Not All Asians Are Math and Science Geniuses

“No tickee-no washee…”
“With two, you get egg roll…”
Sound familiar? These are surprisingly common stereotypes about the Asian community. Many people see Asians solely as laundry and restaurant owners.
Just as common is the idea that all Asians excel in the areas of math and science. Mary Chan, a student at Townsend Harris HS in Queens, said, “If I get a low score on a test in science, they [the other students] say,’How did you do that?'”
While in some ways it might seem harmless for Asians to be viewed as math and science geniuses, it also has negative effects.
Ignoring Real Needs
“We are hurt by that `model minority’ concept,” said Amelia Chu, director of Asian Family Services. “A lot of us aren’t good at math or science. And, because of that stereotype, we tend not to have people pay attention to our needs and concerns when our community has a lot of problems. They may think we don’t have drug problems, but that’s not true in our community…teenage problems, pregnancy problems-yes, we do have teenage pregnancy problems. In that sense, it’s affecting our ability to get public money to finance some of those programs that may benefit our community.”
The stereotype has an affect on students as well. Grace Chan, another Asian student at Townsend Harris HS, said that being stereotyped irritates her and unconsciously makes her want to do poorly in science and math to spite everyone.
Lisa Chan, a student at Stuyvesant HS, added that “I have friends that are Asian that want to go into art or writing, and [the stereotype] is harmful for them, because they feel that they ought to be doing well in math and the sciences because it’s expected of them by society, as well as their parents…”
Roots of Stereotypes
Stereotypes, however, don’t just rise out of thin air. There are several places where they came from.
The history of Asian immigration to the United States played a big role in establishing the math and science stereotype.
In 1882 the Chinese Exclusion Act permitted only unskilled workers to enter into the U.S. This law was in effect for many years. Hence, the perception that all Asians are involved with restaurants and laundry, or are unskilled workers.
Thus, when the immigration laws were relaxed in 1965 and skilled Asians entered the country, they began competing academically on an equal basis for the first time.
In addition to immigration, the cultures and educational policies of Asian countries, (except China, whose system has suffered an educational crisis) are tough and rigid compared to those in the U.S.
Amelia Chu said that Asian schools are very structured and place a lot of emphasis on school work. Chu says that in Hong Kong kids are given compulsory examinations after the sixth and 12th grades to see if they can advance to the next level of schooling.
“I would say that we study math at a higher level in my country,” said Chu. “The entire system is different.”
“The nature of Asian education requires memorization of long lists,” added Charlie Chin of the Chinatown History Project.
Pressure From the Family
The family also plays a big role in the lives Asian students. Harry and Grace Chan, students at Townsend Harris, said that their parents exert a great deal of pressure on them to do well in school, especially in the areas of math and science.
Grace remarks that, “They feel it’s [math and science] their key to success in the world.”
Dr. Michael Anzel, a science teacher at Townsend Harris, said that he’s seen Asian kids at parent teacher meetings who were “almost reduced to crying because of the pressure to do well.”
Heather Golen, a student at Townsend Harris, said that she once saw an Asian father pressuring his child harshly. “Her father said [to the teacher] that his child should get 95 or 100 in math.”
Connie Wong [not her real name], a senior at Brooklyn Tech, recalled that “I’ve heard my friends say, `My parents are really down on me `cause I’m only getting a 95 and not a 99’…I personally don’t like that pressure and I don’t like my parents giving it to me. Other students, I’ve heard, actually kill themselves because there’s so much pressure for them to do well and they can’t deal with it, so they just fly off the handle.”
An International Language
According to Chu, Asian students are attracted to math and science because it is an international language-unlike English, it’s a language they can understand.
Chu added, “Even though they don’t communicate [through the language], they can still communicate through numbers-it’s just a way for survival… a way to move ahead.”
The Asian way of writing also requires an entirely different way of thinking.
Chinese writing, which is borrowed by all other Asian cultures, is picto-phonetic. Each symbol can be visually recognized as a word. The closest things to picto-phonetic symbols in our country are numbers.
The Chinese system, for example, has 214 basic characters (a bit more than our 26 letters).
According to Charlie Chin, conceptualization is different in a picto-phonetic system from that of a phonetic alphabet. “It leads to a very different way of thinking,” said Chin.
Community Responsibility
The stereotype has been reinforced over the years by students, teachers, and by the Asian community itself.
Chu remarked that, “…maybe the parents think that the kids should go for science in order for them to secure a better job. We have to tell the parents to let our children grow as we are, instead of forcing us to pick a particular profession.”
Chu continued on to say that false ideas about the Asian community might be corrected “through community education… If we have somebody [to represent us] who is a leader in the areas of music, art, literature…[it would let] people know we’re good at this stuff too!”
Valentine Kang, a student at Brooklyn Tech, had this to say: “Asian students shouldn’t be so afraid of getting involved in drama clubs, speech classes or whatever…[If you don’t] you’re limiting yourself, and eventually, when you work in the real world, even if you go into the math and science fields you’ll find that it’s very important to have verbal skills… if you don’t have these verbal skills, you’ll face many difficulties in the future.”

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.