“The police are even worse than the criminals,” says Godfrey, 18, a student at Lafayette HS who watched a police officer use unnecessary force to arrest his cousin.
Police: A department of the government charged with enforcing law and order, with respect to the prevention, detection, and prosecution of public nuisances and crimes.
Brutality: A state of being brutal. Unnecessary force inflicting pain or injury.
Combine the two and you have police brutality. Is this a problem in New York City? Is unnecessary force ever justified?
“Police brutality is a very big problem in New York,” said Roger Wareham, project associate at the CUNY Center for Law and Social Justice. “It is not as big a problem as racism, but it’s just as strong.”
Perception of Brutality
“Police brutality is a problem for us because the perception the people get is that all police officers are bad, which is not true,” states Lt. Harvey Wyche, administrative lieutenant in the office of the Deputy Commissioner, Community Affairs. “Because of this perception, there is a problem.”
“There is this sort of’Dodge City’ attitude the police seem to have,” says Wareham. “They don’t deal with the welfare of the community. The attitudes of the police do not let them see people as human beings.”
“When a police officer is arresting a suspect, he or she is supposed to be professional about it,” Lt. Wyche said. “If the suspect does resist, then they are to be treated calmly, not thrown up against the wall.”
Is this true? Within the last three months there have been several incidents reported in which the police may have used excessive force.
Last March 18, a 20-year-old Manhattan man who jumped a subway turnstile was shot in the back by a Transit Authority police officer.
On March 24, a man who had held his mother hostage for several hours in Far Rockaway, Queens, and then set their apartment on fire, was killed after he advanced on police officers with a rifle.
Was it necessary to kill him? Could the police have taken him alive? These are the questions many people have asked, including the man’s mother.
“Unnecessary force is never justified, because force shouldn’t be used when it isn’t necessary,” said Lt. Wyche. “It’s the policy of the police department that we aren’t brutal to people.
“In reality, I know that there are individual incidents of brutality by police officers, but these isolated incidents do not mean we let these police officers do it. A cop does this on his own,” without department approval, Wyche continued.
“Police brutality does exist,” says Chantale, 18, from Westinghouse HS. “I should know-my brother was once involved in an incident with a policeman.”
Punched in the Face
He was not the only one. I found two other young people who had had similar terrifying experiences.
Carl Weston, 21, says he was a victim of police brutality in two cases. One incident was when he and a friend were caught writing graffiti on a subway train. He says a cop approached him and said, “What do you think this is, some kind of f—–g joke?,” slapped him in the face, and pushed him down into a seat. He was then arrested.
A second incident occurred a few days later when he was caught again writing on a subway train. This time, he says, a police officer took him into a subway bathroom and kept hitting him in the face.
“He kept slapping me on my face, saying,’You’re gonna let a little cop like me slap you around?'” says Carl. “I asked him if he was gonna arrest me and he said no.”
Rob Wade, 21, says he was also a victim of police brutality. This incident took place one night when, he says, he and his friends were just walking around 42nd St. and they laughed at a homeless man whose shopping cart was knocked over. He says a police officer saw this and grabbed one of his friends and threw him against a storm gate, and said, “Do you think that was funny?”
He says the officer then tried to put handcuffs on the guy, but he pushed and began to run. The officer then pursued him and called for backup. Rob says the cop caught the guy, beat him down, and arrested him. Then, he says, the cops asked Rob and his friends if they wanted some, too, and began to beat them down.
They were all arrested for disturbing the peace and then quickly released at the police station. Unfortunately, these incidents were never reported.
‘They’ll Still Get Away With It’
“It really doesn’t matter whether or not you report a cop that has beat on you, because he will still get away with it,” said Markus, 17, from Fort Hamilton HS.
“Most incidents do not get reported, but if one did, the officer would get indicted, [and if the charge were proven], convicted, suspended, or just lose his or her job,” Wareham said. “Usually the sentence is pretty light.”
“A lot of people who have been victims of a police officer using unnecessary force are scared to report them,” says Lt. Wyche. “The C.C.R.B. [Civilian Complaint Review Board] is a place that can help them.”
The C.C.R.B. investigates incidents involving police brutality. If a police officer is found guilty, they will either suspend him, fine him, dismiss him, or arrest him like any other suspect.
“There is a perception in low economic areas where people do believe that the police are no good,” Lt. Wyche says. “In reality, there is no proof that this is true, just isolated incidents of police brutality.”
Is there tension between teenagers and the police?
“Sort of. I know I feel sort of threatened when I see a cop,” says Latoya, 17, from Murry Bergtraum HS. “The badge gives them the power to do anything they want.”
“Yeah, I think so. Sometimes I’m afraid to approach a cop for help, like directions or just the time,” said Harold, 16, from Aviation HS.
“I don’t really think there’s tension, but I do know teenagers tend to keep distant from the police,” said Tiffany, 16, from Lafayette HS.
Tension on Both Sides
“Yes, there is tension on both sides,” says Wareham. “Teens know about the police, but they don’t know their rights. Teens don’t have to tell them anything-just basic information like their name, address, and phone number.”
“This is the same as asking,’Is there tension between Whites and Blacks?'” said Lt. Wyche. “Some Whites may say all Blacks are thieves. They are only highlighting the bad ones, because not all Blacks steal.”
Police brutality is a problem. It may be caused by a racist cop, an angry cop, or a cop who wants to show who has the power. So, if there’s a problem, is there a solution?
“People should get organized. People should have some idea of what their rights are,” Wareham said. “If a kid knows more about the police, they won’t have trouble. It’s easy for [the police] to mess with someone who knows less.”
“Instead of avoiding trouble with a police officer, people try to run away or curse at an officer,” says Lt. Wyche. “This may result in police brutality. This would probably never happen if the suspect shows respect.”
Police Brutality: Is It the Officer or the Badge?
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.