Police: Friend or Foe?

There are 7 million stories in the naked city, but one of the most common is about cops harassing young people.
Many teens feel they have been treated unfairly by the law, which makes them view the police department as corrupt.
Maira Rivera, 18, told of how she and her boyfriend were suspected of being drug dealers because they were hanging out in a park three days in a row.
“All of a sudden… they [the cops] began searching the area where we had just been sitting. I asked the officer what happened, but the other officer came out snotty and said, `Look, cut the crap before you get slapped.”
She continued: “They asked me to empty my purse. I cooperated fully without hesitation. I finally realized the cops thought we were drug dealers. I heard one of the cops say as he pointed to a strange man,’There goes their manager.’ Then he turned to us and asked,’What have you been coming here three straight days in a row for with that same man watching you?'”
She told the cop they had never seen the man until that day, and when the cops didn’t find anything on them or in the area, they let them go.
Racial and Sexual Abuse
Many teens feel that some of the abuse teens receive from cops is racially or sexually motivated.
“Most cops overemphasize most situations, especially if there are Blacks and Puerto Ricans involved. They do it because they’re White and they have power. It’s an abuse of authority,” Tye, 19, said.
“I feel that automatically when a cop gets his badge, he goes crazy, especially on Black and Hispanic youths,” said George of Brooklyn Technical.
Angela, 18, told me how she was arrested for chasing a guy who stole her bag in a train station. A male cop tried to search her but she wouldn’t let him.
“See, this guy had snatched my bag while I was going into the train station, so I ran through the gate and chased him up the stairs.
“Then this male cop chased me. I almost caught up to this guy when the cop grabbed me by the arm, and let the guy who really committed the crime get away,” she said.
Angela continued: “The cop tried to search me, but I told him he couldn’t search a girl, so he arrested me.
“When I got to the precinct, I called my aunt… he [the cop] had booked me and put me in a cell by the time my aunt came and got me out. He gave me a fine but I beat it [in court] because they found my bag two train stops from where it had been stolen.”
Cops Seen As Too Rough
Angela felt the cop was too rough while arresting her and that he was not justified to do so, which is a common compliant of many teens about police.
She said, “Cops take out their frustrations on everybody, especially teens because we are supposed to be the rebels. I don’t know about most cops, but when this cop arrested me, he was definitely too rough.”
George, who was once arrested, said, “Yeah, I feel they are too rough, because they don’t have to put the cuffs on so tight… Exercising roughness is the cops’ trait, they want to put fear in our hearts.”
Tye said, “Yes, they are too rough because they feel they have to stress the seriousness of the situation. It’s taught to them by the department for that purpose.”
Ricardo Guzman, 15, told me how he was almost physically abused by two detectives.
He said, “Two undercover cops came up to me while I was waiting for my father outside of his friend’s store. I was dressed nice and in an all-Black area; I’m Puerto Rican. One of the cops was waving a steel flashlight at me… they told me in a very rude way to get off the streets, but I didn’t listen.
“My father came out of the store and started talking to them in a bad manner … and they left,” he continued. “You see, I’m Puerto Rican. If I were White driving an I-Rock Z, those cops would have never said nothing to me.”
Suspected of Drug Dealing
It seems as though cops think that all Blacks and Hispanics are drug dealers, which may be the reason why so many more Blacks and Hispanics are arrested.
Crystal, 18, of Columbus HS, was suspected of being a drug dealer because she was using a pay phone.
“It was summer and I was out of school. My telephone wasn’t working, so I went to the corner to call A.T.& T. to come fix the phone. As I was talking to the operator, this police van pulled up and ordered everybody not to move through his bullhorn.
“Then this big, White, male cop came up to me and grabbed the phone. He started yelling to me that they sell crack on this corner and what was I doing here, and who was I talking to.
“I explained to him that I didn’t know it was a drug spot and I was just trying to get the phone company to come fix my mother’s phone.
“The cop spoke to the lady on the phone, then he hung up. I don’t know why, but he tried to frisk me. I told him that unless he was going to hold me until a female cop came, I was going home. As I walked away the cop yelled out, `If I ever catch you on this corner again I’ll break your head.’ I just looked back at him and laughed.”
Cops are trained to act rather than to react. They often must make a quick decision, like “shoot now and ask questions later.” In their haste, they pick up innocent bystanders or act abusively and are therefore looked upon as harassing.
Can There Be Trust?
So who’s to blame? How can cops and teens learn to trust each other more? I asked this question and the responses were varied, yet they all seemed to reflect the fact that there is a serious problem.
George feels that teens overreact: “The reason teens are so frequently arrested is because when a cop touches them, they get hype and yell,’Get the f— off me man,’ and this makes the cops hyper too.”
“I sympathize with the teens, but why should I sympathize with the cop, because they’re not the ones going to jail,” was Tye’s response.
Angela said, “I kinda sympathize with both of us, because we judge each other too quickly. The cops have to remember that teens are people and the teens have to realize that cops are people.”

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.