The SAT: What Does It Test?

A lot of juniors and seniors are living in constant fear of the Scholastic Aptitude Test (SAT). They hear that a low score will prevent them from winning scholarships and getting into a good college, therefore preventing them from having successful careers in the future.
It could be worse. Many students are uninformed about the SAT until a few weeks before they have to take it, leaving them no time to prepare for a test that determines their futures.
What Does it Test?
But why should students have to go through the agony of either of those situations? What do colleges need the SAT for, anyway? What does the test show about a student?
Nancie Koenigsberg, a 17-year-old student at Edward R. Murrow HS, gives her opinion:
“The SAT doesn’t measure how much you’ve learned. It measures your ability to analyze the questions and come up with the answer they want you to come up with-or rather, the answer they don’t want you to come up with, because they’re trying to trick you.”
According to Anne Grosso of the College Board, which administers the test, it measures “developed verbal and mathematical reasoning skills which a student will have to make use of in college.”
But Mike Friedman of FairTest, the National Center for Fair and Open Testing, says, “It measures your ability to take a test, and not a whole lot more. It doesn’t show what it claims it can show.”
The College Board started giving the SAT in 1926. According to Anne Grosso, “It was developed in order to create some fairness in the college admissions process. It is a standard-the same for all students.”
FairTest says that the SAT has done just the opposite. This organization was formed two years ago to expose what they feel is unfair about the SAT and other standardized tests. They publish a quarterly newsletter and conduct research.
Is It Fair?
When asked about unfairness, Mike Friedman said, “Research shows that Blacks score lower than Whites, the poor score lower than the rich, [and] women score lower than men.
“Last year, women scored 61 points below men, but on average, women have better high school and college grades than men,” he added.
FairTest says that if the test really showed what it was supposed to show, SAT scores would be consistent with college grades.
Anne Grosso says that the SAT “does not contain bias. What those score differences reflect is a difference in educational experience.”
But many students and others feel that the “difference in educational experience” de-scribed above is exactly what makes the SAT biased.
“People in regular public schools don’t learn what kids in Catholic schools do,” says Michelle Matthews, a 17-year-old at Lafayette HS. “Most kids don’t get an education that would teach them college-level words.”
But Jodi Brockington, 17, of Lafayette HS, disagrees. “I’m not sure if I believe the test is biased. I don’t think it makes a difference if you’re urban or rural, female or male, Black or White,” she says. “There’s always someone who won’t be the same [as the statistics].”
Even if the SAT itself is not biased, some students are opposed to the way that colleges use the SAT.
Anne Grosso of the College Board says, “There is a high correlation between scores and performance in college. Some colleges are using the SAT for placement purposes-which is legitimate.”
Michelle replies, “Why base it on one test? Suppose you get a 700 combined, but you’re excellent in history, for example. If they are going to predict my college history grades from a test, they don’t know me. I could have been sick or tired or had family problems.”
“Should Be Optional”
“The schools that took the SAT out of admissions, those are the smart colleges,” says Michelle.
Jodi agrees: “It’s good for someone who’s not doing well in school, but it shouldn’t be heavily weighted . . . It should be optional.”
Some colleges have stopped requiring SAT scores or changed the way they weigh the scores for men and women. Mike Friedman offers an explanation for this.
“I think it’s a combination of pressure from organizations like us and pressure from within. Bowdoin did it under pressure from their faculty,” he says.
Anne Grosso acknowledged that some colleges are placing less emphasis on the SAT, but added that “400 additional colleges have started using the SAT since 1977. The fact that there are so many shows that the SAT is providing colleges with useful information.”
But how can this information be considered valid when students can take preparatory courses to artificially raise theirscores? (That is, if they can afford to pay for the courses.)
Do Prep Classes Work?
Grosso says, “This is merely a claim that has not been substantiated. What research indicates is that the average increase is 25 points-which is what a student might get if they just took the test again [without preparation].”
Some students have raised their scores by as much as 200 points by taking such courses. On the other hand, there are students like James Earl Hardy, now in college, who says, “I got an 800 the first time I took it and a 1400 the second time, so I know that test doesn’t mean anything.”

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.