptions the elderly and young people have about one another.
Teenagers involved in these programs agreed that their impressions of elderly people have changed. Most of the negative impressions young people have about elderly people are due to the fact that they haven’t had much contact with of elderly people.
City Volunteer Corps (CVC) is a voluntary national youth service which recently implemented an intergenerational program. Young people from ages 17-21 help the elderly with shopping, errands, and light housekeeping. They escort them on visits to friends and trips around the neighborhood, providing the elderly with much-needed company.
A few young people from CVC were asked if they had gotten a better understanding of elderly people by being in the program.
Anthony Marks, 20, said, “Yes, because I’ve never dealt with them before, but now that I’ve dealt with them I have some understanding…I was in a way scared to touch them, but you learn from them. Now I feel more comfortable.”
Junior Roberts, 18: “I viewed them as old and grumpy. But I found that they are everyday people. Just as you meet elderly that are nice, and others that are grumpy, you meet young people that are nice, and others that are grumpy.”
Less Respect for the Elderly
One reason elderly people today are stereotyped by most young people is that there is less respect for elderly people today than in the past.
For example, years ago a young person would give up her seat on the bus for an elderly person. Today you rarely see that happening.
Ron Carlos, student coordinator for the Intergenerational Work Study Program funded by New York City’s Department for the Aging, said, “Society has become unbalanced. Adults spend so much time doing their own thing,’till they don’t pass down to the young people the things that have been handed down.
“You can’t keep knowledge unless you give it away.”
Mr. Carlos stressed the fact that young people today are more disrespectful than youth of past generations.
He continued, “Compassion shown by youth has changed. A large number of young people lack self-esteem. And since they lack self-esteem, they don’t like themselves, so they don’t like others. It’s hard to like others who are different if you don’t like yourself, and elderly people are from a different spectrum.”
The experience of working with the elderly seems to help young people know how it feels to be old, and how they would like to be treated when they become old.
Kayla Laserson, a field supervisor at CVC, speaking about the city volunteers, said, “I think it gives them a chance to see people who are lonely . . . It also gives them a chance to see what growing old is all about.”
Young people realize that the elderly are not really valued or respected in our culture.
Junior, 18, CVC member, said, “People treat them as though they don’t exist.”
Saran Mcwhoreter, 15, Laguardia HS, agreed that elderly people are ignored. “After a certain age you’re treated like no one.”
Saran participates in an intergenerational program called Mindbuilders Creative Arts. In this program the elderly teach young people folk art and folklore. This traditional knowledge of people and cultures is sometimes told in songs or stories.
Understanding the Elderly
Understanding the elderly has been difficult for young people, but the elderly also have difficulty understanding young people. Intergenerational programs have helped older people change their attitudes.
John Fox, an elderly member of the Intergenerational Work Study Program, said, “I learned quite a bit. I learned that some of them [young people] have positive attitudes. It puts them above the run-of-the-mill type of teenagers.”
Marie Pavloni, also an elderly participant in the Intergenerational Work Study Program, said, “I have learned that they’re ambitious, and polite in the way they help the elderly.”
One of the main difficulties is that both young people and the elderly assume from the misconceptions that they have about one another that communication is impossible.
But those involved in intergenerational programs lay these fears to rest.
Brian Young, 18, a CVC member, said, “I figured they would be scared because of the way the media shows us, only robbing, raping, and stealing, but their moods changed like everybody else’s.”
Paullette Ha, said, “I thought that the elderly would see me as a stranger in their home, but they accepted me, and that was surprising.”
A Better Outlook on Young People
The elderly I spoke with said they received a better outlook on young people from the experience of dealing with them.
Ida Goodisman, Ida Zimmerman, and Molly Marks are elderly members of a nutrition program which is part of the Canarsie Neighborhood Development Program. They all agreed that they learned a lot from working with young people.
Ida Goodisman said, “We learned that we have to have a little patience. Just as you treat little children with patience, you have to treat older children with patience as well.”
Kenya, 16, is one of the bright young teenagers who works with elderly people at the Canarsie Neighborhood Development Program. She is enrolled in Canarsie A.W.A.R.E., which is a drug treatment facility. This program specializes in treating teenagers and families who are experiencing difficulties, specifically with substance abuse.
When asked what was most important about the program, Kenya said, “The help-because a lot of people don’t help you-they just tell you. They had a lot of patience and caring, and you don’t find that everywhere.”
Rolinda Santana, 17, University Heights HS, said, “I have developed a bond that isn’t like a grandparent to grandchild, but more of a mother or father to daughter.” Santana participates in the Intergenerational Work Study Program.
Need For More Programs
Is there a need for more intergenerational programs like these? All of those interviewed felt there was a definite need.
Saran Mcwhoreter, 15: “Definitely! To get rid of the ignorance about our elders.”
Junior Roberts, 18, “I feel that if the young people had a shot at this, their point of view of old people would change. It would make everyone feel wanted and needed.”
Young people can learn from elderly people. At the same time, I feel that young people can, by sharing their knowledge, help elderly adults to better understand and communicate with young people. Keep in mind that where there’s unity, there is strength.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.