I Never Thought He Would Try to Kill Me

I’ve published personal pieces before about the trials and turbulence of teenagehood, but I never thought I’d write a story with this title and hide bed an anonymous byline because of what follows. And I certainly never expected the “he” would be Lewis, my boyfriend of 13 months.
If anyone told me that Lewis would transform my eager anticipation of turning 18 and beginning college into a nightmare of brain damage and agony, I would have said, “You’re crazy.”
That’s the same thing I said to my friends who met Lewis and told me to be careful because there was “something strange about him.” They said he was too quiet, and seemed jealous of me.
I resented and ignored these comments. Lots of people told me I was very mature and perceptive for my age and I liked to believe it. If there was something wrong with him, I’d definitely see it.
So I asked those “Dear Abbey” friends of mine to mind their own business. Fortunately, when these same people came to visit me in the hospital not one of them said aloud the ‘I told you so’s” that seemed to fill their eyes.
Attacked With a Baseball Bat
Our fight took place on a deceptively beautiful day in early May. We got into an argument in part over sex and in part over nonsense. Before I knew what was happening, Lewis threw me on the couch and hovered over me with a baseball bat.
All I could do was plead “Stop! Stop!” as the heavy wood smashed my skull. I couldn’t believe he was doing this since he never came close hitting me before.
The image of him standing over me with a cold stare as I on the floor with blood rushing out of my head, and hands raised to get him to help me, will forever be tattooed in my memory.
When I awoke in the hospital four days later, doctors stood over me trying to see if I was as brain damaged as they predicted. I couldn’t talk, but I managed to write “Am I okay?”
My comatose daze didn’t e me further humiliation. Every serious head injury patient has to go through a battery of psychiatric tests to determine if the injury caused certain problems. I can’t capture in words how I felt when the hospital psychiatrist asked me if I actually “enjoyed” the beating.
Or when two friends walked into my room as mashed potatoes slid out of my mouth because I could barely swallow.
Treated Like a Criminal
But nothing could match the police visits which left me feeling like a criminal. Only hours after I came out of the coma, the police made me describe (in writing since I was temporally mute) the extent of our sexual relationship in near graphic detail, since our argument was caused in part by sex.
I just wanted to go home. There I was at the doorstep of my 18th birthday and people were treating me like a physical and emotional invalid.
I came home to discover that the police suspected Lewis was a drug user because of “strange” messages he left on my answering machine. We had a lot of stupid private jokes that might seem “druggish” to the serious listener.
But why should I have to explain that to anyone? And how did they find out, anyway? I soon discovered that, thanks to the police and gossip, almost everyone knew my boyfriend used my head for batting practice.
To this day, that’s the first thing some people bring up when they see me. Ms. Goody Two Shoes became Ms. “Jennifer Levin.”
My speech was seriously impaired. To escape, I became obsessed with my therapy exercises and tried every trick in the book to get my paralyzed tongue to move.
But I just couldn’t escape, the concerned and the nosy who wanted to know more. I kept on hearing how good I looked-“considering.” I think a few people were slightly disappointed that my head wasn’t bandaged or shaved and my hair did a pretty good job of covering the scars.
People wanted to know if I was going to press full charges or even drop them in lieu of intense psychiatric care for Lewis and a court order that he forever stay far away from me.
A Suicide
I never got the chance to decide.
On June 1, a detective called to tell me that they found Lewis-but he was dead. They found him floating off a pier a mile away from his house in Brooklyn.
I was falsely given the impression that he killed himself out of remorse. That impression did more damage to me than the baseball bat. I’ll get to that later.
For a while it appeared the attack would only bring a minor hearing loss and temporarily impaired speech. But in late June, I took the English Regents and bombed on it. The little writing I did was forced and poor by my standards. And ever since I came out of the coma, thinking clearly was a struggle.
In July I went to a neuro-psychologist who put me through grueling but extensive testing. She determined the blows to the head caused a language agnosia (a serious language impairment) and some cognitive dysfunction (a blockage of thought processes.) I was also suffering from a case of something called receptive aphasia (a lesion in the brain that causes a communication problem.)
She referred me to another neuro-psychologist and began hinting that I start thinking of other careers besides journalism and professional writing.
Since the fifth grade, becoming a writer had been an obsessive dream and now a doctor was telling me I may never be able to realize that dream.
Even if I could express the kind of devastation I felt, I wouldn’t-it’s just too painful. It was the kind of pain I’m battling right now as I sit at this computer trying to say things, but settling for inferior ways of saying them.
In September I started college against the neuro-psychologist’s advice in the hope of proving her wrong.
I put up a fierce struggle to wade through my studies while putting on a phony smile and personality to get by socially. I even made some new friends.
Guilt and Self-Punishment
But I was breaking down emotionally and guilt made it difficult to keep the feelings in check.
All I could think of was that Lewis would be alive if I gave into the sexual stuff. The argument was engraved in my head and I knew I could have stopped it. I kept thinking of how a detective told me that Lewis’s aunt had said “he punished himself” in commenting on his suicide.
I refused to do the exercises the neuro-psychologist said were crucial if I wanted to start thinking better. I didn’t think I had a right to get better.
To punish myself, I quit a part time job I loved. I even went out to Lewis’ grave a few times to say “I’m sorry.”
My father was getting pretty worried. In October, he called the private investigator who was searching for Lewis almost from the start and asked him to tell me everything he knew.
In my three hour visit to his office, I learned more about Lewis’s past then I knew about my own. Two weeks after Lewis was buried, the P.I. had phone conversations with Lewis’s mother and uncle, under false pretexts. He also read the police psychology report on Lewis’s suicide and the Medical Examiner’s report.
First of all, Lewis didn’t kill himself the night he attacked me. Someone in his family was hiding him for weeks and, for a complicated reason, it’s even possible most of his family didn’t know about it. The most incredible piece of evidence the P.I. had was that Lewis went bowling while I was in the hospital with black eyes!
This was all backed up by the medical report which estimated he was dead for only around four days when he was found, four weeks after the attack.
And it seems that he didn’t kill himself only because of what he did to me. The police psychology report listed him as suicidal for a long time His mental health had been withering away since his father’s death in ’85 and he had a lot of problems I never knew about.
And he got into a vicious verbal fight with his mother two days before he beat me-he probably did to me what he wanted to do to her. I could go on and on.
Not One Phone Call
“Then why,” I asked the P.I., “couldn’t someone, anyone from his family say, ‘He was very unstable for a long time and had a lot of emotional problems you didn’t know about. The details are private and it’s too difficult to speak to you. Please understand. Goodbye.’ “
After all, I was given the impression that he was fine until he attacked me. Those words or something similar would have made a world of difference and speeded my recovery.
“Why couldn’t someone say that-why?”
The P.I. just shook his head and got really annoyed.
“When are you going to realize that to Lewis’s family you were nothing more than a piece of ass he spent his weekends with? They wouldn’t have given a damn if he killed you. They don’t remember your name and probably think Lewis smashed your skull in self-defense.”
A piece of ass he spent his weekends with. Even though the P.I.’s words were very harsh, they were probably very true.
His aunt was nastier than the flu as she denied me permission to attend Lewis’s funeral. And his older sister refused to speak to me when I called to express my condolences since she was one of the few relatives Lewis ever claimed to care about.
No one ever expressed any remorse for what their flesh and blood did to his girlfriend and no one was willing to talk to me for three minutes, like I very much wanted. And of course, no one had the morality to call just once to see if I even was recovering.
I was stupid enough to take that to mean I was being “blamed” for what happened. But they were just cold and low class people who didn’t give a damn.
A Transforming Anger
Suddenly, my anchor of guilt dropped and a victim’s anger set in. I didn’t deserve to be smashed in the head and I didn’t deserve to feel guilty. I was a victim and I received no justice. I needed to feel that anger so it could be transformed into a determination to get better.
I’m determined to prove the neuro-psychologist wrong and overcome those brain defects the way I overcame my speech impediment. I’m speaking normally now and I believe I’ll regain the writing and thinking abilities I’m supposed to have lost and will become a stronger person for it.
I won’t let the sickness of one person destroy my future. You shouldn’t either if you’ve been the victim of a vicious crime.
Believe it or not, I’m still sorry that Lewis is dead even though a bulldozer couldn’t drag me to his grave again. He never would have beat me if he had gotten help for his problems and he’d still be alive if he turned himself in after the attack. It’s really a shame-he had a lot going for him and he had just turned 21.
I’ve lost a lot of self respect. I was used and I don’t think Lewis was capable of loving me or anyone else.
I realize I wasn’t the very mature and perceptive person people said I was. I was just some naive teen whose poor judgment nearly cost her her life. Even though they were vague, Lewis gave me signals and warnings that I just ignored.
I don’t know when or if I’ll ever be able to trust my judgment again.
What happened to me had a one in a million chance of happening. And that guy you’re dating right now is probably just as wonderful as you think he is. But keep your ears open and listen, really listen to what, people have to say.
And pay attention to cues and warnings which show unstable behavior. If I had, I wouldn’t have spent my graduation day in a neurologist’s office.
Remember, you’ll probably never go through something like this. But pay attention. One in a million is one too many.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.