One of the most controversial issues of our time is the debate over a woman’s legal right to an abortion, the result of the Supreme Court decision in the Roe vs. Wade case in 1973. The court is soon to rule on a Missouri case which could curtail or reverse the legality of abortion.
But abortion is more than a legal issue. It is about people and feelings and lives.
In this struggle there are two clear opposing views, commonly called “right to life” and “pro-choice.” Both sides have convincing arguments.
The following article lays out the arguments for and against a woman’s legal right to an abortion.
‘Not Good For Society’
What is the “right to life” movement about? Jeanne Head, president of the New York Right To Life Coalition, which was founded in 1967, explained that her organization is “fighting for the protection of all human beings at every stage of development from conception to natural death-[while] focusing [particularly] on the unborn.”
Head got involved in the movement in the early 70’s. As a registered nurse, she saw abortions and is convinced that abortion is murder.
According to Head, who says she was a feminist before feminism was popular, abortion is “unbelievably wrong, not good for women, not good for babies, and not good for society.” Head feels one abortion every 20 seconds in the U.S. shows a lack of regard for human life.
Head claims RTL members would like to see Roe vs. Wade overturned because “we would want to see the protection of the most innocent and helpless of our citizens restored.”
The “pro-choice” movement should be more accurately called “pro-abortion,” according to Head, because she believes they want abortion legalized not only for cases of rape, incest, and danger to the life of the mother, but also for any reason, including inconvenience.
Head puts the fetus’ right to life before the mother’s right to privacy. “Your rights stop when they infringe on my rights. And the mother’s right to privacy stops when her privacy involves taking the life of another human being, and particularly another human being who has been put under her protection.”
A Live Human Being?
Right to Lifers believe the fetus is a live human being. They claim a woman has no more right to kill this child in her womb than she has to kill an infant outside the womb.
“Although abortions are usually done in or before the sixth month, it is legal to perform them up to’the moment of birth’ if you can find a doctor who is willing to do it. Most doctors are not willing because of the increased possibility of the abortion resulting in a live birth,” said Head.
According to Head, prior to legalization the only legal abortions were done to protect the life of the mother.
Head would like to see this guideline restored to stop the “convenience killings of many babies.”
“Now they apply abortion to the killing of babies after viability… technically, after the fifth month it is no longer an abortion from a medical point of view,” Head added.
She claimed the term “termination of pregnancy” is now used to describe most abortions because it is not technically an abortion. It is “the premature induction of labor after viability or the killing of a baby in the womb.”
Head also feels it is ironic that the more medical science advances (i.e. we can see babies moving with the aid of sonograms as early as 12 weeks), the less regard we seem to have for what we now know.
‘A Method of Birth Control’
According to Right to Life information, “10% [of abortions are] done after 21 weeks when babies are possibly viable (capable of living). Most are done within the first three months. Each year 1.5 million are done. Every year 150-160,000 are done after possible viability and of those… about 15-16,000 are done in the last three months of pregnancy…
“Between 98 and 99% of abortions are done for social or economic reasons… Between 1 and 2% are done for the hard cases, which are the health of the mother, the life of the mother, rape and incest…”
Before abortions were legal, 100-200,000 abortions were performed in the U.S. each year.
Head explained that the number of abortions escalated after the 1973 decision from about 600,000 in 1972 to 1.2 million in 1977. Head asserts some women started using abortion as a method of birth control. Forty percent of all abortions are repeat abortions. She concludes that “If we make it not legal, there will be fewer women getting pregnant irresponsibly.”
She agrees that it is tragedy if even one woman dies from a back alley (illegal) abortion. But she does not see that as an excuse for abortion or the legalization of it.
Religion Coalition For Abortion Rights
Members of the Religious Coalition For Abortion Rights (RCAR) have a different perspective. This organization has representatives from almost all mainline religions who support a woman’s right to have an abortion.
RCAR was founded in 1974. Since the Roman Catholic church was so expressive in its stand against abortion, a group of religious people felt the necessity to present “the majority opinion on the other side.”
They are not “pro-abortion.” They believe abortion should be a choice between “a woman and her God.” They would like to see abortion remain legal.
One purpose of this organization is to counter the belief that all religious people are opposed to abortion because the Roman Catholic Church is.
Reverend Beatrice Blaire, chairperson for the policy council of RCAR, says that just the opposite is true: that religious people believe in the “freedom of a woman’s conscience.”
Another reason they are against making abortion illegal is that when abortion was illegal, rich women continued to have them. They flew to another country where it was legal and safer. Poor women, on the other hand, gave themselves their own abortions and died from them.
Reverend Blaire adds that most “people who want abortion to remain legal are also in favor of school based clinics and other programs to prevent unwanted pregnancy.”
A Constitutional Right to Privacy
The Coalition would like to see Roe vs. Wade remain unchanged because, Blaire believes, that is where the basic constitutional right to privacy is stated.
Reverend Blaire points out that certain religious Jewish groups put the welfare of the mother before that of her unborn child. Also, there are passages in the Bible supporting a woman’s choice to have a child or not.
For example, in Genesis 2, it states that God made man from the dust of the earth and blew life into man by blowing His own breath into him. This suggests that a creature does not have life until she breathes.
Blaire claims the Virgin Mary was given the choice not to have Jesus, and so should the women of today.
RCAR members reason that since the beginning of life has not been defined, everyone has the right to their own opinion about when life begins. One group does not have the right to impose their opinion of when life begins on anyone else, Blaire said.
She explains: “One of the strengths of this country is that people of all different religions and all different types can live together because we are tolerant of each other’s attitudes…”
A Woman’s Choice-Not the Government’s
Another organization which supports a woman’s legal right to an abortion is NARAL, which stands for the National Abortion Rights Action League.
According to Ellen Carton, executive director of the New York State affiliate of NARAL, it is “a single issue pro-choice organization. We believe that it’s up to a woman to decide whether or not to carry a pregnancy to term and that she and she alone has the right to make that choice without any interference from the government.
“And what we do is we educate and organize the pro-choice majority to advocate for themselves and get involved in the process,” she continues, “whether it’s to get involved in the community or writing letters or making phone calls or visiting their legislators and then finally working with a political action committee to elect pro-choice candidates to the state legislature.”
The group would like to see Roe vs. Wade upheld because they feel if it is upheld this year it will help them get back what they’velost.
“There’s been a restriction of access for abortion rights and it particularly affects poor women and young women, so we want that access restored,” said Carton. Also, the Roe vs. Wade ruling “prohibits states from voting to make abortion illegal.”
Carton feels that a woman’s right to privacy and to have an abortion is synonymous with her right to life. Carton places that right before a fetus’ right to life.
She is a part of NARAL because she feels that having a child affects all other aspects of a woman’s life and her place in society. She is afraid that right is being threatened. She is working to make sure that people understand that it is being threatened so that they’ll give their support to the pro-choice movement.
Can a Fetus Feel Pain?
When questioned about information from the RTL office which states that “a fetus has a developed nervous system and can feel pain at 13 1/2 weeks,” Carton commented, “That’s not true. The Association of Obstetricians and Gynecologists say that a fetus’ developmental capacity is such that, at such an early stage of its existence, it cannot feel pain.”
According to Carton, at three months the fetus “looks like it is formed, but in terms of its brain waves, its lung capacity, and a variety of other biological functions, it’s far from formed and, in fact, until some time after 24 weeks, the fetus couldn’t exist outside the woman’s body which is why we call it a non-viable fetus and which is why a woman has the right to abort it.”
She added, “Abortions are not done up to nine months. Abortions are done up to 24 weeks… Something like .0001% of abortions are done after 24 weeks so it virtually does not happen. The only time it does happen is if it’s the choice of does the woman die or does the fetus die? But basically, it’s not really an issue because it doesn’t really happen. And in fact, more than 90% of abortions are done in 12 weeks or less.”
Will They Be Safe and Legal?
Carton would like for people to remember this: “It’s a question of not whether women will have abortions, but will they be safe and legal? Or will we be returning to the back alleys where women’s health and lives were at stake? We don’t want to return to those days, and we hope that you won’t want us to and that you’ll join and help.”
Conflicting views? Sure. Confusing? You bet.
What is the truth? Does the fetus feel the pain of being aborted? Whose life is more important-the baby’s or the mother’s?
How can the average Jane become unconfused?
Well, obviously, there is a difference in opinion, and a disagreement about the facts. But to make your own decision about this issue requires research, determining which arguments you agree with, and struggling with your own values.
The Abortion Controversy: Which Side Is Right?
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.