A Special Ed Student Shares Her Hopes and Fears

Do any of you know what it’s like to be a special ed student? Most people do not-and that includes me.
Clara Rodriguez, a student at Livingston High School (a special ed school in Manhattan), spoke to me about her experiences-how her friends treat her, what her school is like, and her hopes and fears.
Here is what she had to say.
Special ed? It’s not bad. You’re still getting a high school diploma, but not from a regular high school. I like it because some of the people here, the teachers, are good. Some of the kids here don’t know when to ask for help, but deep down inside they want it.
“I guess sometimes being in special ed does bother me, because at times I’ll be sitting around with my friends and they would be like, `What school do you go to?’ I always say I go to school, just a school, ’cause I’m not gonna lie and tell them I go to Brandeis or something. But after a while, even though it’s embarrassing, I usually tell them,’Well, alright, I’m in a 600 school, so what?’ They’re like,’Yeah, how is it?’ They start asking you all sorts of questions.
“But the kids in Livingston are OK. They are not as rowdy as I thought they would be. In the beginning, when I first came to special ed, I was like `Oh, my God, I’m gonna get beat up.’ But when I got here it was a whole different picture.
‘People Put Us Down’
“A lot of people put down special ed students. I don’t think it’s fair to put down someone just because you have a learning disability or a behavioral problem.
“Just because I’m in special ed doesn’t mean I don’t want a career like regular students. I want to go for my Ph.D. I think I’d like to major in communications, probably social communications. I either want to go to Boston University or BMCC. I remember Harvard used to be my dream school, but . . . .
“The one special thing about Livingston is that we’re all like a family. We all love each other. Yeah, we’re all teenagers and we fight, but it’s just play fighting.
“We treat each other like brothers and sisters. A lot of us don’t have brothers and sisters to go home to. Like me, I don’t live with my sister, so who do I have to fight with or talk with?
“Everyone is special and that includes special ed students, because everybody has something inside of them that makes them shine out.
“Like me, I have a special love for flowers and the stars. Every time I pass by a flower shop I like watching the flowers and how beautiful they are because flowers are so delicate.
“And I love the stars. I live by FDR Drive and I love to just sit down and talk to the stars. I got that from my sister.
A Love of Reading
“I did go to some regular schools and they had more programs and more classrooms and they had animals in the labs. In this school we don’t have a library and that is a great need for a school. Yes, special ed kids read, too.
“OK, we’re not the most intelligent or sophisticated people, but we like the same things just like everyone else. I know some of the girls in this school like to read love stories; all girls do. The boys like to read football books, weight training books, and karate.
“Me, I love reading 16th century novels. You know, Queen Elizabeth and her courts. When I read them I feel far away. It takes me out of all the stuff around my neighborhood.
“I feel like I’m in Queen Elizabeth’s court. I’m talking about ladies-in-waiting and that kind of stuff. Oh, you hafta read it. I mean you feel some kind of magic when you read it. It’s the best thing I’ve ever read.
“I never really liked school because there were all these cliques. I never fit into any of those cliques. I was always in the middle. But I’m really accepted in this school. Everybody is accepted. Nobody is ever treated badly.
“I don’t like those `dictatorships’ in other schools. You know-sometimes certain students want to run the school. They want everybody to listen to them. I mean, everybody craves attention, but that’s not fair. Here at Livingston we’re all in the same predicament, so it’s different.
‘Teachers Are Creative’
“We learn a lot in special ed. You know, it’s like the teacher is more creative than a regular teacher.
“Like in a regular English class you come in and copy what’s on the board and then the teacher talks about it, but she keeps it strictly English.
“In this school you sit down and if there’s anything on the board you copy it down and somehow the teacher finds some activity that makes you learn without even knowing it. It’s not like, `Damn, I gotta get out of this class.’ I learn a lot and it’s fun.
“You know, sometimes I get embarrassed when I’m walkin’ down the street and a lot of times people will be like, `don’t I know you?’ I’ll be like, `From where?’ And they’ll yell out where I’m from out in the street. And I’ll be so embarrassed’cause they will be looking at me.
“But you know, what I’m not embarrassed to say is that Livingston has never been in the paper for something really bad. What about the regular high schools? You don’t see Livingston in the newspaper for having weapons or anything like that. And I’m proud to say that nobody here deals drugs.
“Not enough good stuff is said about Livingston and special ed. We should have an open house and kids from all over the city could come in and look at the school and see our role-model students.
“There’s no real big difference between regular students and special ed students. We all talk about the same things. I also want to point out that not all special ed students are crackheads, steal cars or commit crimes, and we’re not stupid. we’re just the same as other kids.
“Some people are like, `Well, these are special kids, they dumped them in a special ed school.’ So what do they care if anything happens to them?
No Sports, No Prom
“The regular high schools have things that special ed schools don’t and it’s not fair. They have cheerleaders and football teams and basketball teams and a lot of afterschool programs, like trips, and we don’t have a prom.
“And what happened to class rings? The least we could do is buy a class ring so that we could show our friends and our kids that we graduated from high school.
“We don’t even have a student council. And why can’t we have teams that could give the students something to come to school for and say,’Hey, I’m going to school today and try out for the basketball team or the football team?’ I think it would raise the attendance.
“And we could have after school gym classes; gymnastics would be nice.
“The Board of Education should give special ed more money because we don’t get as much money as the regular high schools. There’s so much we could have.
“At least they should give special ed students the power to choose what high school they want to go to. You know, I never knew about the other special ed high schools. we’re not informed of anything. We only know the one around our area.
“What I really want people to know is they should treat special ed students like regular students. Why should you be prejudiced toward somebody because they’re in special ed? That person that you called stupid could turn out be a doctor. You should think twice before speaking once.”

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.