Interview With Chancellor Richard Green

NYC interviewed Chancellor Richard Green in his office on April 11. The following is a partial transcript of that interview.
Joi: How will students who are entering under your leadership benefit in future years?
Green: I would like to think that the answer to that question is largely going to reside with parents and teachers and students working together.
I think where communities are able to deal with the question of drugs and all the other related things that go along with poverty, I think that that’s going to have a profound impact on whether they’re successful or not during the course of my time.
I think how we introduce approximately 30,000 new teachers into the system during the decade of the 1990s is going to be important, because the district is dark and different these days than it was 30 years ago.
And so the means by which we can bring minority teachers into the system so there will be some reflection of our presence in the system would be very important-all on the basis of quality, not color.
Precious: Is there a multicultural curriculum in the public schools? What is it and how is it being carried out?
Green: One of our major goals has been to produce the finest multicultural, multiethnic curriculum that’s available for any school system in America… In order to make the system whole, I believe that bilingual education ought not to be seen as additive-that it ought to be seen as essential in the educational process.
Our view is that Black History Month, Black History Day, or Martin Luther King’s Birthday ought to be essential and not some additive moment.
In May we’re bringing all the textbook publishers into a conference to talk to them about producing materials which is more reflective of the world population.
Precious: For the current students now, how can this be accomplished-let’s say a child who’s in the fifth grade.
Green: By the time that child is in junior high school we should be far along in producing the kind of materials that would accomplish the goals that I just described. I think we’re in sort of an 18 month to 24 month period of having the final product out there.
New Expulsion Policy
Fitzcarl: What will happen to students who are expelled under your new discipline plan?
Green: They’ll be thrown out of school. That’s what expulsion is.
Fitzcarl: I know. But their education-what will happen to that?
Green: They violated the rights to an education-that’s up to them to determine that. If they have the ability to violate the rights to an education by carrying a gun in school where you’re present, by assaulting a teacher in a school that has come to teach, by making that school unsafe, if they go in and they make the choice of acting in that way, they have lost their right to an education. So their responsibility for getting that education is going to have to come at another time. That’s what the word expulsion is all about.
Fitzcarl: At what time?
Green: That’s up to them…
Fitzcarl: They just go on and out of there and that’s it?
Green: You got it. That’s what the word `expulsion’ means. That’s what the policy is all about.
Fitzcarl: Do they disappear?
Green: I have no idea what they do. I put my time into people that are in school, not people that carry weapons to school.
Fitzcarl: What is the mayor [going to do] since they’re going to be out on the street, either doing nothing or doing what they’vedone in school to get expelled? I mean you’re adding [to a problem].
Green: No. No, your question starts with the wrong assumption. I did not create the right to bring a gun into a school.
Fitzcarl: I know.
Green: Well that’s the origin of the creation [of the plan.]
Fitzcarl: I’m saying you’re adding to a problem.
Green: No, I’m not adding to a problem. I’m suggesting that you’re a higher priority, that schools have to be safe, that your parents who send you to school have a right to expect that I will act in responsible ways towards their child.
Fitzcarl: What about the areas around the school-the community where these people live?
Green: What about them?
Fitzcarl: Well, they’re still in their community. They haven’t disappeared at all.
Green: You better talk to them and others. I’m responsible for the schools. I’m responsible for the places of learning. I’m not responsible for the things that happen down the street.
Fitzcarl: Well, I just wanted to know if there’s some-
Green: I don’t want any confusion in your mind about this one, because I’m your custodian. I’m the one that’s responsible for you.
Fitzcarl: Well, I really just-
Green: That’s a new poster-just came out today. There’s a new curriculum that goes with it. I mean, did you read the title there?
Fitzcarl: `don’t risk your education.’
Green: You’re risking your education when you carry a gun or a weapon or assault someone that comes to instruct in the New York schools.
Fitzcarl: There’s still a problem, though. That’s what I’m pointing out. There’s still a problem.
Green: I wouldn’t say the problem is solved. I didn’t say the original problem was solved. I said I have an obligation that at the door of the school-that it’s my time, it’s my game that I’m playing in this town right now. And when you play my game you cannot walk into school with a weapon. It’s just not much of a debate.
Involving Parents
Lester: What steps are you taking to increase parent involvement?
Green: Well, we are just about to name a person to head a parent’s
desk for the first time in the chancellor’s office.
My anticipation is that the school parent desk will have a staff that will make parents recognize that they have a role to play in the various boroughs. The intent would be to bring parents into the schools K to 12 and make them feel like they’re partners in schools…
Hopefully their presence in school will help deter some of the discussion that we had a few moments ago because that’s what parent power is all about-helping to set the climate of the school.
Lester: Do you have any problems increasing parent involvement? I know some parents’ [situation] is `I’ve got to work…’
Green: I understand. I would prefer to call it a challenge rather than problems. After all, one out of two young people that come to the New York public schools today, come from single-parent families. A majority of those families are [headed by] females.
Lester: How do you get that parent to get to the school?
Green: When you say how do’I,’ it’s how do’we.’ And the way that we do it is call them and invite them to the school. Some teachers at the start of the school year call parents and say, `Welcome to the school, when are you going to visit?’ Some principals write newsletters. Some parents have led parent groups that spend some time targeting the various communities.
Pressures As Black Chancellor
Joi: What particular pressures have you faced as the first Black chancellor?
Green: Well, I’m the first chancellor that happens to be Black. I think you need to keep in mind the word `chancellor’ has been around. Pressures? I suspect when you come from outside the city you are going to be put to unusual tests about leadership.
When change takes place there’s a certain amount of people that feel threatened by that change. And consequently [they] say the chancellor’s only going to be here for six months or he’s only going to be here for nine months…And the more the story gets repeated, the more it becomes believable.
There’s always going to be, I suspect, in America a challenge for individuals on the basis of color to some extent. So it didn’t matter if I’d come to New York or wherever.
I really haven’t felt, on a personal level, that I haven’t had a lot of support from the people I’ve had contact with. And, of course, you can’t-I’ve never tried to manage the information that turns out to be misinformation and that drives other people’s instincts. I could spend all of my time, a lot of my time, with misinformation. I choose not to.
Joi: Do you think the press has been fair to you overall?
Green: It isn’t just the press. I don’t think the press is the issue. I don’t recall in my comment to you that I mentioned the word `press.’ That was the word you mentioned.
Joi: Right, I just wondered because you didn’t mention it.
Green: I didn’t. No, because I don’t consider that to be a major issue. They’re going to print what they print. I have no control over them. I don’t try to shape it.
I strongly support a free and open press in this country. I don’t think the country would be, or the city would be what it could be without a free and open press. So as a public figure you’re always going to be to some degree vulnerable in a society.
If you believe highly in the notion of a free and open press, then you have to go along with that process some of it being misinformation and some of it being misplaced information. And there’s very little I can do about it. And I’m not about to write a letter to the editor every time they get it wrong.
Metal Detector Program
Eric: Has the metal detector program made any progress, and how much would it cost to put metal detectors in all our schools?
Green: I don’t know what it would cost. It’s been a very successful program. I don’t know how you have felt about it…
When I first proposed that teachers could not be assaulted, guns were not acceptable, and I said I wanted to expel students, I was told I couldn’t expel students under 17 by state law in New York State…In other communities across the country, students who would carry weapons could be expelled at a much earlier age.
So we pushed ahead with the metal detectors.
The students have been very good. I’ve come to find out in talking to students, they’vebeen to discos, they’vebeen to other places where on occasion they’vehad to deal with the whole issue of metal detectors. So they are probably ahead of the adult population [which is] running around saying kids aren’t going to like this, etc., etc.
The second issue was that students want to be safe in their schools. Unless they got used to the metal detectors being there-they said, `If it means that I walk through these metal detectors and so does everybody else, but the guns can’t walk through, then I’m in favor…’
Eric: Does the money come from other programs?
Green: The money comes out of the same budget…
Eric: That’s a lot of money to install the systems.
Green: I would say prevention of death-there’s no amount of money I could push that up to. So I’m sorry. I don’t follow your logic in your question. If you’re asking do we have to make priorities, there’s not a bottomless pit of money that you can reach down into. So something’s not being done in order to put those metal detectors in school, and that’s a choice that was made.
I’d be glad to tell you where that money came from this year, but I don’t have that data right in front of me right now. And I’ll be glad to tell you where it comes from next year. But the other things [are] not going to be done because I have to guarantee safe schools. And I don’t mind telling the public we’re not going to have swimming, if that’s a good example, in your school in order to have metal detectors.
Fitzcarl: How come the chancellor position isn’t that well known among students?
Joi: What can we as students do to get to know your office better, and how can you help us do that?
Green: Well, I have no idea. But I don’t agree with your analysis that the job’s not well known. Everywhere I go people…
Fitzcarl: I’m talking about students.
Green: I’m talking about students. I’m not talking about adults. I’m talking about students. Everywhere I go, there are very few times that I go around New York City where students are, that they don’t know about Richard Green, the chancellor of New York City schools, and I…
Fitzcarl: I don’t mean your name. I mean the job-what you exactly do.
Green: I don’t know how to educate students about what the job of chancellor is. That’s something that would have to depend upon principals and teachers to do-if they found that of value.
In some respects the exposure of the media has given me a fairly high profile in the household.
Fitzcarl: Household word?
Green: Yeah, so who’s next?
Treatment By Press
Precious: What can be done to make you a better known person, because the press that you get is not always positive, and just sitting here I’m starting to get the impression they’re not fair to you.
Green: There’s not much I can do about that. Students can come and get their own impressions. I made it clear very early on I didn’t intend to manage the New York schools and their decisions to the press. And I was hoping that people would report the news rather than create the news…
There’s not much I can do about it. I still don’t believe you can successfully manage an organization, a $6.4 billion organization, whether it’s government or private or public, to the media. I just don’t believe that’s the way to do it. I won’t pass judgment on it. I still have my original views 13 months later. This is my 14th month.
In terms of students, I’d love to do these kind of interviews with you from time to time so you can have your own impressions.
Eric: One quick question, Why was that press conference [on March 14, with high school newspapers] so short?
Green: Two hours is not short.
Eric: Two hours?
Green: That’s not short for me.
Eric: And only about half of the students got to ask their questions.
Green: Well, I didn’t organize it.
Eric: Did you think it was fair?
Green: Yes, absolutely. I don’t think everybody gets a chance to ask their questions in a general body the size of that body. If you’d been in bodies like that I don’t think you would ask that kind of question.
Number two: I know classrooms where I’m sure in the context of an hour or 45 minute classroom, not every student’s question gets answered.
And number three: you had a pretty highly well informed group of students. And you have to take time talking with those people. So those aren’t going to be 30 second, 10 second answers…
And I was willing to come back as I indicated to you.
Eric: So you do have plans to have more press conferences?
Green: It’s up to the students. I don’t know who set this meeting up. Who set this meeting up?
[Editor’s Note: We told him we’d been trying through letters and phone calls to schedule this interview since he entered the office.]
Green: So does that tell you something about my schedule?
Fitzcarl: Would you encourage letters from students?
Green: Sure, I get tons of mail from students.
Fitzcarl: So that influences your decisions?
Green: No, I never made that kind of commitment. That’s not how I manage the system.
Fitzcarl: If something was mentioned, would you check up on it-[something] deviant?
Green: In terms of mail that comes from students and parents and others-if it’s something that they’re charging happened in the school, we have to send someone out generally to call in and check that out. If a teacher’s alleging something’s happening to them, we have to send it to a specific party to get that checked out. So the answer is yeah-mail is a big part of this job. Communication is a big part of this job…

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.